At both time steps, baseline retains inherited reference warnings for LV ยฑdP/dt, isovolumic contraction time (ICT), and Tei index. Measurement methods differ from the cited clinical methods. The raw pressure rises slowly for part of isovolumic contraction after mitral closure; ICT is about 89โ93 ms. This construction feature persists at the finer grid. Mitral flow E/A is about 0.93.
Adoption covers four fixed constructions of a new numerical model. The existing presentation/analysis methods and checkpoint codec are inherited. Standard73 in their identifiers does not imply an identical Standard73 numerical trajectory. This independent cold 2/1 ms qualification does not include a paired Standard73 control run. Candidate, compiled successor and source continuation agreement is verified separately.
Venous pressure is recovered from volume by bracketed safeguarded Newton iteration, falling back to bisection when the Newton step does not contract sufficiently. Defaults are 96 iterations, 10โปยนโฐ mL volume residual and 10โปยนโฐ mmHg bracket-width tolerances. Failure is explicit; an unverified pressure is not accepted. Out-of-domain volumes retain the constitutive pressure-bound saturation.
Displayed TBVโPV and Starling families are locally converged short-time fixed-control responses, not a claim of whole-system reservoir equilibrium. They differ from the reservoir-closure preload-response checks used for baseline admission.
Source populations and measurement conditions are distinct from this simulation. Raw records below retain their source language.
Case specification, sources and methods
{
"reference": {
"referenceId": "baseline",
"label": "baseline",
"target": {
"kind": "construction-corridors",
"evidenceRegistryId": "main-wire-normal-reference-evidence-v1",
"evaluationRolePolicyId": "main-wire-standard70-baseline-evaluation-roles-v3",
"admissionPolicyId": "main-wire-prospective-baseline-admission-v1",
"comparisonProfileId": "main-wire-resting-reference-profile-v1",
"referenceOutputsAreTargets": false
},
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"clinicalValidationClaimed": false
},
"methodId": "main-wire-baseline-observation-v2",
"assessmentPolicy": {
"policy": {
"policyId": "main-wire-prospective-baseline-admission-v1",
"scope": "Resting unassisted nonshunting sinus research construction, BSA1.9, HR60 or70, zero intrathoracic reference. Scientific eligibility for exact-model promotion, not public mint or clinical normality.",
"operating": [
{
"metricId": "systemic-net-flow.cardiac-index",
"lower": 2.5,
"upper": 4,
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"locator": "Table 11, CI",
"basis": "source-informed-operating-target"
},
{
"metricId": "central-venous-pressure.mean",
"lower": 2,
"upper": 6,
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"locator": "Table 11, mean RAP",
"basis": "source-informed-operating-target"
},
{
"metricId": "pulmonary-artery-pressure.mean",
"lower": 8,
"upper": 20,
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"locator": "Table 11, mean PAP",
"basis": "source-informed-operating-target"
},
{
"metricId": "aortic-pressure.maximum",
"lower": 90,
"upper": 140,
"sourceId": "herbert-2014-central-pressure-reference",
"locator": "Methods, invasive versus cuff-calibrated pressure distinction",
"basis": "retained-engineering-load-guard-NOT-source-derived-normal-range"
},
{
"metricId": "aortic-pressure.minimum",
"lower": 60,
"upper": 90,
"sourceId": "herbert-2014-central-pressure-reference",
"locator": "Methods, DBP calibration; no central-DBP reference interval",
"basis": "retained-engineering-load-guard-NOT-source-derived-normal-range"
},
{
"metricId": "left-ventricle.native-end-filling-pressure",
"lower": null,
"upper": 16,
"sourceId": "nagueh-2025-lv-diastolic-function",
"locator": "Section2, Table1 p539 (>16), Figure1 p540",
"basis": "source-informed-engineering-load-guard-NOT-method-matched-normal-range"
}
],
"loadGuardRationale": "Keep a baseline away from low/high systemic load and high native end-filling pressure. Ao bounds are retained design choices, not derived from Herbert. LV native flow cessation may precede the pressure upstroke; <=16 is an approximate end-filling design ceiling, not validated catheter LVEDP equivalence or a lower normal limit.",
"anatomyRule": "For this sex-unspecified generic baseline only, automatic eligibility requires all six valid anatomical CMR comparisons inside BOTH declared sex strata. Otherwise require demographic/method review, not automatic disease rejection. This conservative design intersection does not assign sex or claim joint population normality; preset/patient fitting must use its own profile.",
"warningRule": "Keep strict source comparisons for phasic PAP, ET, anatomy and SVI plus historical timing/E-A/dPdt/roundness context. A warning never excuses missing, nonfinite or invalid observations. Preserve unexplained ringing/closure-rebound construction holds; pressure-peak phase and PV roundness are not universal normality gates.",
"numericalAndConstructionProvenance": "Inherited numerical/gradient/ringing checks resolve their existing per-check evidence; new rest criteria do not reinterpret the old physiological corridors or clear the old provenance audit.",
"regression": "__tests__/mainWireProspectiveBaselineAdmissionV1.test.ts"
},
"evidence": {
"schemaVersion": 1,
"registryId": "main-wire-normal-reference-evidence-v1",
"evaluationPolicyId": "main-wire-standard70-baseline-evaluation-roles-v3",
"observationMethodId": "main-wire-baseline-observation-v2",
"sourceComparisonTiming": "retrospective-provenance-audit-not-original-cutoff-derivation",
"operatingTargetInterpretation": "Retained ET, pressures, indexed size, EF, CI and SVI are predeclared resting-baseline design targets. Failure means the intended operating point was not met, not physiological impossibility. Their source-specific observation limitations remain binding; no cross-modality universal normality is claimed.",
"referenceSubjectInterpretation": "BSA 1.9 m2 and sex-neutral synthetic anatomy do not identify age, sex or ethnicity. Conserved cavity blood volume is conceptually closer to anatomical segmentation excluding myocardial tissue from the blood pool than to smooth-contour volume that includes that tissue. This is an operator comparison, not a validated imaging-equivalence claim or permission to select the cohort that passes a candidate.",
"supplementalChecks": [
{
"checkId": "left-ventricle.relaxation-tau",
"observationMethodId": "main-wire-lv-relaxation-tau-v1",
"evaluationRole": "reference-warning",
"measurementMeaning": "Intracavitary LV Weiss zero-asymptote time-weighted log-pressure fit, from minimum dP/dt interval midpoint after AVC to next EDP + 5 mmHg before MVO; Glantz derivative-pressure free-asymptote sensitivity fit reported separately.",
"requiredObservation": "Prospective v3 baseline assessment must contain an interpretable tau observation; unavailable or poor fit is unresolved analysis, not normality and not a disease diagnosis.",
"referenceSourceIds": [
"nagueh-2025-lv-diastolic-function",
"hirota-1980-lv-relaxation"
],
"referenceUpperMs": 48,
"boundRationale": "ASE 2025 section 2/Table 1 calls >48 ms prolonged. Contextual warning only, no arbitrary normal lower bound and no transfer of that threshold to Glantz. Hirota reports 33 +/- 8 ms in 18 selected controls, using P0 / peak negative dP/dt, not this fitted observer; that cohort is not a normal interval.",
"qualityRationale": "Minimum window support and regression/residual limits are explicit provisional numerical fit-usability settings, not empirically established physiological limits. Both fits and the extrapolated Glantz pressure asymptote remain visible; neither may be selected for being closer to a target."
}
],
"claimScope": {
"currentBaselineEvidenceRole": "construction",
"finalConfirmationStatus": "unavailable",
"reason": "Standard68/69 gates, Standard69 preload-reserve floors, and candidate outputs were inspected during model construction; no lineage-disjoint final evidence set has been frozen."
},
"sources": [
{
"sourceId": "herbert-2014-central-pressure-reference",
"title": "Establishing reference values for central blood pressure and its amplification in a general healthy population and according to cardiovascular risk factors",
"year": 2014,
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1093/eurheartj/ehu293"
},
"verification": "primary-full-text-methods-and-results-checked",
"verificationScope": "Methods, Standardizing methodologies, and Tables 1-2 checked on 2026-09-07. Cuff-calibrated noninvasive cSBP differs from invasive intra-aortic pressure; Table 2 gives P10/P90, not 95% normal limits. Does not verify retained Ao-node bounds.",
"url": "https://academic.oup.com/eurheartj/article/35/44/3122/2293191"
},
{
"sourceId": "van-oort-1988-pulmonary-doppler",
"title": "Reference values for pulsed Doppler signals from the blood flow velocity on both sides of the pulmonary valve",
"year": 1988,
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1093/oxfordjournals.eurheartj.a062515",
"pmid": "3383877"
},
"verification": "primary-abstract-population-and-method-checked-not-full-text",
"verificationScope": "215 healthy subjects aged 1-65; pulmonary artery and RVOT Doppler measurements. Adult ejection-time limits not verified; acceleration time or LV timing is not substituted.",
"url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3383877/"
},
{
"sourceId": "murgo-1980-human-aortic-waveforms",
"title": "Aortic input impedance in normal man: relationship to pressure wave forms",
"year": 1980,
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1161/01.CIR.62.1.105",
"pmid": "7379273"
},
"verification": "author-institution-abstract-checked-not-full-text",
"url": "https://scholars.uthscsa.edu/es/publications/aortic-input-impedance-in-normal-man-relationship-to-pressure-wav/"
},
{
"sourceId": "kohli-2017-normalized-human-pv-loops",
"title": "The quest for load-independent left ventricular chamber properties: exploring the normalized pressure-volume loop",
"year": 2017,
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.14814/phy2.13160",
"pmid": "28351966"
},
"verification": "primary-full-text-methods-and-figures-4-5-checked",
"url": "https://physoc.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.14814/phy2.13160"
},
{
"sourceId": "lang-2015-chamber-quantification",
"title": "Recommendations for Cardiac Chamber Quantification by Echocardiography in Adults: An Update from the American Society of Echocardiography and the European Association of Cardiovascular Imaging",
"year": 2015,
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1016/j.echo.2014.10.003",
"pmid": "25559473"
},
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"url": "https://www.asecho.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/2015_ChamberQuantificationREV.pdf"
},
{
"sourceId": "kou-2014-norre-chamber-reference",
"title": "Echocardiographic reference ranges for normal cardiac chamber size: results from the NORRE study",
"year": 2014,
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1093/ehjci/jet284",
"pmid": "24451180"
},
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"url": "https://orbi.uliege.be/bitstream/2268/169431/1/Eur%20Heart%20J%20Cardiovasc%20Imaging-2014-Kou-680-90.pdf"
},
{
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2015-cmr-normal-values",
"title": "Normal values for cardiovascular magnetic resonance in adults and children",
"year": 2015,
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1186/s12968-015-0111-7",
"pmid": "25928314"
},
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"url": "https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1186/s12968-015-0111-7.pdf"
},
{
"sourceId": "carlsson-2012-cmr-cardiac-output",
"title": "Cardiac output and cardiac index measured with cardiovascular magnetic resonance in healthy subjects, elite athletes and patients with congestive heart failure",
"year": 2012,
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1186/1532-429X-14-51",
"pmid": "22839436"
},
"verification": "primary-full-text-methods-and-results-checked",
"url": "https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/1532-429X-14-51"
},
{
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2025-scmr-reference-values",
"title": "Society for Cardiovascular Magnetic Resonance reference values (normal values) in cardiovascular magnetic resonance: 2025 update",
"year": 2025,
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1016/j.jocmr.2025.101853",
"pmcid": "PMC12159681"
},
"verification": "primary-full-text-methods-and-results-checked",
"verificationScope": "Sections 2-4 and Tables 2, 3, 8, 9; anatomical versus smooth segmentation and pooled adult sex-specific intervals. No current gate endpoints are verified by this source comparison.",
"url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12159681/"
},
{
"sourceId": "raisi-estabragh-2024-hhc-anatomical-tables",
"title": "Cardiovascular Magnetic Resonance Reference Ranges From the Healthy Hearts Consortium: author-published anatomical segmentation tables",
"year": 2024,
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1016/j.jcmg.2024.01.009",
"pmid": "38613554"
},
"verification": "author-published-tables-7-and-37-checked-not-full-article",
"verificationScope": "Full one-page source PDFs visually checked, including headers, age columns, units and N ranges. White men and women aged 40-49 are parallel illustrative comparisons, not the declared model subject or a new gate.",
"url": "https://healthy-hearts.org.uk/tables/"
},
{
"sourceId": "barratt-boyes-wood-1958-healthy-hemodynamics",
"title": "Cardiac output and related measurements and pressure values in the right heart and associated vessels, together with an analysis of the hemo-dynamic response to the inhalation of high oxygen mixtures in healthy subjects",
"year": 1958,
"identifiers": {
"pmid": "13514210"
},
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/13514210/"
},
{
"sourceId": "mukherjee-2025-right-heart-guideline",
"title": "Guidelines for the Echocardiographic Assessment of the Right Heart in Adults and Special Considerations in Pulmonary Hypertension: Recommendations from the American Society of Echocardiography",
"year": 2025,
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1016/j.echo.2025.01.006",
"pmid": "40044341"
},
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"url": "https://www.asecho.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/PIIS0894731725000379.pdf"
},
{
"sourceId": "kovacs-2009-healthy-pap-review",
"title": "Pulmonary arterial pressure during rest and exercise in healthy subjects: a systematic review",
"year": 2009,
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1183/09031936.00145608"
},
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"url": "https://publications.ersnet.org/highwire_display/entity_view/node/476971/full"
},
{
"sourceId": "zeder-2024-healthy-pawp-meta-analysis",
"title": "Pulmonary arterial wedge pressure in healthy subjects: a meta-analysis",
"year": 2024,
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1183/13993003.00967-2024",
"pmid": "38964777"
},
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"url": "https://publications.ersnet.org/content/erj/64/2/2400967"
},
{
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"title": "2022 ESC/ERS Guidelines for the diagnosis and treatment of pulmonary hypertension",
"year": 2022,
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1183/13993003.00879-2022",
"pmid": "36028254"
},
"verification": "primary-table-11-and-rhc-methods-checked",
"verificationScope": "Table 11 and section 5.1.12.1, European Heart Journal pp. 3646-3647. Passage verification does not establish the model operator mapping or support wider retained pressure bounds.",
"url": "https://publications.ersnet.org/lookup/pmid/36028254"
},
{
"sourceId": "alhakak-2023-copenhagen-cardiac-time-intervals",
"title": "Age- and sex-based normal reference ranges of the cardiac time intervals: the Copenhagen City Heart Study",
"year": 2023,
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1007/s00392-023-02269-2"
},
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"url": "https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00392-023-02269-2"
},
{
"sourceId": "nagueh-2025-lv-diastolic-function",
"title": "Recommendations for the Evaluation of Left Ventricular Diastolic Function by Echocardiography and for Heart Failure With Preserved Ejection Fraction Diagnosis: An Update From the American Society of Echocardiography",
"year": 2025,
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1016/j.echo.2025.03.011"
},
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"url": "https://www.asecho.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/Left-Ventricular-Diastolic-Function.pdf"
},
{
"sourceId": "bussmann-1977-normal-lv-contractile-relaxation-reserve",
"title": "Contractile and relaxation reserve of the left ventricle. I. Normal left ventricle",
"year": 1977,
"identifiers": {
"pmid": "602351"
},
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/602351/"
},
{
"sourceId": "hirota-1980-lv-relaxation",
"title": "A clinical study of left ventricular relaxation",
"year": 1980,
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1161/01.cir.62.4.756",
"pmid": "7190882"
},
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7190882/"
},
{
"sourceId": "stein-1980-rv-pressure-fall",
"title": "Effect of chronic pressure overload on the maximal rate of pressure fall of the right ventricle",
"year": 1980,
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1378/chest.78.1.10",
"pmid": "7471826"
},
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7471826/"
}
],
"evidenceBindings": [
{
"evidenceId": "lang-ase-eacvi-2015",
"canonicalSourceIds": [
"lang-2015-chamber-quantification"
],
"useRole": "construction-context",
"measurementMeaning": "Adult echocardiographic LV chamber volumes and systolic function.",
"limitations": "Modality-, sex-, age-, and body-size-dependent reference context; it does not directly define this model's joint admissible interval."
},
{
"evidenceId": "kou-norre-2014",
"canonicalSourceIds": [
"kou-2014-norre-chamber-reference"
],
"useRole": "construction-context",
"measurementMeaning": "Two-dimensional echocardiographic adult chamber-size reference ranges.",
"limitations": "The cohort and measurement method do not identify a unique 0D-model parameter vector or a joint multivariate normal region."
},
{
"evidenceId": "cmr-consolidated-normal-reference-2016",
"canonicalSourceIds": [
"kawel-boehm-2015-cmr-normal-values"
],
"useRole": "construction-context",
"measurementMeaning": "CMR chamber-volume and function reference context across published cohorts.",
"limitations": "The retained legacy evidence ID has a 2016 label but resolves to the 2015 publication; CMR and echocardiographic volumes are not interchangeable without a measurement model."
},
{
"evidenceId": "lang-ase-eacvi-2015-3de-rv",
"canonicalSourceIds": [
"lang-2015-chamber-quantification"
],
"useRole": "construction-context",
"measurementMeaning": "Adult three-dimensional echocardiographic RV volumes and ejection fraction.",
"limitations": "A 0D chamber volume is compared only as broad construction context; acquisition and segmentation conventions remain different."
},
{
"evidenceId": "cardiac-index-clinical-reference",
"canonicalSourceIds": [
"carlsson-2012-cmr-cardiac-output",
"barratt-boyes-wood-1958-healthy-hemodynamics"
],
"useRole": "construction-context",
"measurementMeaning": "Resting forward cardiac output indexed to body surface area.",
"limitations": "The model interval is an engineering synthesis across methods and cohorts, not a verbatim interval from either source."
},
{
"evidenceId": "resting-indexed-flow-reference",
"canonicalSourceIds": [
"carlsson-2012-cmr-cardiac-output",
"barratt-boyes-wood-1958-healthy-hemodynamics"
],
"useRole": "construction-context",
"measurementMeaning": "Resting systemic forward stroke volume indexed to body surface area.",
"limitations": "Stroke-volume index depends on heart rate, body-size convention, cohort, and acquisition method; the gate is a broad engineering envelope."
},
{
"evidenceId": "mukherjee-ase-right-heart-2025",
"canonicalSourceIds": [
"mukherjee-2025-right-heart-guideline",
"kovacs-2009-healthy-pap-review"
],
"useRole": "construction-context",
"measurementMeaning": "Right-heart echocardiographic assessment and healthy pulmonary arterial pressure context.",
"limitations": "This does not directly support the exact 10-35 mmHg model interval or validate the current pulmonary waveform shape."
},
{
"evidenceId": "kovacs-pawp-healthy-meta-2024",
"canonicalSourceIds": [
"zeder-2024-healthy-pawp-meta-analysis"
],
"useRole": "construction-context",
"measurementMeaning": "Supine resting pulmonary arterial wedge pressure in healthy subjects.",
"limitations": "The retained legacy evidence ID uses the last author's name; the model reports mean LA pressure, not a simulated wedged-catheter measurement."
}
],
"checkGroups": [
{
"groupId": "settlement",
"checkIds": [
"settlement.period1"
],
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"thresholdBasis": "exact-contract",
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"measurementMeaning": "Whether the exact periodic classifier established the required period-one terminal state.",
"changeReason": "Fail closed before interpreting any derived baseline measurement.",
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"evaluationRole": "numerical-quality",
"observationLimitations": "Period-one settlement is numerical admissibility, not physiological normality or independent model validation.",
"evidenceGap": "No clinical population interval applies to an exact periodic-classifier contract.",
"sourceComparisons": []
},
{
"groupId": "ventricular-pressure-morphology",
"checkIds": [
"waveform.LVP.single-peak-no-ringing",
"waveform.RVP.single-peak-no-ringing"
],
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess",
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"measurementMeaning": "Algorithmic peak count, total variation and episode count of pressure during the associated semilunar-valve forward-flow episode.",
"changeReason": "Retain the artifact guards motivated by Standard65-to-68 ringing, separately from unvalidated contour reference corridors. This is a current-model construction requirement, not a claim that every healthy human trace has one peak.",
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"evaluationRole": "construction-guard",
"observationLimitations": "Prominence and variation depend on accepted sampling and the thresholded forward-flow episode. Real arterial reflection can produce a systolic shoulder or secondary rise; the current lumped model has no explicit propagation/reflection mechanism, so that observation does not explain its numerical or coupled-mode ringing.",
"evidenceGap": "No primary healthy-cohort distribution supports the exact peak-count or variation cutoffs. They remain transparent construction guards; no clinical normality follows from passing.",
"sourceComparisons": []
},
{
"groupId": "ventricular-pressure-contour-reference",
"checkIds": [
"waveform.LVP.rounded-not-plateau",
"waveform.RVP.rounded-not-plateau"
],
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess",
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"measurementMeaning": "Central accepted-sample-index pressure range divided by full ejection pressure range, jointly with the first maximum's normalized sample index. The check reports peak index when that alone fails; it is not PV-loop curvature or a time-weighted shape measurement.",
"changeReason": "Demote the frozen central-range and peak-index corridors to descriptive warnings: no matched normal distribution supports the limits, and a single compound failure previously conflated late pressure peak with flatness. Numerical thresholds are not widened to admit a candidate.",
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"evaluationRole": "reference-warning",
"observationLimitations": "Sample-index phase is not elapsed-time phase on nonuniform accepted steps. Pressure versus time and pressure versus volume have different curvature because ejection flow varies. Resolution, pressure loading and the selected episode affect these summaries; RV and LV cannot be assigned the same physiological contour solely by analogy.",
"evidenceGap": "No matched healthy LV or RV reference interval was identified for centralRangeFraction 0.08-0.35 or peakPhase01 0.2-0.8. These values remain visible warnings, not independent scientific validation or permission to accept unexplained ringing.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"sourceId": "murgo-1980-human-aortic-waveforms",
"locator": "Author-institution abstract; ascending aortic pressure waveform groups",
"targetPopulation": "18 elective catheterization patients in whom no heart disease was found; not a population reference sample.",
"observationMeaning": "Simultaneous ascending aortic pressure and flow; early versus late systolic pressure, not the model's ventricular central-range or peak-index fractions.",
"sourceRange": "Late greater than early in 7, nearly equal in 7, early greater than late in 4.",
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "Demonstrates aortic contour diversity and reflection-related interpretation, but supplies no numeric cutoff for LV/RV roundness and does not justify reflection-like oscillation in this model."
},
{
"sourceId": "kohli-2017-normalized-human-pv-loops",
"locator": "Methods; Tables 1 and 4; Figures 4-5, PDF pp. 6-7",
"targetPopulation": "13 catheterization subjects selected for normal LV function, sinus rhythm and valves; 9 had hypertension. This is not a strictly healthy normative cohort.",
"observationMeaning": "Simultaneous Millar conductance-catheter LV pressure/volume sampled at 250 Hz; observed inter- and intra-subject PV contours.",
"sourceRange": null,
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The displayed contours vary, including a relatively flat upper limb (visual inference, not digitized statistics). No central-range, ejection peak-phase or PV-curvature normal interval was reported."
}
]
},
{
"groupId": "aortic-valve-gradient",
"checkIds": [
"aortic-valve.mean-gradient",
"aortic-valve.peak-gradient"
],
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess",
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"measurementMeaning": "Time-weighted mean and maximum raw LV-minus-Ao node pressure difference during native aortic forward flow.",
"changeReason": "Constrain the non-stenotic baseline while retaining the model's explicit pressure-station limitation.",
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"evaluationRole": "construction-guard",
"observationLimitations": "This hydraulic node gradient is neither a Doppler Bernoulli gradient nor a simultaneous catheter LV-to-recovered-aortic pressure difference; pressure recovery and spatial acceleration are not observed.",
"evidenceGap": "No matching healthy-population source establishes the exact mean or peak cutoffs for these model pressure stations. Stenosis diagnostic thresholds would not validate them.",
"sourceComparisons": []
},
{
"groupId": "aortic-ejection-time",
"checkIds": [
"aortic-valve.ejection-time"
],
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess",
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"measurementMeaning": "Native AoV zero-flow opening to exact completed-beat closure; the observer requires agreement with the completed beat's accumulated positive-flow duration.",
"changeReason": "Prevent a gradient reduction obtained by implausibly shortening or prolonging ejection.",
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"evaluationRole": "physiological-target",
"observationLimitations": "A single complete ejection episode is required. This hydraulic duration is shared with left ICT, IRT and Tei calculations, but is not color-TDI, Doppler-envelope or ECG timing; HR and population selection matter.",
"evidenceGap": "The frozen construction interval is provisional. Similarity to the retrospective Copenhagen interval does not establish its historical derivation or cross-method validity.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"sourceId": "alhakak-2023-copenhagen-cardiac-time-intervals",
"locator": "Table 2; Methods, Cardiac time intervals",
"targetPopulation": "1,969 Danish adults without cardiovascular disease or risk factors; median age 46 (IQR 33-58) years, 61.5% women, HR 63 +/- 10/min.",
"observationMeaning": "Color-TDI M-mode mitral-leaflet event timing; pooled 95% prediction intervals, not interchangeable with other Doppler or hydraulic event methods.",
"sourceRange": "LVET 248-336 ms.",
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen interval is slightly broader at both endpoints; no observer-specific calibration has established equivalence."
}
]
},
{
"groupId": "left-ventricular-pressure-rate",
"checkIds": [
"left-ventricle.maximum-dpdt",
"left-ventricle.minimum-dpdt"
],
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess",
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"measurementMeaning": "Maximum and minimum accepted-step finite-difference derivative of absolute intracavitary LV pressure over the completed beat.",
"changeReason": "Retain plausible contraction and relaxation rates while adjusting aortic ejection morphology.",
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"evaluationRole": "reference-warning",
"observationLimitations": "Accepted-step bandwidth, pressure loading, HR, preload, medication and catheter filtering affect extrema. Published negative dP/dt is often a positive magnitude, whereas this model stores a signed minimum; this is not a transmural derivative.",
"evidenceGap": "The positive corridor overlaps small normal-LV patient series, but the frozen negative corridor excludes their resting means. Neither series supplies a population-normal acceptance interval; keep both corridors as warnings rather than validated pass/fail physiology.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"sourceId": "bussmann-1977-normal-lv-contractile-relaxation-reserve",
"locator": "Abstract; resting values before ergometer exercise",
"targetPopulation": "13 patients described as having a normal LV; not a population-based, sex/age-stratified healthy sample.",
"observationMeaning": "Invasive maximal LV pressure rise and pressure-fall magnitude; the accessible abstract does not fully establish acquisition bandwidth.",
"sourceRange": "Resting maximum +1721 +/- 378 mmHg/s; negative magnitude 1862 +/- 343 mmHg/s (mean +/- SD).",
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The positive mean lies within the frozen corridor; the signed negative mean does not. Exercise values cannot justify a resting cutoff."
},
{
"sourceId": "hirota-1980-lv-relaxation",
"locator": "Methods p. 757; normal-control table p. 759; abstract",
"targetPopulation": "18 normal controls including patients investigated for chest pain, murmurs or other indications; not a healthy population reference sample.",
"observationMeaning": "Millar LV micromanometer and continuous differentiator; average of five sinus beats, after premedication.",
"sourceRange": "Maximum +1674 +/- 421 mmHg/s; negative magnitude 1864 +/- 390 mmHg/s (observed negative-magnitude range 1275-2772).",
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The frozen relaxation corridor excludes the control mean and much of the observed range. Means/SDs and observed extrema are context, not newly selected cutoffs."
}
]
},
{
"groupId": "mitral-e-to-a",
"checkIds": [
"mitral-flow.peak-e-to-a"
],
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess",
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"measurementMeaning": "Ratio of peak native mitral forward volume flow in early and atrial filling windows anchored to the observed atrial-capture event.",
"changeReason": "Retain the recorded corridor as context only: native volumetric E/A is not Doppler velocity E/A. Positive resolved waves remain required; no numeric widening or candidate-specific target change.",
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"evaluationRole": "reference-warning",
"observationLimitations": "Volume-flow peaks are not leaflet-tip Doppler velocities; varying effective valve area can change their ratio. A complete post-capture inlet closure and identifiable E/A windows are required, and age, rhythm, HR and loading affect interpretation.",
"evidenceGap": "The fixed corridor is provisional, not an age-specific Doppler normal interval. Better event anchoring does not remove the flow-versus-velocity observation mismatch.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"sourceId": "nagueh-2025-lv-diastolic-function",
"locator": "Tables 3 and 5 (p. 551)",
"targetPopulation": "Healthy reference data grouped by age; guideline echocardiographic assessment in adults, with age- and sex-aware supplementary data.",
"observationMeaning": "PW Doppler mitral leaflet-tip E and A velocities, identified relative to ECG T and P waves; estimated fifth-to-95th percentiles.",
"sourceRange": "E/A: ages 20-39, 0.88-2.73; ages 40-60, 0.69-2.07; ages 60-80, 0.50-1.40.",
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen bounds truncate some healthy age-specific ranges and admit values outside others; numerical overlap cannot validate a native volume-flow ratio."
}
]
},
{
"groupId": "left-ventricular-timing",
"checkIds": [
"timing.ict",
"timing.irt",
"timing.tei-index"
],
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess",
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"measurementMeaning": "ICT from exact MV closure to AoV zero-flow opening, IRT from exact AoV closure to MV zero-flow opening, and (ICT + IRT) divided by the matched aortic ejection duration.",
"changeReason": "Demote method-mismatched ICT/IRT/Tei corridors to context; retain complete ordered hydraulic events, positivity and exact Tei arithmetic. ET remains an explicitly chosen baseline operating target, not proof of a population-normal timing pattern.",
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"evaluationRole": "reference-warning",
"observationLimitations": "Closure landmarks and trace-interpolated openings must describe one complete beat. Tei is algebraically linked to ICT, IRT and the separately checked ejection time, so these are not independent constraints.",
"evidenceGap": "The intervals remain provisional hydraulic timing targets. Matching some published endpoints does not establish a measurement-equivalence study or historical source derivation.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"sourceId": "alhakak-2023-copenhagen-cardiac-time-intervals",
"locator": "Table 2; Methods, Cardiac time intervals",
"targetPopulation": "1,969 Danish adults without cardiovascular disease or risk factors; median age 46 (IQR 33-58) years, 61.5% women, HR 63 +/- 10/min.",
"observationMeaning": "Color-TDI M-mode mitral-leaflet event timing; pooled 95% prediction intervals, not interchangeable with other Doppler or hydraulic event methods.",
"sourceRange": "IVCT 20-59 ms; IVRT 59-134 ms; MPI 0.29-0.65.",
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "IRT and Tei endpoints match this pooled table, while the chosen ICT upper bound is wider. The source expressly limits generalization across measurement methods."
}
]
},
{
"groupId": "systemic-pressure",
"checkIds": [
"aortic-pressure.maximum",
"aortic-pressure.minimum",
"central-venous-pressure.mean"
],
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess",
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"measurementMeaning": "Completed-beat extrema of absolute Ao root-compliance-node pressure and time-weighted mean absolute RA pressure; the active AoP display uses this same Ao node.",
"changeReason": "Maintain broad resting systemic-pressure compatibility as a construction safety envelope.",
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"evaluationRole": "physiological-target",
"observationLimitations": "The lumped central Ao node has no arterial propagation, peripheral amplification or pressure recovery and is not a brachial cuff observation. RA pressure is intracavitary, not transmural; its beat mean does not reproduce end-expiratory catheter averaging or IVC-based RAP estimation.",
"evidenceGap": "No verified primary healthy central-aortic source establishes both chosen Ao ranges. The RA range is broader than the invasive reference below. All three are provisional resting construction targets.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"locator": "Table 11; section 5.1.12.1",
"targetPopulation": "Adult resting right-heart catheterization reference values summarized by the guideline, not a new sex-, age-, or BSA-stratified healthy cohort.",
"observationMeaning": "Supine catheter pressure, mid-thoracic zero and end-expiratory reading; output by direct Fick or thermodilution.",
"sourceRange": "Mean RAP 2-6 mmHg; systemic systolic/diastolic pressure is illustrated as 120/80 mmHg, not a reference interval.",
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen RA corridor is wider. A single illustrative arterial pressure cannot substantiate either Ao endpoint."
}
]
},
{
"groupId": "pulmonary-artery-pressure",
"checkIds": [
"pulmonary-artery-pressure.maximum",
"pulmonary-artery-pressure.minimum"
],
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"thresholdBasis": "literature-context-plus-engineering-envelope",
"contextEvidenceIds": [
"mukherjee-ase-right-heart-2025"
],
"measurementMeaning": "Extrema of absolute model PA root-node pressure over the exact completed beat.",
"changeReason": "Use broad resting pressure context as a sentinel while withholding a pulmonary-waveform validation claim.",
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"evaluationRole": "physiological-target",
"observationLimitations": "This is an invasive-like lumped pressure signal, not TR-derived RVSP/PASP or a spatially resolved catheter waveform; respiratory reference and averaging differ. RVSP is not PASP when an RV-to-PA gradient is present.",
"evidenceGap": "The chosen systolic and diastolic upper bounds are broader than both cited invasive references. This remains a provisional pressure envelope, not confirmation of normal PAP or pulmonary waveform shape.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"locator": "Table 11; section 5.1.12.1",
"targetPopulation": "Adult resting right-heart catheterization reference values summarized by the guideline, not a new sex-, age-, or BSA-stratified healthy cohort.",
"observationMeaning": "Supine catheter pressure, mid-thoracic zero and end-expiratory reading; output by direct Fick or thermodilution.",
"sourceRange": "PAP systolic 15-30 mmHg; diastolic 4-12 mmHg.",
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen lower bounds match; the upper bounds are deliberately wider and are not the guideline's normal interval."
},
{
"sourceId": "kovacs-2009-healthy-pap-review",
"locator": "Table 1; healthy resting supine catheterization data",
"targetPopulation": "47 studies, 1,187 healthy participants overall; resting supine systolic PAP available in 625, with heterogeneous age and sex representation.",
"observationMeaning": "Invasive resting supine PAP pooled across cohorts; mean +/- SD rather than a joint systolic/diastolic normal region.",
"sourceRange": "Systolic 20.8 +/- 4.4 mmHg (upper limit 29.6); diastolic 8.8 +/- 3.0 mmHg.",
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "These distributions provide context but do not establish the chosen wider systolic and diastolic corridors."
}
]
},
{
"groupId": "pcwp-surrogate",
"checkIds": [
"pcwp-surrogate.mean"
],
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"thresholdBasis": "literature-context-plus-engineering-envelope",
"contextEvidenceIds": [
"kovacs-pawp-healthy-meta-2024"
],
"measurementMeaning": "Time-weighted completed-beat mean absolute LA pressure, exposed only as a labelled PCWP surrogate.",
"changeReason": "Bound left-sided filling pressure while preserving the explicit station and measurement mismatch.",
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"evaluationRole": "physiological-target",
"observationLimitations": "Mean intracavitary LA pressure is not LVEDP, transmural LA pressure or an actual wedged-catheter observation. Wedge zero, respiratory sampling and transmission through the pulmonary circulation are not reproduced.",
"evidenceGap": "The chosen upper limit has healthy PAWP context, but the lower bound lacks an exact source and no observation study establishes this model's LA-mean-to-PAWP equivalence.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"sourceId": "zeder-2024-healthy-pawp-meta-analysis",
"locator": "Main results; individual-data and zero-reference subgroup analyses",
"targetPopulation": "960 mainly nonobese healthy participants from 49 studies; individual-data subset n=159, median age 26 (IQR 23-53), 67% men.",
"observationMeaning": "Resting supine catheter PAWP, with heterogeneous zero references and respiratory conventions; significant sex differences.",
"sourceRange": "Pooled PAWP 9.4 +/- 1.82 mmHg; upper limit 13 mmHg (mid-thoracic-zero subgroup 12.2 mmHg).",
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen upper limit matches the pooled upper limit, not every subgroup. The study does not establish the chosen lower limit or validate mean model LA pressure as a wedge observation."
}
]
},
{
"groupId": "left-ventricular-indexed-size-function",
"checkIds": [
"left-ventricle.edv-index",
"left-ventricle.esv-index",
"left-ventricle.ejection-fraction"
],
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"thresholdBasis": "literature-context-plus-engineering-envelope",
"contextEvidenceIds": [
"lang-ase-eacvi-2015",
"kou-norre-2014",
"cmr-consolidated-normal-reference-2016"
],
"measurementMeaning": "Valve-event-defined 0D LV volumes indexed to the reference BSA and their event-defined ejection fraction.",
"changeReason": "Create a deliberately broad cross-modality construction corridor rather than a joint population-normal claim.",
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"evaluationRole": "physiological-target",
"observationLimitations": "ED/ES are volumes at native inlet/outlet closure, not necessarily global extrema. Event definitions can align with imaging, but 0D cavity boundaries lack echo/CMR segmentation conventions. Fixed reference BSA does not select a sex/age cohort; EF is derived from the two volumes.",
"evidenceGap": "The frozen corridor combines context across methods; its volume endpoints do not reproduce the cited echo or CMR intervals, and its independent marginal gates are not a joint healthy distribution.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"sourceId": "lang-2015-chamber-quantification",
"locator": "Table 2 (p. 7); ED/ES definition (p. 6)",
"targetPopulation": "Adult sex-specific echocardiographic reference data.",
"observationMeaning": "2D biplane LV volumes indexed to BSA; ED/ES may use valve events or cavity extrema; normal ranges based on mean +/- 2 SD.",
"sourceRange": "Men: EDVi 34-74, ESVi 11-31 mL/m2, EF 52-72%; women: 29-61, 8-24, 54-74%.",
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "Chosen EF is the sex-union; the volume corridor is not the sex-union and admits larger volumes."
},
{
"sourceId": "kou-2014-norre-chamber-reference",
"locator": "Table 2, pp. 684-685",
"targetPopulation": "734 healthy adults (320 men, 414 women), age 45.8 +/- 13.3 years, predominantly white Europeans from 22 institutions.",
"observationMeaning": "Biplane Simpson 2D echo, excluding papillary muscles and trabeculae from the cavity; BSA indexing does not remove age/sex effects.",
"sourceRange": "Men: EDVi 34.8-75.7, ESVi 11.7-28.8 mL/m2, EF 55.8-71.3%; women: 34.2-67.6, 10.5-25.9, 57.3-72.6%.",
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen volume and EF bounds are broader than these sex-specific intervals; the source does not support their exact endpoints."
},
{
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2015-cmr-normal-values",
"locator": "Table 2 (p. 2)",
"targetPopulation": "Pooled adult European cohorts, ages 20-80 years; sex-specific results.",
"observationMeaning": "1.5 T SSFP CMR with LV papillary muscles included in mass; mean +/- 2 SD.",
"sourceRange": "Men: EDVi 57-105, ESVi 14-38 mL/m2, EF 57-77%; women: 56-96, 14-34, 57-77%.",
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen corridor is not a CMR normal interval and can exclude source-normal EDVi or EF while admitting much lower volumes."
},
{
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2025-scmr-reference-values",
"locator": "Sections 2-3; Table 2 (papillary muscles/trabeculations in mass)",
"targetPopulation": "Pooled healthy adult CMR cohorts, sex-specific and mixed ages; not an age-40-49 or single joint population interval.",
"observationMeaning": "Short-axis bSSFP anatomical cavity volumes; random-effects aggregation with reference-limit estimation. Myocardial tissue is excluded from the blood pool; imaging events and spatial segmentation are not reproduced by a 0D cavity.",
"sourceRange": "Men: EDVi 46-104, ESVi 11-41 mL/m2, EF 53-79%; women: 46-91, 11-34, 55-80%.",
"thresholdVerification": "context-only",
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "An updated, method-declared comparison, not support for the retained cross-modality endpoints or a demographic assignment to the synthetic model."
},
{
"sourceId": "raisi-estabragh-2024-hhc-anatomical-tables",
"locator": "Author website Table 37 (men) and Table 7 (women), 40-49-year column, LV rows",
"targetPopulation": "Illustrative same-study White adults aged 40-49; variable-dependent N 378-447 men and 458-518 women. Neither stratum is assigned to the model.",
"observationMeaning": "CMR anatomical segmentation, BSA-indexed volumes and EF; both ventricles can be compared in the same stratum without joining different modalities.",
"sourceRange": "Men: EDVi 51-102, ESVi 13-40 mL/m2, EF 53-77%; women: 49-88, 13-33, 56-78%.",
"thresholdVerification": "context-only",
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "Retain both comparisons rather than selecting the sex that admits the candidate; no new gate or joint-95-percent normality claim."
}
]
},
{
"groupId": "right-ventricular-indexed-size-function",
"checkIds": [
"right-ventricle.edv-index",
"right-ventricle.esv-index",
"right-ventricle.ejection-fraction"
],
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"thresholdBasis": "literature-context-plus-engineering-envelope",
"contextEvidenceIds": [
"lang-ase-eacvi-2015-3de-rv"
],
"measurementMeaning": "Valve-event-defined 0D RV volumes indexed to the reference BSA and their event-defined ejection fraction.",
"changeReason": "Retain broad RV size/function safety bounds without extending the current systemic and left-heart claim.",
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"evaluationRole": "physiological-target",
"observationLimitations": "Native TV/PV closure volumes and derived EF do not specify a 3D-echo or CMR segmentation method. BSA indexing alone does not remove sex/age effects; EF and the two event volumes are algebraically linked.",
"evidenceGap": "The volume bounds match a union of male/female 3D-echo ranges, not a population-specific or cross-modality range. The EF endpoints combine age/sex subgroup extremes rather than defining a single healthy cohort.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"sourceId": "lang-2015-chamber-quantification",
"locator": "Table 8 (p. 20); Supplemental Table 8 (p. 39.e13)",
"targetPopulation": "Adult sex-specific 3D-echo data; supplemental RV EF limits further stratified by age.",
"observationMeaning": "3D-echo RV volume segmentation and BSA indexing; subgroup EF limits are fifth/95th percentiles.",
"sourceRange": "Men: EDVi 35-87, ESVi 10-44 mL/m2; women: 32-74, 8-36. Subgroup EF extremes include 42% and 82%; general RV EF below 45% is abnormal.",
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "Volume bounds reproduce the sex-union. EF bounds span subgroup extremes, not a universal normal range."
},
{
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2015-cmr-normal-values",
"locator": "Table 6 (p. 7)",
"targetPopulation": "Healthy adult cohorts aged 20-68 years, sex-specific results; indexed RV ESV uses the Hudsmith cohort.",
"observationMeaning": "1.5 T SSFP CMR with RV trabeculations and papillary muscles in the cavity; mean +/- 2 SD.",
"sourceRange": "Men: EDVi 61-121, ESVi 19-59 mL/m2, EF 52-72%; women: 48-112, 12-52, 51-71%.",
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "Chosen volume bounds exclude substantial CMR-normal values; the 3D-echo corridor cannot be called a broad cross-modality RV normal interval."
},
{
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2025-scmr-reference-values",
"locator": "Sections 2 and 4; Table 8 (papillary muscles/trabeculations in mass), not smooth-segmentation Table 9",
"targetPopulation": "Pooled healthy adult CMR cohorts, sex-specific and mixed ages. Constituent cohorts differ from LV Table 2; marginal limits do not define a joint healthy subject.",
"observationMeaning": "Short-axis bSSFP anatomical RV cavity volume with myocardial tissue excluded from blood volume; event, geometric and segmentation correspondence to 0D remains approximate.",
"sourceRange": "Men: EDVi 49-117, ESVi 12-56 mL/m2, EF 44-77%; women: 47-99, 11-43, 49-77%.",
"thresholdVerification": "context-only",
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "This uses the anatomical RV counterpart of the LV comparison. Do not substitute age-specific smooth-contour RV rows or retroactively replace old check bounds."
},
{
"sourceId": "raisi-estabragh-2024-hhc-anatomical-tables",
"locator": "Author website Table 37 (men) and Table 7 (women), 40-49-year column, RV rows",
"targetPopulation": "Illustrative same-study White adults aged 40-49; variable-dependent N 378-447 men and 458-518 women. Neither stratum is assigned to the model.",
"observationMeaning": "CMR anatomical segmentation and BSA indexation, same subject strata and measurement convention as the LV comparison.",
"sourceRange": "Men: EDVi 61-118, ESVi 21-55 mL/m2, EF 44-71%; women: 53-97, 17-42, 49-73%.",
"thresholdVerification": "context-only",
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "Provides a coherent same-study alternative for future prospective design. BSA1.9 alone does not select either column, and the current upper EDVi bound is not verified by this study."
}
]
},
{
"groupId": "indexed-systemic-forward-flow",
"checkIds": [
"systemic-forward-flow.cardiac-index",
"systemic-forward-flow.stroke-volume-index"
],
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"thresholdBasis": "literature-context-plus-engineering-envelope",
"contextEvidenceIds": [
"cardiac-index-clinical-reference",
"resting-indexed-flow-reference"
],
"measurementMeaning": "Positive-only native AoV flow integrated for stroke volume and converted to cardiac output over the completed beat, both indexed to reference BSA.",
"changeReason": "Maintain broad resting forward-flow compatibility across the admitted HR values.",
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"evaluationRole": "physiological-target",
"observationLimitations": "Forward volume is not signed net aortic flow or EDV-minus-ESV when regurgitation or other routes exist. CI and SVI are linked by HR, so at a fixed HR they are not independent targets; reference BSA and body habitus remain relevant.",
"evidenceGap": "CI has an exact guideline interval, but SVI is a cross-source construction choice. The retained Barratt-Boyes binding was metadata-verified only and does not provide a verified quantitative derivation here.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"locator": "Table 11; section 5.1.12.1",
"targetPopulation": "Adult resting right-heart catheterization reference values summarized by the guideline, not a new sex-, age-, or BSA-stratified healthy cohort.",
"observationMeaning": "Supine catheter pressure, mid-thoracic zero and end-expiratory reading; output by direct Fick or thermodilution.",
"sourceRange": "CI 2.5-4.0 L/min/m2; SVI 33-47 mL/m2.",
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "CI endpoints match exactly; SVI endpoints do not. Fick/thermodilution output is not necessarily the model's positive-only valve-flow output."
},
{
"sourceId": "carlsson-2012-cmr-cardiac-output",
"coveredCheckIds": [
"systemic-forward-flow.cardiac-index",
"systemic-forward-flow.stroke-volume-index"
],
"thresholdVerification": "context-only",
"thresholdRationale": "Methods and healthy-group results checked in full text on 2026-09-06. These are cohort summaries, not direct verification of the retained construction endpoints; passage verification alone must not qualify those endpoints.",
"locator": "Methods; healthy-group results and age analysis",
"targetPopulation": "144 healthy nonathletic adults, 68 women, ages 21-81 (mean 39 +/- 16) years; BMI <=30, no cardiovascular disease or medication.",
"observationMeaning": "Supine free-breathing ascending-aortic phase-contrast CMR at pulmonary-bifurcation level, distal to coronary origins; signed whole-cycle flow integrated for SV, Mosteller BSA. The paper attributes expected Qp/Qs around 1.04 to coronary flow of 3-5 percent, so absence of regurgitation alone does not equate this plane to native AoV output.",
"sourceRange": "CI 3.2 +/- 0.5 L/min/m2; SVI 51 +/- 7 mL/m2 (mean +/- SD).",
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen SVI interval is close to, but not identical to, a calculated mean +/- 2 SD interval of 37-65. Such a calculation is not a published universal normal cutoff."
}
]
},
{
"groupId": "pulmonary-valve-gradient",
"checkIds": [
"pulmonary-valve.mean-gradient",
"pulmonary-valve.peak-gradient"
],
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess",
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"measurementMeaning": "Time-weighted mean and maximum raw RV-minus-PA node pressure difference while native PV flow is positive over the completed beat.",
"changeReason": "Record the existing Standard70 right-heart gradient sentinels without promoting them to left-objective groups or changing their numerical limits.",
"analysisPartition": "right-heart-sentinel",
"evaluationRole": "construction-guard",
"observationLimitations": "The model's hydraulic gradient is not a Doppler Bernoulli or recovered catheter gradient; an explicit outlet node does not provide spatial velocity, pressure recovery or an invasive sensor model.",
"evidenceGap": "No source establishes the exact mean and peak healthy cutoffs for these pressure stations. These remain non-stenotic construction guards, not clinical normal-gradient intervals.",
"sourceComparisons": []
},
{
"groupId": "pulmonary-ejection-time",
"checkIds": [
"pulmonary-valve.ejection-time"
],
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess",
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"measurementMeaning": "Native PV zero-flow opening to exact completed-beat closure; the observer requires agreement with the completed beat's accumulated positive-flow duration.",
"changeReason": "Record the existing Standard70 pulmonary ejection-time corridor with its missing method-matched normative evidence.",
"analysisPartition": "right-heart-sentinel",
"evaluationRole": "physiological-target",
"observationLimitations": "A complete single ejection episode is required. This duration also enters right ICT, IRT and Tei calculations; hydraulic timing is not a Doppler-envelope or tissue-Doppler measurement and depends on HR/loading.",
"evidenceGap": "No exact primary normal interval was identified for this observer and target population. Retain the frozen interval only as a provisional physiological target; left-sided LVET data do not establish a right-sided range.",
"sourceComparisons": []
},
{
"groupId": "right-ventricular-pressure-rate",
"checkIds": [
"right-ventricle.maximum-dpdt",
"right-ventricle.minimum-dpdt"
],
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess",
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"measurementMeaning": "Maximum and minimum accepted-step finite-difference derivative of absolute intracavitary RV pressure over the completed beat.",
"changeReason": "Reclassify the existing Standard70 RV derivative corridors as reference warnings without altering the recorded numerical bounds.",
"analysisPartition": "right-heart-sentinel",
"evaluationRole": "reference-warning",
"observationLimitations": "These load- and bandwidth-dependent extrema are neither transmural pressure derivatives nor the mean RV-to-RA pressure-gradient rise inferred over a selected TR velocity interval. Signed negative extrema must not be confused with published pressure-fall magnitudes.",
"evidenceGap": "No verified source establishes either frozen normal corridor. Sparse normal-PAP invasive data and a method-specific abnormal Doppler threshold justify contextual warnings, not hard healthy-population acceptance limits.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"sourceId": "mukherjee-2025-right-heart-guideline",
"locator": "RV dP/dt section, pp. 158-159",
"targetPopulation": "Adult right-heart echocardiography; normal-reference data are limited.",
"observationMeaning": "TR Doppler 1-to-2 m/s upslope converted to a 12 mmHg pressure-gradient rise divided by time.",
"sourceRange": "RV dP/dt below 400 mmHg/s is abnormal for this Doppler method.",
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "This is not the maximum native intracavitary derivative and does not establish either chosen endpoint or a normal upper limit."
},
{
"sourceId": "stein-1980-rv-pressure-fall",
"locator": "Abstract; normal-PAP and pulmonary-hypertension groups",
"targetPopulation": "34 patients: eight with normal PAP, 17 with pulmonary hypertension, nine with pulmonary hypertension and RV failure; not a general healthy reference cohort.",
"observationMeaning": "Maximal invasive RV pressure-fall magnitude; strong pressure-load dependence, with acquisition detail incompletely resolved by the abstract.",
"sourceRange": "Normal-PAP group 170 +/- 20 mmHg/s; pulmonary-hypertension groups 670 +/- 60 mmHg/s, with or without RV failure.",
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "Both loading groups can fit the broad signed negative corridor. The reported summary values are not a healthy reference interval and cannot define its bounds."
}
]
},
{
"groupId": "tricuspid-e-to-a",
"checkIds": [
"tricuspid-flow.peak-e-to-a"
],
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess",
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"measurementMeaning": "Ratio of peak native tricuspid forward volume flow in early and atrial filling windows anchored to the observed atrial-capture event.",
"changeReason": "Demote the native tricuspid flow-ratio corridor to context because Doppler velocity and respiratory averaging are different observations; resolved positive filling waves remain required.",
"analysisPartition": "right-heart-sentinel",
"evaluationRole": "reference-warning",
"observationLimitations": "Requires identifiable windows and an observed post-capture inlet closure. Volume-flow peaks do not equal Doppler velocities if effective valve area changes; respiration, HR, rhythm, age and loading remain relevant.",
"evidenceGap": "The numerical corridor resembles a guideline Doppler interval but remains provisional for the native-flow observer; the source upper endpoint is exclusive whereas the frozen gate is inclusive.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"sourceId": "mukherjee-2025-right-heart-guideline",
"locator": "Table 1; RV diastolic function, pp. 168-169",
"targetPopulation": "Adult echocardiographic reference context.",
"observationMeaning": "PW tricuspid inflow E/A velocities; end-expiratory averaging over at least five beats.",
"sourceRange": "Tricuspid E/A >=0.8 and <2.0.",
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen numeric endpoints match, but flow-versus-velocity and respiratory averaging differ; this is not method-matched validation."
}
]
},
{
"groupId": "right-ventricular-timing",
"checkIds": [
"right-timing.ict",
"right-timing.irt",
"right-timing.tei-index"
],
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess",
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"measurementMeaning": "ICT from exact TV closure to PV zero-flow opening, IRT from exact PV closure to TV zero-flow opening, and (ICT + IRT) divided by the matched pulmonary ejection duration.",
"changeReason": "Demote the unsupported hydraulic right ICT/IRT/Tei numeric corridors to context. Ordered complete valve events and algebraic consistency remain mandatory; a short RV isovolumic phase is not automatically pathological.",
"analysisPartition": "right-heart-sentinel",
"evaluationRole": "reference-warning",
"observationLimitations": "One complete valve-event sequence is required. Tei is algebraically linked to ICT, IRT and the separately checked pulmonary ET; PW-Doppler, TDI and hydraulic timings are different observations.",
"evidenceGap": "No primary source was identified for the chosen joint ICT/IRT/Tei corridors. The source below supplies method-specific context, not equivalent normal intervals; all three remain provisional physiological targets.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"sourceId": "mukherjee-2025-right-heart-guideline",
"locator": "RV MPI, pp. 158-159; IVRT, pp. 168-169",
"targetPopulation": "Adult right-heart echocardiography.",
"observationMeaning": "PW-Doppler or tissue-Doppler MPI and tissue-Doppler IVRT, not native valve-flow events.",
"sourceRange": "MPI <0.40 by PW Doppler or <0.55 by TDI; IVRT <=73 ms by TDI.",
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen upper IRT and Tei bounds are wider, and no chosen lower bound or ICT interval follows from these thresholds."
}
]
},
{
"groupId": "pulmonary-root-morphology",
"checkIds": [
"waveform.PAP.single-peak-no-ringing",
"waveform.PV-flow.single-forward-episode",
"waveform.PV-flow.single-peak-no-ringing",
"waveform.PAP.post-PV-closure-rebound"
],
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess",
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"measurementMeaning": "Algorithmic full-cycle PA pressure peak count, thresholded PV forward-episode count, primary-episode PV flow peak count and maximal post-episode PA rebound.",
"changeReason": "Record Standard70 pulmonary ringing and re-ejection guards as construction-only waveform criteria.",
"analysisPartition": "right-heart-sentinel",
"evaluationRole": "construction-guard",
"observationLimitations": "The episode threshold and peak-prominence algorithm define these observations; the post-episode rebound is not an invasive dicrotic-notch metric. One peak does not characterize the entire pressure or flow contour.",
"evidenceGap": "No primary normal distribution supports the exact one-peak, one-episode or rebound cutoffs. A qualitative Doppler flow shape must not be cited as proof of these pressure-waveform thresholds.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"sourceId": "mukherjee-2025-right-heart-guideline",
"locator": "RVOT Doppler flow, p. 158",
"targetPopulation": "Adult resting right-heart echocardiography.",
"observationMeaning": "Qualitative RVOT Doppler velocity waveform: parabolic with a midsystolic peak.",
"sourceRange": null,
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "Qualitative flow context only; it establishes no peak-prominence, PAP peak-count or post-PV-closure rebound cutoff."
}
]
}
],
"policyRevisions": [
{
"revisionId": "main-wire-standard68-baseline-policy-r1",
"policySha256": "74f5b1ca712b56f304fee1ccf20da3e9dee8c7102213a2cb60dc2e7701cf3356",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"changeReason": "Capture the current Standard68 mint policy and healthy-reference context after retrospective provenance repair."
}
],
"preloadReservePolicyRevisions": [
{
"revisionId": "main-wire-standard69-preload-reserve-policy-r1",
"policySha256": "dec7d6cdf587522c67892f0f94c910a2a8871a1aada6620c1a8778869109f4d5",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"decisionTiming": "post-hoc-after-exploratory-candidate-inspection",
"changeReason": "Freeze the Standard69-specific relative CO, pressure-flow slope, and relative EDV floors after exploratory candidate inspection. These are construction-only non-regression thresholds, not independently validated physiological cutoffs."
}
]
}
}
}Complete 2 / 1 ms observations and assessments
[
{
"modelId": "circleheart.main-wire-integrated-transaction-v3.static-anatomy.standard-74",
"numericalSourceSha256": "f92b231c6f11c4746bb9f47e96d89cbe6f17692f57f704cca5ff82eb1ee2b326",
"resultSha256": "d01746c0373a761176db0da0243ba1711102ef55d6ab311649b0fae49b7d5a07",
"nominalDtSec": 0.002,
"initialization": {
"kind": "cold"
},
"cycles": 54,
"rest": {
"assessment": {
"anatomyReviewRequired": false,
"comparison": {
"admissionDecision": "not-performed",
"applicabilityReview": "Caller must separately establish settlement, no support/shunt and correct pressure reference. This readback does not infer those conditions from a plausible scalar or small flow mismatch.",
"endTimeSec": 46.153714285714244,
"entries": [
{
"actual": 0.25800000000000267,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": 0.248,
"upper": 0.336
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "Copenhagen pooled healthy adults; HR 63 +/- 10"
}
],
"locator": "Methods, Cardiac time intervals; Table 2, pooled LVET 95% prediction interval",
"mapping": "Native accumulated positive AoV-flow duration, not mitral-leaflet color-TDI timing. Opening-to-closure interpretation requires the separate morphology/timing observer to establish one forward episode; this comparison does not enforce that condition. No HR correction or method equivalence inferred.",
"metricId": "aortic-valve.ejection-time",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "method-context",
"sourceId": "alhakak-2023-copenhagen-cardiac-time-intervals",
"unit": "s"
},
{
"actual": 0.25800000000000267,
"comparisons": [],
"locator": "Abstract: population and recording stations; no numeric adult ET interval verified",
"mapping": "Native accumulated positive PV-flow duration; the separate morphology/timing observer must establish one forward episode. Doppler PA versus RVOT station, respiration and HR differ. No adult ET bounds inferred from acceleration time, tissue S-wave duration or LVET.",
"metricId": "pulmonary-valve.ejection-time",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "method-context",
"sourceId": "van-oort-1988-pulmonary-doppler",
"unit": "s"
},
{
"actual": 111.29648919376602,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": 80,
"upper": 110
},
"statistic": "published-10th-90th-percentiles",
"status": "outside-source-range",
"stratum": "women 20-29"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 92,
"upper": 115
},
"statistic": "published-10th-90th-percentiles",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "men 20-29"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 84,
"upper": 119
},
"statistic": "published-10th-90th-percentiles",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "women 30-39"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 88,
"upper": 120
},
"statistic": "published-10th-90th-percentiles",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "men 30-39"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 87,
"upper": 123
},
"statistic": "published-10th-90th-percentiles",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "women 40-49"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 90,
"upper": 123
},
"statistic": "published-10th-90th-percentiles",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "men 40-49"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 93,
"upper": 127
},
"statistic": "published-10th-90th-percentiles",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "women 50-59"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 96,
"upper": 126
},
"statistic": "published-10th-90th-percentiles",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "men 50-59"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 97,
"upper": 129
},
"statistic": "published-10th-90th-percentiles",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "women 60-69"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 97,
"upper": 128
},
"statistic": "published-10th-90th-percentiles",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "men 60-69"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 100,
"upper": 131
},
"statistic": "published-10th-90th-percentiles",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "women 70+"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 99,
"upper": 130
},
"statistic": "published-10th-90th-percentiles",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "men 70+"
}
],
"locator": "Methods, Standardizing methodologies; Table 2, Normal population, all adult age rows",
"mapping": "Model Ao root pressure is invasive-like. Source cSBP is cuff-calibrated noninvasive estimation; authors explicitly distinguish it from higher invasive intra-aortic SBP. Published P10/P90 are context, not 95% normal cutoffs or a model calibration target.",
"metricId": "aortic-pressure.maximum",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "method-context",
"sourceId": "herbert-2014-central-pressure-reference",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 77.52496258535398,
"comparisons": [],
"locator": "Methods, Standardizing methodologies; Table 1, brachial DBP summary",
"mapping": "Source assumes DBP consistency for calibration, but does not publish a central-DBP normal interval. Do not turn the brachial mean +/- SD into a verified Ao-node cutoff.",
"metricId": "aortic-pressure.minimum",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "method-context",
"sourceId": "herbert-2014-central-pressure-reference",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 3.0795269248997674,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": 2,
"upper": 6
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "resting adult RHC reference"
}
],
"locator": "Table 11, mean RAP; section 5.1.12.1",
"mapping": "Absolute lumped pressure, no respiratory cycle; compare with supine end-expiratory catheter values at the specified zero. No catheter transfer function or peripheral waveform is simulated.",
"metricId": "central-venous-pressure.mean",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "operating-comparison",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 26.17242118724626,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": 15,
"upper": 30
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "resting adult RHC reference"
}
],
"locator": "Table 11, systolic PAP; section 5.1.12.1",
"mapping": "Absolute lumped pressure, no respiratory cycle; compare with supine end-expiratory catheter values at the specified zero. No catheter transfer function or peripheral waveform is simulated.",
"metricId": "pulmonary-artery-pressure.maximum",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "operating-comparison",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 12.055592420313948,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": 4,
"upper": 12
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "outside-source-range",
"stratum": "resting adult RHC reference"
}
],
"locator": "Table 11, diastolic PAP; section 5.1.12.1",
"mapping": "Absolute lumped pressure, no respiratory cycle; compare with supine end-expiratory catheter values at the specified zero. No catheter transfer function or peripheral waveform is simulated.",
"metricId": "pulmonary-artery-pressure.minimum",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "operating-comparison",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 17.89193948661483,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": 8,
"upper": 20
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "resting adult RHC reference"
}
],
"locator": "Table 11, mean PAP; section 5.1.12.1",
"mapping": "Absolute lumped pressure, no respiratory cycle; compare with supine end-expiratory catheter values at the specified zero. No catheter transfer function or peripheral waveform is simulated.",
"metricId": "pulmonary-artery-pressure.mean",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "operating-comparison",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 8.40282801978899,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": null,
"upper": 15
},
"statistic": "clinical-upper-limit",
"status": "not-above-source-upper-limit",
"stratum": "adult RHC PAWP clinical reference"
}
],
"locator": "Table 11, PAWP; section 5.1.12.1",
"mapping": "Observed quantity remains LA mean, not a wedge measurement or LVEDP. PAWP <=15 is the guideline clinical reference upper limit, not a healthy-cohort distribution or a verified model LA-to-PAWP transfer. No lower bound is invented.",
"metricId": "pcwp-surrogate.mean",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "method-context",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 75.63750481521748,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": 46,
"upper": 104
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "men, pooled adult ages"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 46,
"upper": 91
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "women, pooled adult ages"
}
],
"locator": "Table 2, anatomical segmentation, sex-specific indexed volume/EF rows",
"mapping": "Native valve-closure cavity blood volumes, BSA indexed; compared with anatomical bSSFP CMR excluding papillary/trabecular myocardium from the blood pool. No validated image segmentation or age/sex assignment; separate marginal ranges are not a joint distribution. EF is derived from EDV and ESV.",
"metricId": "left-ventricle.edv-index",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "demographic-comparison",
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2025-scmr-reference-values",
"unit": "mL/m2"
},
{
"actual": 33.46818399425799,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": 11,
"upper": 41
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "men, pooled adult ages"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 11,
"upper": 34
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "women, pooled adult ages"
}
],
"locator": "Table 2, anatomical segmentation, sex-specific indexed volume/EF rows",
"mapping": "Native valve-closure cavity blood volumes, BSA indexed; compared with anatomical bSSFP CMR excluding papillary/trabecular myocardium from the blood pool. No validated image segmentation or age/sex assignment; separate marginal ranges are not a joint distribution. EF is derived from EDV and ESV.",
"metricId": "left-ventricle.esv-index",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "demographic-comparison",
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2025-scmr-reference-values",
"unit": "mL/m2"
},
{
"actual": 0.5575186664866747,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": 0.53,
"upper": 0.79
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "men, pooled adult ages"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 0.55,
"upper": 0.8
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "women, pooled adult ages"
}
],
"locator": "Table 2, anatomical segmentation, sex-specific indexed volume/EF rows",
"mapping": "Native valve-closure cavity blood volumes, BSA indexed; compared with anatomical bSSFP CMR excluding papillary/trabecular myocardium from the blood pool. No validated image segmentation or age/sex assignment; separate marginal ranges are not a joint distribution. EF is derived from EDV and ESV.",
"metricId": "left-ventricle.ejection-fraction",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "demographic-comparison",
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2025-scmr-reference-values",
"unit": "fraction"
},
{
"actual": 74.08611606820064,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": 49,
"upper": 117
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "men, pooled adult ages"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 47,
"upper": 99
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "women, pooled adult ages"
}
],
"locator": "Table 8, anatomical segmentation, sex-specific indexed volume/EF rows",
"mapping": "Native valve-closure cavity blood volumes, BSA indexed; compared with anatomical bSSFP CMR excluding papillary/trabecular myocardium from the blood pool. No validated image segmentation or age/sex assignment; separate marginal ranges are not a joint distribution. EF is derived from EDV and ESV.",
"metricId": "right-ventricle.edv-index",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "demographic-comparison",
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2025-scmr-reference-values",
"unit": "mL/m2"
},
{
"actual": 31.917135985782327,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": 12,
"upper": 56
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "men, pooled adult ages"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 11,
"upper": 43
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "women, pooled adult ages"
}
],
"locator": "Table 8, anatomical segmentation, sex-specific indexed volume/EF rows",
"mapping": "Native valve-closure cavity blood volumes, BSA indexed; compared with anatomical bSSFP CMR excluding papillary/trabecular myocardium from the blood pool. No validated image segmentation or age/sex assignment; separate marginal ranges are not a joint distribution. EF is derived from EDV and ESV.",
"metricId": "right-ventricle.esv-index",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "demographic-comparison",
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2025-scmr-reference-values",
"unit": "mL/m2"
},
{
"actual": 0.569188699858409,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": 0.44,
"upper": 0.77
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "men, pooled adult ages"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 0.49,
"upper": 0.77
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "women, pooled adult ages"
}
],
"locator": "Table 8, anatomical segmentation, sex-specific indexed volume/EF rows",
"mapping": "Native valve-closure cavity blood volumes, BSA indexed; compared with anatomical bSSFP CMR excluding papillary/trabecular myocardium from the blood pool. No validated image segmentation or age/sex assignment; separate marginal ranges are not a joint distribution. EF is derived from EDV and ESV.",
"metricId": "right-ventricle.ejection-fraction",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "demographic-comparison",
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2025-scmr-reference-values",
"unit": "fraction"
},
{
"actual": 2.951852448445143,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": 2.5,
"upper": 4
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "resting adult RHC reference"
}
],
"historicalCheckId": "systemic-forward-flow.cardiac-index",
"locator": "Table 11, CI; section 5.1.12.1, direct Fick/thermodilution",
"mapping": "Use signed native AoV NET output/BSA under a distinct metric ID. Interpretation as whole-circulation CO requires a settled unassisted nonshunting state; no positive-only flow substitution or distal-CMR-plane equivalence.",
"metricId": "systemic-net-flow.cardiac-index",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "operating-comparison",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"unit": "L/min/m2"
},
{
"actual": 42.16932069207332,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": 33,
"upper": 47
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "resting adult RHC reference"
}
],
"historicalCheckId": "systemic-forward-flow.stroke-volume-index",
"locator": "Table 11, SVI; section 5.1.12.1",
"mapping": "Signed native AoV NET volume/BSA. CI = HR * SVI / 1000, so this is a coupled comparison, not a second independent fitting objective. The CI-conditional interval is reported separately; it is not this published SVI interval.",
"metricId": "systemic-net-flow.stroke-volume-index",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "coupled-flow-context",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"unit": "mL/m2"
}
],
"flowCoupling": {
"basis": "signed-native-AoV-net-flow",
"ciConditionalSviIntervalMlPerM2": {
"lower": 35.71428571428558,
"upper": 57.14285714285693
},
"ciMinusHrTimesSviOver1000": -4.440892098500626e-16,
"conditionalIntervalIsPublishedSviReference": false,
"forwardMinusNetCi": 0,
"pulmonaryMinusAorticNetFlowLPerMin": -0.00004530361777099756
},
"heartRateBpm": 70.00000000000026,
"nativeLvEndDiastolicPressure": {
"absolutePressureMmHg": 10.92333041706009,
"differenceFromMeanLaMmHg": 2.5205023972711,
"externalPressureMmHg": 0,
"timeSec": 45.40342857142857,
"transmuralPressureMmHg": 10.92333041706009
},
"observationApplicabilityEstablished": false,
"physiologicalNormalityClaimed": false,
"profileId": "main-wire-resting-reference-profile-v1",
"scope": "Settled resting unassisted, nonshunting sinus baseline; source comparisons are not patient-fit targets or a replacement for numerical/construction checks.",
"selectionRule": "Report every declared comparison, never select a stratum because it passes. This comparison profile alone provides no sex-union, sex-intersection or summed-score admission rule; any consuming design decision must be explicit and separately versioned.",
"startTimeSec": 45.29657142857139,
"subject": {
"age": "unspecified",
"allowedHeartRatesBpm": [
60,
70
],
"bodySurfaceAreaM2": 1.9,
"ethnicity": "unspecified",
"sex": "unspecified"
}
},
"historicalWarnings": [
{
"actual": 2564.2544594929004,
"checkId": "left-ventricle.maximum-dpdt",
"maximum": 2500,
"minimum": 1200,
"status": "failed",
"unit": "mmHg/s"
},
{
"actual": -1538.8738086615583,
"checkId": "left-ventricle.minimum-dpdt",
"maximum": -700,
"minimum": -1400,
"status": "failed",
"unit": "mmHg/s"
},
{
"actual": 0.08914285714285342,
"checkId": "timing.ict",
"maximum": 0.07,
"minimum": 0.02,
"status": "failed",
"unit": "s"
},
{
"actual": 0.7021040974529081,
"checkId": "timing.tei-index",
"maximum": 0.65,
"minimum": 0.29,
"status": "failed",
"unit": "ratio"
}
],
"invalidOrFailedRetained": [],
"operating": [
{
"actual": 2.951852448445143,
"basis": "source-informed-operating-target",
"locator": "Table 11, CI",
"lower": 2.5,
"metricId": "systemic-net-flow.cardiac-index",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"status": "passed",
"upper": 4
},
{
"actual": 3.0795269248997674,
"basis": "source-informed-operating-target",
"locator": "Table 11, mean RAP",
"lower": 2,
"metricId": "central-venous-pressure.mean",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"status": "passed",
"upper": 6
},
{
"actual": 17.89193948661483,
"basis": "source-informed-operating-target",
"locator": "Table 11, mean PAP",
"lower": 8,
"metricId": "pulmonary-artery-pressure.mean",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"status": "passed",
"upper": 20
},
{
"actual": 111.29648919376602,
"basis": "retained-engineering-load-guard-NOT-source-derived-normal-range",
"locator": "Methods, invasive versus cuff-calibrated pressure distinction",
"lower": 90,
"metricId": "aortic-pressure.maximum",
"sourceId": "herbert-2014-central-pressure-reference",
"status": "passed",
"upper": 140
},
{
"actual": 77.52496258535398,
"basis": "retained-engineering-load-guard-NOT-source-derived-normal-range",
"locator": "Methods, DBP calibration; no central-DBP reference interval",
"lower": 60,
"metricId": "aortic-pressure.minimum",
"sourceId": "herbert-2014-central-pressure-reference",
"status": "passed",
"upper": 90
},
{
"actual": 10.92333041706009,
"basis": "source-informed-engineering-load-guard-NOT-method-matched-normal-range",
"locator": "Section2, Table1 p539 (>16), Figure1 p540",
"lower": null,
"metricId": "left-ventricle.native-end-filling-pressure",
"sourceId": "nagueh-2025-lv-diastolic-function",
"status": "passed",
"upper": 16
}
],
"status": "passed",
"unavailable": []
},
"observation": {
"checks": [
{
"actual": 1,
"checkId": "settlement.period1",
"maximum": 1,
"minimum": 1,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "bool"
},
{
"actual": 1,
"checkId": "waveform.LVP.single-peak-no-ringing",
"maximum": 1,
"minimum": 1,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "bool"
},
{
"actual": 0.20455258328909098,
"checkId": "waveform.LVP.rounded-not-plateau",
"maximum": 0.35,
"minimum": 0.08,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "fraction"
},
{
"actual": 1,
"checkId": "waveform.RVP.single-peak-no-ringing",
"maximum": 1,
"minimum": 1,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "bool"
},
{
"actual": 0.18979357650926013,
"checkId": "waveform.RVP.rounded-not-plateau",
"maximum": 0.35,
"minimum": 0.08,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "fraction"
},
{
"actual": 4.193858213219736,
"checkId": "aortic-valve.mean-gradient",
"maximum": 5,
"minimum": 0,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 7.820873008716177,
"checkId": "aortic-valve.peak-gradient",
"maximum": 10,
"minimum": 0,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 0.25800000000000267,
"checkId": "aortic-valve.ejection-time",
"maximum": 0.34,
"minimum": 0.24,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "s"
},
{
"actual": 2564.2544594929004,
"checkId": "left-ventricle.maximum-dpdt",
"maximum": 2500,
"minimum": 1200,
"status": "failed",
"unit": "mmHg/s"
},
{
"actual": -1538.8738086615583,
"checkId": "left-ventricle.minimum-dpdt",
"maximum": -700,
"minimum": -1400,
"status": "failed",
"unit": "mmHg/s"
},
{
"actual": 0.9379364716964619,
"checkId": "mitral-flow.peak-e-to-a",
"maximum": 2,
"minimum": 0.8,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "ratio"
},
{
"actual": 0.08914285714285342,
"checkId": "timing.ict",
"maximum": 0.07,
"minimum": 0.02,
"status": "failed",
"unit": "s"
},
{
"actual": 0.09199999999999875,
"checkId": "timing.irt",
"maximum": 0.134,
"minimum": 0.059,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "s"
},
{
"actual": 0.7021040974529081,
"checkId": "timing.tei-index",
"maximum": 0.65,
"minimum": 0.29,
"status": "failed",
"unit": "ratio"
},
{
"actual": 111.29648919376602,
"checkId": "aortic-pressure.maximum",
"maximum": 140,
"minimum": 90,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 77.52496258535398,
"checkId": "aortic-pressure.minimum",
"maximum": 90,
"minimum": 60,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 26.17242118724626,
"checkId": "pulmonary-artery-pressure.maximum",
"maximum": 35,
"minimum": 15,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 12.055592420313948,
"checkId": "pulmonary-artery-pressure.minimum",
"maximum": 15,
"minimum": 4,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 3.0795269248997674,
"checkId": "central-venous-pressure.mean",
"maximum": 8,
"minimum": 1,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 8.40282801978899,
"checkId": "pcwp-surrogate.mean",
"maximum": 13,
"minimum": 4,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 75.63750481521748,
"checkId": "left-ventricle.edv-index",
"maximum": 99,
"minimum": 34,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mL/m2"
},
{
"actual": 33.46818399425799,
"checkId": "left-ventricle.esv-index",
"maximum": 40,
"minimum": 10,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mL/m2"
},
{
"actual": 0.5575186664866747,
"checkId": "left-ventricle.ejection-fraction",
"maximum": 0.74,
"minimum": 0.52,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "ratio"
},
{
"actual": 74.08611606820064,
"checkId": "right-ventricle.edv-index",
"maximum": 87,
"minimum": 32,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mL/m2"
},
{
"actual": 31.917135985782327,
"checkId": "right-ventricle.esv-index",
"maximum": 44,
"minimum": 8,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mL/m2"
},
{
"actual": 0.569188699858409,
"checkId": "right-ventricle.ejection-fraction",
"maximum": 0.82,
"minimum": 0.42,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "ratio"
},
{
"actual": 2.9518524484451434,
"checkId": "systemic-forward-flow.cardiac-index",
"maximum": 4,
"minimum": 2.5,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "L/min/m2"
},
{
"actual": 42.16932069207332,
"checkId": "systemic-forward-flow.stroke-volume-index",
"maximum": 65,
"minimum": 35,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mL/m2"
},
{
"actual": 4.448942655299428,
"checkId": "pulmonary-valve.mean-gradient",
"maximum": 5,
"minimum": 0,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 7.366248564154482,
"checkId": "pulmonary-valve.peak-gradient",
"maximum": 10,
"minimum": 0,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 0.25800000000000267,
"checkId": "pulmonary-valve.ejection-time",
"maximum": 0.35,
"minimum": 0.22,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "s"
},
{
"actual": 585.6274034994009,
"checkId": "right-ventricle.maximum-dpdt",
"maximum": 1000,
"minimum": 300,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mmHg/s"
},
{
"actual": -371.8957345875963,
"checkId": "right-ventricle.minimum-dpdt",
"maximum": -150,
"minimum": -700,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mmHg/s"
},
{
"actual": 1.1040204787748886,
"checkId": "tricuspid-flow.peak-e-to-a",
"maximum": 2,
"minimum": 0.8,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "ratio"
},
{
"actual": 0.027999999999998693,
"checkId": "right-timing.ict",
"maximum": 0.09,
"minimum": 0.02,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "s"
},
{
"actual": 0.06400000000000006,
"checkId": "right-timing.irt",
"maximum": 0.12,
"minimum": 0.03,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "s"
},
{
"actual": 0.3565891472868132,
"checkId": "right-timing.tei-index",
"maximum": 0.65,
"minimum": 0.25,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "ratio"
},
{
"actual": 1,
"checkId": "waveform.PAP.single-peak-no-ringing",
"maximum": 1,
"minimum": 1,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "count"
},
{
"actual": 1,
"checkId": "waveform.PV-flow.single-forward-episode",
"maximum": 1,
"minimum": 1,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "count"
},
{
"actual": 1,
"checkId": "waveform.PV-flow.single-peak-no-ringing",
"maximum": 1,
"minimum": 1,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "count"
},
{
"actual": 0,
"checkId": "waveform.PAP.post-PV-closure-rebound",
"maximum": 0.5,
"minimum": 0,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mmHg"
}
],
"measured": {
"LVP": {
"centralRangeFraction": 0.20455258328909098,
"forwardEpisodeCount": 1,
"peakPhase01": 0.746031746031746,
"significantPeakCount": 1,
"totalVariationRatio": 1.162263974207825
},
"RVP": {
"centralRangeFraction": 0.18979357650926013,
"forwardEpisodeCount": 1,
"peakPhase01": 0.6771653543307087,
"significantPeakCount": 1,
"totalVariationRatio": 1.2847060597553432
},
"aorticValve": {
"ejectionTimeSec": 0.25800000000000267,
"meanGradientMmHg": 4.193858213219736,
"peakGradientMmHg": 7.820873008716177
},
"cardiacSizeAndFunction": {
"bodySurfaceAreaM2": 1.9,
"leftVentricle": {
"ejectionFraction01": 0.5575186664866747,
"endDiastolicVolumeIndexMlPerM2": 75.63750481521748,
"endDiastolicVolumeMl": 143.7112591489132,
"endSystolicVolumeIndexMlPerM2": 33.46818399425799,
"endSystolicVolumeMl": 63.58954958909018
},
"rightVentricle": {
"ejectionFraction01": 0.569188699858409,
"endDiastolicVolumeIndexMlPerM2": 74.08611606820064,
"endDiastolicVolumeMl": 140.7636205295812,
"endSystolicVolumeIndexMlPerM2": 31.917135985782327,
"endSystolicVolumeMl": 60.64255837298642
},
"systemicForwardFlow": {
"cardiacIndexLPerMinPerM2": 2.9518524484451434,
"cardiacOutputLPerMin": 5.608519652045772,
"strokeVolumeIndexMlPerM2": 42.16932069207332,
"strokeVolumeMl": 80.12170931493931
}
},
"hemodynamicPressure": {
"aortic": {
"maximumMmHg": 111.29648919376602,
"minimumMmHg": 77.52496258535398
},
"centralVenousMeanMmHg": 3.0795269248997674,
"pcwpSurrogateMeanMmHg": 8.40282801978899,
"pulmonaryArtery": {
"maximumMmHg": 26.17242118724626,
"minimumMmHg": 12.055592420313948
}
},
"leftVentricle": {
"maximumDpDtMmHgPerSec": 2564.2544594929004,
"minimumDpDtMmHgPerSec": -1538.8738086615583
},
"mitralFlow": {
"peakAMlPerSec": 419.0344622960538,
"peakEMlPerSec": 393.0277050851848,
"peakEToA": 0.9379364716964619
},
"pulmonaryRootMorphology": {
"maximumPostClosurePapReboundMmHg": 0,
"papSignificantPeakCount": 1,
"pvFlowSignificantPeakCount": 1,
"pvForwardEpisodeCount": 1
},
"pulmonaryValve": {
"ejectionTimeSec": 0.25800000000000267,
"meanGradientMmHg": 4.448942655299428,
"peakGradientMmHg": 7.366248564154482
},
"rightTiming": {
"ictSec": 0.027999999999998693,
"irtSec": 0.06400000000000006,
"teiIndex": 0.3565891472868132
},
"rightVentricle": {
"maximumDpDtMmHgPerSec": 585.6274034994009,
"minimumDpDtMmHgPerSec": -371.8957345875963
},
"timing": {
"ictSec": 0.08914285714285342,
"irtSec": 0.09199999999999875,
"teiIndex": 0.7021040974529081
},
"tricuspidFlow": {
"peakAMlPerSec": 320.2095227117433,
"peakEMlPerSec": 353.51787057249743,
"peakEToA": 1.1040204787748886
}
}
},
"referenceId": "baseline",
"status": "passed"
},
"referenceContext": {
"assessmentPolicy": {
"evidence": {
"checkGroups": [
{
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"changeReason": "Fail closed before interpreting any derived baseline measurement.",
"checkIds": [
"settlement.period1"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "numerical-quality",
"evidenceGap": "No clinical population interval applies to an exact periodic-classifier contract.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "settlement",
"measurementMeaning": "Whether the exact periodic classifier established the required period-one terminal state.",
"observationLimitations": "Period-one settlement is numerical admissibility, not physiological normality or independent model validation.",
"sourceComparisons": [],
"thresholdBasis": "exact-contract"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"changeReason": "Retain the artifact guards motivated by Standard65-to-68 ringing, separately from unvalidated contour reference corridors. This is a current-model construction requirement, not a claim that every healthy human trace has one peak.",
"checkIds": [
"waveform.LVP.single-peak-no-ringing",
"waveform.RVP.single-peak-no-ringing"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "construction-guard",
"evidenceGap": "No primary healthy-cohort distribution supports the exact peak-count or variation cutoffs. They remain transparent construction guards; no clinical normality follows from passing.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "ventricular-pressure-morphology",
"measurementMeaning": "Algorithmic peak count, total variation and episode count of pressure during the associated semilunar-valve forward-flow episode.",
"observationLimitations": "Prominence and variation depend on accepted sampling and the thresholded forward-flow episode. Real arterial reflection can produce a systolic shoulder or secondary rise; the current lumped model has no explicit propagation/reflection mechanism, so that observation does not explain its numerical or coupled-mode ringing.",
"sourceComparisons": [],
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"changeReason": "Demote the frozen central-range and peak-index corridors to descriptive warnings: no matched normal distribution supports the limits, and a single compound failure previously conflated late pressure peak with flatness. Numerical thresholds are not widened to admit a candidate.",
"checkIds": [
"waveform.LVP.rounded-not-plateau",
"waveform.RVP.rounded-not-plateau"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "reference-warning",
"evidenceGap": "No matched healthy LV or RV reference interval was identified for centralRangeFraction 0.08-0.35 or peakPhase01 0.2-0.8. These values remain visible warnings, not independent scientific validation or permission to accept unexplained ringing.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "ventricular-pressure-contour-reference",
"measurementMeaning": "Central accepted-sample-index pressure range divided by full ejection pressure range, jointly with the first maximum's normalized sample index. The check reports peak index when that alone fails; it is not PV-loop curvature or a time-weighted shape measurement.",
"observationLimitations": "Sample-index phase is not elapsed-time phase on nonuniform accepted steps. Pressure versus time and pressure versus volume have different curvature because ejection flow varies. Resolution, pressure loading and the selected episode affect these summaries; RV and LV cannot be assigned the same physiological contour solely by analogy.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "Demonstrates aortic contour diversity and reflection-related interpretation, but supplies no numeric cutoff for LV/RV roundness and does not justify reflection-like oscillation in this model.",
"locator": "Author-institution abstract; ascending aortic pressure waveform groups",
"observationMeaning": "Simultaneous ascending aortic pressure and flow; early versus late systolic pressure, not the model's ventricular central-range or peak-index fractions.",
"sourceId": "murgo-1980-human-aortic-waveforms",
"sourceRange": "Late greater than early in 7, nearly equal in 7, early greater than late in 4.",
"targetPopulation": "18 elective catheterization patients in whom no heart disease was found; not a population reference sample."
},
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The displayed contours vary, including a relatively flat upper limb (visual inference, not digitized statistics). No central-range, ejection peak-phase or PV-curvature normal interval was reported.",
"locator": "Methods; Tables 1 and 4; Figures 4-5, PDF pp. 6-7",
"observationMeaning": "Simultaneous Millar conductance-catheter LV pressure/volume sampled at 250 Hz; observed inter- and intra-subject PV contours.",
"sourceId": "kohli-2017-normalized-human-pv-loops",
"sourceRange": null,
"targetPopulation": "13 catheterization subjects selected for normal LV function, sinus rhythm and valves; 9 had hypertension. This is not a strictly healthy normative cohort."
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"changeReason": "Constrain the non-stenotic baseline while retaining the model's explicit pressure-station limitation.",
"checkIds": [
"aortic-valve.mean-gradient",
"aortic-valve.peak-gradient"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "construction-guard",
"evidenceGap": "No matching healthy-population source establishes the exact mean or peak cutoffs for these model pressure stations. Stenosis diagnostic thresholds would not validate them.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "aortic-valve-gradient",
"measurementMeaning": "Time-weighted mean and maximum raw LV-minus-Ao node pressure difference during native aortic forward flow.",
"observationLimitations": "This hydraulic node gradient is neither a Doppler Bernoulli gradient nor a simultaneous catheter LV-to-recovered-aortic pressure difference; pressure recovery and spatial acceleration are not observed.",
"sourceComparisons": [],
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"changeReason": "Prevent a gradient reduction obtained by implausibly shortening or prolonging ejection.",
"checkIds": [
"aortic-valve.ejection-time"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "physiological-target",
"evidenceGap": "The frozen construction interval is provisional. Similarity to the retrospective Copenhagen interval does not establish its historical derivation or cross-method validity.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "aortic-ejection-time",
"measurementMeaning": "Native AoV zero-flow opening to exact completed-beat closure; the observer requires agreement with the completed beat's accumulated positive-flow duration.",
"observationLimitations": "A single complete ejection episode is required. This hydraulic duration is shared with left ICT, IRT and Tei calculations, but is not color-TDI, Doppler-envelope or ECG timing; HR and population selection matter.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen interval is slightly broader at both endpoints; no observer-specific calibration has established equivalence.",
"locator": "Table 2; Methods, Cardiac time intervals",
"observationMeaning": "Color-TDI M-mode mitral-leaflet event timing; pooled 95% prediction intervals, not interchangeable with other Doppler or hydraulic event methods.",
"sourceId": "alhakak-2023-copenhagen-cardiac-time-intervals",
"sourceRange": "LVET 248-336 ms.",
"targetPopulation": "1,969 Danish adults without cardiovascular disease or risk factors; median age 46 (IQR 33-58) years, 61.5% women, HR 63 +/- 10/min."
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"changeReason": "Retain plausible contraction and relaxation rates while adjusting aortic ejection morphology.",
"checkIds": [
"left-ventricle.maximum-dpdt",
"left-ventricle.minimum-dpdt"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "reference-warning",
"evidenceGap": "The positive corridor overlaps small normal-LV patient series, but the frozen negative corridor excludes their resting means. Neither series supplies a population-normal acceptance interval; keep both corridors as warnings rather than validated pass/fail physiology.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "left-ventricular-pressure-rate",
"measurementMeaning": "Maximum and minimum accepted-step finite-difference derivative of absolute intracavitary LV pressure over the completed beat.",
"observationLimitations": "Accepted-step bandwidth, pressure loading, HR, preload, medication and catheter filtering affect extrema. Published negative dP/dt is often a positive magnitude, whereas this model stores a signed minimum; this is not a transmural derivative.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The positive mean lies within the frozen corridor; the signed negative mean does not. Exercise values cannot justify a resting cutoff.",
"locator": "Abstract; resting values before ergometer exercise",
"observationMeaning": "Invasive maximal LV pressure rise and pressure-fall magnitude; the accessible abstract does not fully establish acquisition bandwidth.",
"sourceId": "bussmann-1977-normal-lv-contractile-relaxation-reserve",
"sourceRange": "Resting maximum +1721 +/- 378 mmHg/s; negative magnitude 1862 +/- 343 mmHg/s (mean +/- SD).",
"targetPopulation": "13 patients described as having a normal LV; not a population-based, sex/age-stratified healthy sample."
},
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The frozen relaxation corridor excludes the control mean and much of the observed range. Means/SDs and observed extrema are context, not newly selected cutoffs.",
"locator": "Methods p. 757; normal-control table p. 759; abstract",
"observationMeaning": "Millar LV micromanometer and continuous differentiator; average of five sinus beats, after premedication.",
"sourceId": "hirota-1980-lv-relaxation",
"sourceRange": "Maximum +1674 +/- 421 mmHg/s; negative magnitude 1864 +/- 390 mmHg/s (observed negative-magnitude range 1275-2772).",
"targetPopulation": "18 normal controls including patients investigated for chest pain, murmurs or other indications; not a healthy population reference sample."
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"changeReason": "Retain the recorded corridor as context only: native volumetric E/A is not Doppler velocity E/A. Positive resolved waves remain required; no numeric widening or candidate-specific target change.",
"checkIds": [
"mitral-flow.peak-e-to-a"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "reference-warning",
"evidenceGap": "The fixed corridor is provisional, not an age-specific Doppler normal interval. Better event anchoring does not remove the flow-versus-velocity observation mismatch.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "mitral-e-to-a",
"measurementMeaning": "Ratio of peak native mitral forward volume flow in early and atrial filling windows anchored to the observed atrial-capture event.",
"observationLimitations": "Volume-flow peaks are not leaflet-tip Doppler velocities; varying effective valve area can change their ratio. A complete post-capture inlet closure and identifiable E/A windows are required, and age, rhythm, HR and loading affect interpretation.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen bounds truncate some healthy age-specific ranges and admit values outside others; numerical overlap cannot validate a native volume-flow ratio.",
"locator": "Tables 3 and 5 (p. 551)",
"observationMeaning": "PW Doppler mitral leaflet-tip E and A velocities, identified relative to ECG T and P waves; estimated fifth-to-95th percentiles.",
"sourceId": "nagueh-2025-lv-diastolic-function",
"sourceRange": "E/A: ages 20-39, 0.88-2.73; ages 40-60, 0.69-2.07; ages 60-80, 0.50-1.40.",
"targetPopulation": "Healthy reference data grouped by age; guideline echocardiographic assessment in adults, with age- and sex-aware supplementary data."
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"changeReason": "Demote method-mismatched ICT/IRT/Tei corridors to context; retain complete ordered hydraulic events, positivity and exact Tei arithmetic. ET remains an explicitly chosen baseline operating target, not proof of a population-normal timing pattern.",
"checkIds": [
"timing.ict",
"timing.irt",
"timing.tei-index"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "reference-warning",
"evidenceGap": "The intervals remain provisional hydraulic timing targets. Matching some published endpoints does not establish a measurement-equivalence study or historical source derivation.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "left-ventricular-timing",
"measurementMeaning": "ICT from exact MV closure to AoV zero-flow opening, IRT from exact AoV closure to MV zero-flow opening, and (ICT + IRT) divided by the matched aortic ejection duration.",
"observationLimitations": "Closure landmarks and trace-interpolated openings must describe one complete beat. Tei is algebraically linked to ICT, IRT and the separately checked ejection time, so these are not independent constraints.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "IRT and Tei endpoints match this pooled table, while the chosen ICT upper bound is wider. The source expressly limits generalization across measurement methods.",
"locator": "Table 2; Methods, Cardiac time intervals",
"observationMeaning": "Color-TDI M-mode mitral-leaflet event timing; pooled 95% prediction intervals, not interchangeable with other Doppler or hydraulic event methods.",
"sourceId": "alhakak-2023-copenhagen-cardiac-time-intervals",
"sourceRange": "IVCT 20-59 ms; IVRT 59-134 ms; MPI 0.29-0.65.",
"targetPopulation": "1,969 Danish adults without cardiovascular disease or risk factors; median age 46 (IQR 33-58) years, 61.5% women, HR 63 +/- 10/min."
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"changeReason": "Maintain broad resting systemic-pressure compatibility as a construction safety envelope.",
"checkIds": [
"aortic-pressure.maximum",
"aortic-pressure.minimum",
"central-venous-pressure.mean"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "physiological-target",
"evidenceGap": "No verified primary healthy central-aortic source establishes both chosen Ao ranges. The RA range is broader than the invasive reference below. All three are provisional resting construction targets.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "systemic-pressure",
"measurementMeaning": "Completed-beat extrema of absolute Ao root-compliance-node pressure and time-weighted mean absolute RA pressure; the active AoP display uses this same Ao node.",
"observationLimitations": "The lumped central Ao node has no arterial propagation, peripheral amplification or pressure recovery and is not a brachial cuff observation. RA pressure is intracavitary, not transmural; its beat mean does not reproduce end-expiratory catheter averaging or IVC-based RAP estimation.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen RA corridor is wider. A single illustrative arterial pressure cannot substantiate either Ao endpoint.",
"locator": "Table 11; section 5.1.12.1",
"observationMeaning": "Supine catheter pressure, mid-thoracic zero and end-expiratory reading; output by direct Fick or thermodilution.",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"sourceRange": "Mean RAP 2-6 mmHg; systemic systolic/diastolic pressure is illustrated as 120/80 mmHg, not a reference interval.",
"targetPopulation": "Adult resting right-heart catheterization reference values summarized by the guideline, not a new sex-, age-, or BSA-stratified healthy cohort."
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"changeReason": "Use broad resting pressure context as a sentinel while withholding a pulmonary-waveform validation claim.",
"checkIds": [
"pulmonary-artery-pressure.maximum",
"pulmonary-artery-pressure.minimum"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [
"mukherjee-ase-right-heart-2025"
],
"evaluationRole": "physiological-target",
"evidenceGap": "The chosen systolic and diastolic upper bounds are broader than both cited invasive references. This remains a provisional pressure envelope, not confirmation of normal PAP or pulmonary waveform shape.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "pulmonary-artery-pressure",
"measurementMeaning": "Extrema of absolute model PA root-node pressure over the exact completed beat.",
"observationLimitations": "This is an invasive-like lumped pressure signal, not TR-derived RVSP/PASP or a spatially resolved catheter waveform; respiratory reference and averaging differ. RVSP is not PASP when an RV-to-PA gradient is present.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen lower bounds match; the upper bounds are deliberately wider and are not the guideline's normal interval.",
"locator": "Table 11; section 5.1.12.1",
"observationMeaning": "Supine catheter pressure, mid-thoracic zero and end-expiratory reading; output by direct Fick or thermodilution.",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"sourceRange": "PAP systolic 15-30 mmHg; diastolic 4-12 mmHg.",
"targetPopulation": "Adult resting right-heart catheterization reference values summarized by the guideline, not a new sex-, age-, or BSA-stratified healthy cohort."
},
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "These distributions provide context but do not establish the chosen wider systolic and diastolic corridors.",
"locator": "Table 1; healthy resting supine catheterization data",
"observationMeaning": "Invasive resting supine PAP pooled across cohorts; mean +/- SD rather than a joint systolic/diastolic normal region.",
"sourceId": "kovacs-2009-healthy-pap-review",
"sourceRange": "Systolic 20.8 +/- 4.4 mmHg (upper limit 29.6); diastolic 8.8 +/- 3.0 mmHg.",
"targetPopulation": "47 studies, 1,187 healthy participants overall; resting supine systolic PAP available in 625, with heterogeneous age and sex representation."
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "literature-context-plus-engineering-envelope"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"changeReason": "Bound left-sided filling pressure while preserving the explicit station and measurement mismatch.",
"checkIds": [
"pcwp-surrogate.mean"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [
"kovacs-pawp-healthy-meta-2024"
],
"evaluationRole": "physiological-target",
"evidenceGap": "The chosen upper limit has healthy PAWP context, but the lower bound lacks an exact source and no observation study establishes this model's LA-mean-to-PAWP equivalence.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "pcwp-surrogate",
"measurementMeaning": "Time-weighted completed-beat mean absolute LA pressure, exposed only as a labelled PCWP surrogate.",
"observationLimitations": "Mean intracavitary LA pressure is not LVEDP, transmural LA pressure or an actual wedged-catheter observation. Wedge zero, respiratory sampling and transmission through the pulmonary circulation are not reproduced.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen upper limit matches the pooled upper limit, not every subgroup. The study does not establish the chosen lower limit or validate mean model LA pressure as a wedge observation.",
"locator": "Main results; individual-data and zero-reference subgroup analyses",
"observationMeaning": "Resting supine catheter PAWP, with heterogeneous zero references and respiratory conventions; significant sex differences.",
"sourceId": "zeder-2024-healthy-pawp-meta-analysis",
"sourceRange": "Pooled PAWP 9.4 +/- 1.82 mmHg; upper limit 13 mmHg (mid-thoracic-zero subgroup 12.2 mmHg).",
"targetPopulation": "960 mainly nonobese healthy participants from 49 studies; individual-data subset n=159, median age 26 (IQR 23-53), 67% men."
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "literature-context-plus-engineering-envelope"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"changeReason": "Create a deliberately broad cross-modality construction corridor rather than a joint population-normal claim.",
"checkIds": [
"left-ventricle.edv-index",
"left-ventricle.esv-index",
"left-ventricle.ejection-fraction"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [
"lang-ase-eacvi-2015",
"kou-norre-2014",
"cmr-consolidated-normal-reference-2016"
],
"evaluationRole": "physiological-target",
"evidenceGap": "The frozen corridor combines context across methods; its volume endpoints do not reproduce the cited echo or CMR intervals, and its independent marginal gates are not a joint healthy distribution.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "left-ventricular-indexed-size-function",
"measurementMeaning": "Valve-event-defined 0D LV volumes indexed to the reference BSA and their event-defined ejection fraction.",
"observationLimitations": "ED/ES are volumes at native inlet/outlet closure, not necessarily global extrema. Event definitions can align with imaging, but 0D cavity boundaries lack echo/CMR segmentation conventions. Fixed reference BSA does not select a sex/age cohort; EF is derived from the two volumes.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "Chosen EF is the sex-union; the volume corridor is not the sex-union and admits larger volumes.",
"locator": "Table 2 (p. 7); ED/ES definition (p. 6)",
"observationMeaning": "2D biplane LV volumes indexed to BSA; ED/ES may use valve events or cavity extrema; normal ranges based on mean +/- 2 SD.",
"sourceId": "lang-2015-chamber-quantification",
"sourceRange": "Men: EDVi 34-74, ESVi 11-31 mL/m2, EF 52-72%; women: 29-61, 8-24, 54-74%.",
"targetPopulation": "Adult sex-specific echocardiographic reference data."
},
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen volume and EF bounds are broader than these sex-specific intervals; the source does not support their exact endpoints.",
"locator": "Table 2, pp. 684-685",
"observationMeaning": "Biplane Simpson 2D echo, excluding papillary muscles and trabeculae from the cavity; BSA indexing does not remove age/sex effects.",
"sourceId": "kou-2014-norre-chamber-reference",
"sourceRange": "Men: EDVi 34.8-75.7, ESVi 11.7-28.8 mL/m2, EF 55.8-71.3%; women: 34.2-67.6, 10.5-25.9, 57.3-72.6%.",
"targetPopulation": "734 healthy adults (320 men, 414 women), age 45.8 +/- 13.3 years, predominantly white Europeans from 22 institutions."
},
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen corridor is not a CMR normal interval and can exclude source-normal EDVi or EF while admitting much lower volumes.",
"locator": "Table 2 (p. 2)",
"observationMeaning": "1.5 T SSFP CMR with LV papillary muscles included in mass; mean +/- 2 SD.",
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2015-cmr-normal-values",
"sourceRange": "Men: EDVi 57-105, ESVi 14-38 mL/m2, EF 57-77%; women: 56-96, 14-34, 57-77%.",
"targetPopulation": "Pooled adult European cohorts, ages 20-80 years; sex-specific results."
},
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "An updated, method-declared comparison, not support for the retained cross-modality endpoints or a demographic assignment to the synthetic model.",
"locator": "Sections 2-3; Table 2 (papillary muscles/trabeculations in mass)",
"observationMeaning": "Short-axis bSSFP anatomical cavity volumes; random-effects aggregation with reference-limit estimation. Myocardial tissue is excluded from the blood pool; imaging events and spatial segmentation are not reproduced by a 0D cavity.",
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2025-scmr-reference-values",
"sourceRange": "Men: EDVi 46-104, ESVi 11-41 mL/m2, EF 53-79%; women: 46-91, 11-34, 55-80%.",
"targetPopulation": "Pooled healthy adult CMR cohorts, sex-specific and mixed ages; not an age-40-49 or single joint population interval.",
"thresholdVerification": "context-only"
},
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "Retain both comparisons rather than selecting the sex that admits the candidate; no new gate or joint-95-percent normality claim.",
"locator": "Author website Table 37 (men) and Table 7 (women), 40-49-year column, LV rows",
"observationMeaning": "CMR anatomical segmentation, BSA-indexed volumes and EF; both ventricles can be compared in the same stratum without joining different modalities.",
"sourceId": "raisi-estabragh-2024-hhc-anatomical-tables",
"sourceRange": "Men: EDVi 51-102, ESVi 13-40 mL/m2, EF 53-77%; women: 49-88, 13-33, 56-78%.",
"targetPopulation": "Illustrative same-study White adults aged 40-49; variable-dependent N 378-447 men and 458-518 women. Neither stratum is assigned to the model.",
"thresholdVerification": "context-only"
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "literature-context-plus-engineering-envelope"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"changeReason": "Retain broad RV size/function safety bounds without extending the current systemic and left-heart claim.",
"checkIds": [
"right-ventricle.edv-index",
"right-ventricle.esv-index",
"right-ventricle.ejection-fraction"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [
"lang-ase-eacvi-2015-3de-rv"
],
"evaluationRole": "physiological-target",
"evidenceGap": "The volume bounds match a union of male/female 3D-echo ranges, not a population-specific or cross-modality range. The EF endpoints combine age/sex subgroup extremes rather than defining a single healthy cohort.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "right-ventricular-indexed-size-function",
"measurementMeaning": "Valve-event-defined 0D RV volumes indexed to the reference BSA and their event-defined ejection fraction.",
"observationLimitations": "Native TV/PV closure volumes and derived EF do not specify a 3D-echo or CMR segmentation method. BSA indexing alone does not remove sex/age effects; EF and the two event volumes are algebraically linked.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "Volume bounds reproduce the sex-union. EF bounds span subgroup extremes, not a universal normal range.",
"locator": "Table 8 (p. 20); Supplemental Table 8 (p. 39.e13)",
"observationMeaning": "3D-echo RV volume segmentation and BSA indexing; subgroup EF limits are fifth/95th percentiles.",
"sourceId": "lang-2015-chamber-quantification",
"sourceRange": "Men: EDVi 35-87, ESVi 10-44 mL/m2; women: 32-74, 8-36. Subgroup EF extremes include 42% and 82%; general RV EF below 45% is abnormal.",
"targetPopulation": "Adult sex-specific 3D-echo data; supplemental RV EF limits further stratified by age."
},
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "Chosen volume bounds exclude substantial CMR-normal values; the 3D-echo corridor cannot be called a broad cross-modality RV normal interval.",
"locator": "Table 6 (p. 7)",
"observationMeaning": "1.5 T SSFP CMR with RV trabeculations and papillary muscles in the cavity; mean +/- 2 SD.",
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2015-cmr-normal-values",
"sourceRange": "Men: EDVi 61-121, ESVi 19-59 mL/m2, EF 52-72%; women: 48-112, 12-52, 51-71%.",
"targetPopulation": "Healthy adult cohorts aged 20-68 years, sex-specific results; indexed RV ESV uses the Hudsmith cohort."
},
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "This uses the anatomical RV counterpart of the LV comparison. Do not substitute age-specific smooth-contour RV rows or retroactively replace old check bounds.",
"locator": "Sections 2 and 4; Table 8 (papillary muscles/trabeculations in mass), not smooth-segmentation Table 9",
"observationMeaning": "Short-axis bSSFP anatomical RV cavity volume with myocardial tissue excluded from blood volume; event, geometric and segmentation correspondence to 0D remains approximate.",
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2025-scmr-reference-values",
"sourceRange": "Men: EDVi 49-117, ESVi 12-56 mL/m2, EF 44-77%; women: 47-99, 11-43, 49-77%.",
"targetPopulation": "Pooled healthy adult CMR cohorts, sex-specific and mixed ages. Constituent cohorts differ from LV Table 2; marginal limits do not define a joint healthy subject.",
"thresholdVerification": "context-only"
},
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "Provides a coherent same-study alternative for future prospective design. BSA1.9 alone does not select either column, and the current upper EDVi bound is not verified by this study.",
"locator": "Author website Table 37 (men) and Table 7 (women), 40-49-year column, RV rows",
"observationMeaning": "CMR anatomical segmentation and BSA indexation, same subject strata and measurement convention as the LV comparison.",
"sourceId": "raisi-estabragh-2024-hhc-anatomical-tables",
"sourceRange": "Men: EDVi 61-118, ESVi 21-55 mL/m2, EF 44-71%; women: 53-97, 17-42, 49-73%.",
"targetPopulation": "Illustrative same-study White adults aged 40-49; variable-dependent N 378-447 men and 458-518 women. Neither stratum is assigned to the model.",
"thresholdVerification": "context-only"
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "literature-context-plus-engineering-envelope"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"changeReason": "Maintain broad resting forward-flow compatibility across the admitted HR values.",
"checkIds": [
"systemic-forward-flow.cardiac-index",
"systemic-forward-flow.stroke-volume-index"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [
"cardiac-index-clinical-reference",
"resting-indexed-flow-reference"
],
"evaluationRole": "physiological-target",
"evidenceGap": "CI has an exact guideline interval, but SVI is a cross-source construction choice. The retained Barratt-Boyes binding was metadata-verified only and does not provide a verified quantitative derivation here.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "indexed-systemic-forward-flow",
"measurementMeaning": "Positive-only native AoV flow integrated for stroke volume and converted to cardiac output over the completed beat, both indexed to reference BSA.",
"observationLimitations": "Forward volume is not signed net aortic flow or EDV-minus-ESV when regurgitation or other routes exist. CI and SVI are linked by HR, so at a fixed HR they are not independent targets; reference BSA and body habitus remain relevant.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "CI endpoints match exactly; SVI endpoints do not. Fick/thermodilution output is not necessarily the model's positive-only valve-flow output.",
"locator": "Table 11; section 5.1.12.1",
"observationMeaning": "Supine catheter pressure, mid-thoracic zero and end-expiratory reading; output by direct Fick or thermodilution.",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"sourceRange": "CI 2.5-4.0 L/min/m2; SVI 33-47 mL/m2.",
"targetPopulation": "Adult resting right-heart catheterization reference values summarized by the guideline, not a new sex-, age-, or BSA-stratified healthy cohort."
},
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen SVI interval is close to, but not identical to, a calculated mean +/- 2 SD interval of 37-65. Such a calculation is not a published universal normal cutoff.",
"coveredCheckIds": [
"systemic-forward-flow.cardiac-index",
"systemic-forward-flow.stroke-volume-index"
],
"locator": "Methods; healthy-group results and age analysis",
"observationMeaning": "Supine free-breathing ascending-aortic phase-contrast CMR at pulmonary-bifurcation level, distal to coronary origins; signed whole-cycle flow integrated for SV, Mosteller BSA. The paper attributes expected Qp/Qs around 1.04 to coronary flow of 3-5 percent, so absence of regurgitation alone does not equate this plane to native AoV output.",
"sourceId": "carlsson-2012-cmr-cardiac-output",
"sourceRange": "CI 3.2 +/- 0.5 L/min/m2; SVI 51 +/- 7 mL/m2 (mean +/- SD).",
"targetPopulation": "144 healthy nonathletic adults, 68 women, ages 21-81 (mean 39 +/- 16) years; BMI <=30, no cardiovascular disease or medication.",
"thresholdRationale": "Methods and healthy-group results checked in full text on 2026-09-06. These are cohort summaries, not direct verification of the retained construction endpoints; passage verification alone must not qualify those endpoints.",
"thresholdVerification": "context-only"
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "literature-context-plus-engineering-envelope"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "right-heart-sentinel",
"changeReason": "Record the existing Standard70 right-heart gradient sentinels without promoting them to left-objective groups or changing their numerical limits.",
"checkIds": [
"pulmonary-valve.mean-gradient",
"pulmonary-valve.peak-gradient"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "construction-guard",
"evidenceGap": "No source establishes the exact mean and peak healthy cutoffs for these pressure stations. These remain non-stenotic construction guards, not clinical normal-gradient intervals.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "pulmonary-valve-gradient",
"measurementMeaning": "Time-weighted mean and maximum raw RV-minus-PA node pressure difference while native PV flow is positive over the completed beat.",
"observationLimitations": "The model's hydraulic gradient is not a Doppler Bernoulli or recovered catheter gradient; an explicit outlet node does not provide spatial velocity, pressure recovery or an invasive sensor model.",
"sourceComparisons": [],
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "right-heart-sentinel",
"changeReason": "Record the existing Standard70 pulmonary ejection-time corridor with its missing method-matched normative evidence.",
"checkIds": [
"pulmonary-valve.ejection-time"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "physiological-target",
"evidenceGap": "No exact primary normal interval was identified for this observer and target population. Retain the frozen interval only as a provisional physiological target; left-sided LVET data do not establish a right-sided range.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "pulmonary-ejection-time",
"measurementMeaning": "Native PV zero-flow opening to exact completed-beat closure; the observer requires agreement with the completed beat's accumulated positive-flow duration.",
"observationLimitations": "A complete single ejection episode is required. This duration also enters right ICT, IRT and Tei calculations; hydraulic timing is not a Doppler-envelope or tissue-Doppler measurement and depends on HR/loading.",
"sourceComparisons": [],
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "right-heart-sentinel",
"changeReason": "Reclassify the existing Standard70 RV derivative corridors as reference warnings without altering the recorded numerical bounds.",
"checkIds": [
"right-ventricle.maximum-dpdt",
"right-ventricle.minimum-dpdt"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "reference-warning",
"evidenceGap": "No verified source establishes either frozen normal corridor. Sparse normal-PAP invasive data and a method-specific abnormal Doppler threshold justify contextual warnings, not hard healthy-population acceptance limits.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "right-ventricular-pressure-rate",
"measurementMeaning": "Maximum and minimum accepted-step finite-difference derivative of absolute intracavitary RV pressure over the completed beat.",
"observationLimitations": "These load- and bandwidth-dependent extrema are neither transmural pressure derivatives nor the mean RV-to-RA pressure-gradient rise inferred over a selected TR velocity interval. Signed negative extrema must not be confused with published pressure-fall magnitudes.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "This is not the maximum native intracavitary derivative and does not establish either chosen endpoint or a normal upper limit.",
"locator": "RV dP/dt section, pp. 158-159",
"observationMeaning": "TR Doppler 1-to-2 m/s upslope converted to a 12 mmHg pressure-gradient rise divided by time.",
"sourceId": "mukherjee-2025-right-heart-guideline",
"sourceRange": "RV dP/dt below 400 mmHg/s is abnormal for this Doppler method.",
"targetPopulation": "Adult right-heart echocardiography; normal-reference data are limited."
},
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "Both loading groups can fit the broad signed negative corridor. The reported summary values are not a healthy reference interval and cannot define its bounds.",
"locator": "Abstract; normal-PAP and pulmonary-hypertension groups",
"observationMeaning": "Maximal invasive RV pressure-fall magnitude; strong pressure-load dependence, with acquisition detail incompletely resolved by the abstract.",
"sourceId": "stein-1980-rv-pressure-fall",
"sourceRange": "Normal-PAP group 170 +/- 20 mmHg/s; pulmonary-hypertension groups 670 +/- 60 mmHg/s, with or without RV failure.",
"targetPopulation": "34 patients: eight with normal PAP, 17 with pulmonary hypertension, nine with pulmonary hypertension and RV failure; not a general healthy reference cohort."
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "right-heart-sentinel",
"changeReason": "Demote the native tricuspid flow-ratio corridor to context because Doppler velocity and respiratory averaging are different observations; resolved positive filling waves remain required.",
"checkIds": [
"tricuspid-flow.peak-e-to-a"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "reference-warning",
"evidenceGap": "The numerical corridor resembles a guideline Doppler interval but remains provisional for the native-flow observer; the source upper endpoint is exclusive whereas the frozen gate is inclusive.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "tricuspid-e-to-a",
"measurementMeaning": "Ratio of peak native tricuspid forward volume flow in early and atrial filling windows anchored to the observed atrial-capture event.",
"observationLimitations": "Requires identifiable windows and an observed post-capture inlet closure. Volume-flow peaks do not equal Doppler velocities if effective valve area changes; respiration, HR, rhythm, age and loading remain relevant.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen numeric endpoints match, but flow-versus-velocity and respiratory averaging differ; this is not method-matched validation.",
"locator": "Table 1; RV diastolic function, pp. 168-169",
"observationMeaning": "PW tricuspid inflow E/A velocities; end-expiratory averaging over at least five beats.",
"sourceId": "mukherjee-2025-right-heart-guideline",
"sourceRange": "Tricuspid E/A >=0.8 and <2.0.",
"targetPopulation": "Adult echocardiographic reference context."
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "right-heart-sentinel",
"changeReason": "Demote the unsupported hydraulic right ICT/IRT/Tei numeric corridors to context. Ordered complete valve events and algebraic consistency remain mandatory; a short RV isovolumic phase is not automatically pathological.",
"checkIds": [
"right-timing.ict",
"right-timing.irt",
"right-timing.tei-index"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "reference-warning",
"evidenceGap": "No primary source was identified for the chosen joint ICT/IRT/Tei corridors. The source below supplies method-specific context, not equivalent normal intervals; all three remain provisional physiological targets.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "right-ventricular-timing",
"measurementMeaning": "ICT from exact TV closure to PV zero-flow opening, IRT from exact PV closure to TV zero-flow opening, and (ICT + IRT) divided by the matched pulmonary ejection duration.",
"observationLimitations": "One complete valve-event sequence is required. Tei is algebraically linked to ICT, IRT and the separately checked pulmonary ET; PW-Doppler, TDI and hydraulic timings are different observations.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen upper IRT and Tei bounds are wider, and no chosen lower bound or ICT interval follows from these thresholds.",
"locator": "RV MPI, pp. 158-159; IVRT, pp. 168-169",
"observationMeaning": "PW-Doppler or tissue-Doppler MPI and tissue-Doppler IVRT, not native valve-flow events.",
"sourceId": "mukherjee-2025-right-heart-guideline",
"sourceRange": "MPI <0.40 by PW Doppler or <0.55 by TDI; IVRT <=73 ms by TDI.",
"targetPopulation": "Adult right-heart echocardiography."
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "right-heart-sentinel",
"changeReason": "Record Standard70 pulmonary ringing and re-ejection guards as construction-only waveform criteria.",
"checkIds": [
"waveform.PAP.single-peak-no-ringing",
"waveform.PV-flow.single-forward-episode",
"waveform.PV-flow.single-peak-no-ringing",
"waveform.PAP.post-PV-closure-rebound"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "construction-guard",
"evidenceGap": "No primary normal distribution supports the exact one-peak, one-episode or rebound cutoffs. A qualitative Doppler flow shape must not be cited as proof of these pressure-waveform thresholds.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "pulmonary-root-morphology",
"measurementMeaning": "Algorithmic full-cycle PA pressure peak count, thresholded PV forward-episode count, primary-episode PV flow peak count and maximal post-episode PA rebound.",
"observationLimitations": "The episode threshold and peak-prominence algorithm define these observations; the post-episode rebound is not an invasive dicrotic-notch metric. One peak does not characterize the entire pressure or flow contour.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "Qualitative flow context only; it establishes no peak-prominence, PAP peak-count or post-PV-closure rebound cutoff.",
"locator": "RVOT Doppler flow, p. 158",
"observationMeaning": "Qualitative RVOT Doppler velocity waveform: parabolic with a midsystolic peak.",
"sourceId": "mukherjee-2025-right-heart-guideline",
"sourceRange": null,
"targetPopulation": "Adult resting right-heart echocardiography."
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess"
}
],
"claimScope": {
"currentBaselineEvidenceRole": "construction",
"finalConfirmationStatus": "unavailable",
"reason": "Standard68/69 gates, Standard69 preload-reserve floors, and candidate outputs were inspected during model construction; no lineage-disjoint final evidence set has been frozen."
},
"evaluationPolicyId": "main-wire-standard70-baseline-evaluation-roles-v3",
"evidenceBindings": [
{
"canonicalSourceIds": [
"lang-2015-chamber-quantification"
],
"evidenceId": "lang-ase-eacvi-2015",
"limitations": "Modality-, sex-, age-, and body-size-dependent reference context; it does not directly define this model's joint admissible interval.",
"measurementMeaning": "Adult echocardiographic LV chamber volumes and systolic function.",
"useRole": "construction-context"
},
{
"canonicalSourceIds": [
"kou-2014-norre-chamber-reference"
],
"evidenceId": "kou-norre-2014",
"limitations": "The cohort and measurement method do not identify a unique 0D-model parameter vector or a joint multivariate normal region.",
"measurementMeaning": "Two-dimensional echocardiographic adult chamber-size reference ranges.",
"useRole": "construction-context"
},
{
"canonicalSourceIds": [
"kawel-boehm-2015-cmr-normal-values"
],
"evidenceId": "cmr-consolidated-normal-reference-2016",
"limitations": "The retained legacy evidence ID has a 2016 label but resolves to the 2015 publication; CMR and echocardiographic volumes are not interchangeable without a measurement model.",
"measurementMeaning": "CMR chamber-volume and function reference context across published cohorts.",
"useRole": "construction-context"
},
{
"canonicalSourceIds": [
"lang-2015-chamber-quantification"
],
"evidenceId": "lang-ase-eacvi-2015-3de-rv",
"limitations": "A 0D chamber volume is compared only as broad construction context; acquisition and segmentation conventions remain different.",
"measurementMeaning": "Adult three-dimensional echocardiographic RV volumes and ejection fraction.",
"useRole": "construction-context"
},
{
"canonicalSourceIds": [
"carlsson-2012-cmr-cardiac-output",
"barratt-boyes-wood-1958-healthy-hemodynamics"
],
"evidenceId": "cardiac-index-clinical-reference",
"limitations": "The model interval is an engineering synthesis across methods and cohorts, not a verbatim interval from either source.",
"measurementMeaning": "Resting forward cardiac output indexed to body surface area.",
"useRole": "construction-context"
},
{
"canonicalSourceIds": [
"carlsson-2012-cmr-cardiac-output",
"barratt-boyes-wood-1958-healthy-hemodynamics"
],
"evidenceId": "resting-indexed-flow-reference",
"limitations": "Stroke-volume index depends on heart rate, body-size convention, cohort, and acquisition method; the gate is a broad engineering envelope.",
"measurementMeaning": "Resting systemic forward stroke volume indexed to body surface area.",
"useRole": "construction-context"
},
{
"canonicalSourceIds": [
"mukherjee-2025-right-heart-guideline",
"kovacs-2009-healthy-pap-review"
],
"evidenceId": "mukherjee-ase-right-heart-2025",
"limitations": "This does not directly support the exact 10-35 mmHg model interval or validate the current pulmonary waveform shape.",
"measurementMeaning": "Right-heart echocardiographic assessment and healthy pulmonary arterial pressure context.",
"useRole": "construction-context"
},
{
"canonicalSourceIds": [
"zeder-2024-healthy-pawp-meta-analysis"
],
"evidenceId": "kovacs-pawp-healthy-meta-2024",
"limitations": "The retained legacy evidence ID uses the last author's name; the model reports mean LA pressure, not a simulated wedged-catheter measurement.",
"measurementMeaning": "Supine resting pulmonary arterial wedge pressure in healthy subjects.",
"useRole": "construction-context"
}
],
"observationMethodId": "main-wire-baseline-observation-v2",
"operatingTargetInterpretation": "Retained ET, pressures, indexed size, EF, CI and SVI are predeclared resting-baseline design targets. Failure means the intended operating point was not met, not physiological impossibility. Their source-specific observation limitations remain binding; no cross-modality universal normality is claimed.",
"policyRevisions": [
{
"changeReason": "Capture the current Standard68 mint policy and healthy-reference context after retrospective provenance repair.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"policySha256": "74f5b1ca712b56f304fee1ccf20da3e9dee8c7102213a2cb60dc2e7701cf3356",
"revisionId": "main-wire-standard68-baseline-policy-r1"
}
],
"preloadReservePolicyRevisions": [
{
"changeReason": "Freeze the Standard69-specific relative CO, pressure-flow slope, and relative EDV floors after exploratory candidate inspection. These are construction-only non-regression thresholds, not independently validated physiological cutoffs.",
"decisionTiming": "post-hoc-after-exploratory-candidate-inspection",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"policySha256": "dec7d6cdf587522c67892f0f94c910a2a8871a1aada6620c1a8778869109f4d5",
"revisionId": "main-wire-standard69-preload-reserve-policy-r1"
}
],
"referenceSubjectInterpretation": "BSA 1.9 m2 and sex-neutral synthetic anatomy do not identify age, sex or ethnicity. Conserved cavity blood volume is conceptually closer to anatomical segmentation excluding myocardial tissue from the blood pool than to smooth-contour volume that includes that tissue. This is an operator comparison, not a validated imaging-equivalence claim or permission to select the cohort that passes a candidate.",
"registryId": "main-wire-normal-reference-evidence-v1",
"schemaVersion": 1,
"sourceComparisonTiming": "retrospective-provenance-audit-not-original-cutoff-derivation",
"sources": [
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1093/eurheartj/ehu293"
},
"sourceId": "herbert-2014-central-pressure-reference",
"title": "Establishing reference values for central blood pressure and its amplification in a general healthy population and according to cardiovascular risk factors",
"url": "https://academic.oup.com/eurheartj/article/35/44/3122/2293191",
"verification": "primary-full-text-methods-and-results-checked",
"verificationScope": "Methods, Standardizing methodologies, and Tables 1-2 checked on 2026-09-07. Cuff-calibrated noninvasive cSBP differs from invasive intra-aortic pressure; Table 2 gives P10/P90, not 95% normal limits. Does not verify retained Ao-node bounds.",
"year": 2014
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1093/oxfordjournals.eurheartj.a062515",
"pmid": "3383877"
},
"sourceId": "van-oort-1988-pulmonary-doppler",
"title": "Reference values for pulsed Doppler signals from the blood flow velocity on both sides of the pulmonary valve",
"url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3383877/",
"verification": "primary-abstract-population-and-method-checked-not-full-text",
"verificationScope": "215 healthy subjects aged 1-65; pulmonary artery and RVOT Doppler measurements. Adult ejection-time limits not verified; acceleration time or LV timing is not substituted.",
"year": 1988
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1161/01.CIR.62.1.105",
"pmid": "7379273"
},
"sourceId": "murgo-1980-human-aortic-waveforms",
"title": "Aortic input impedance in normal man: relationship to pressure wave forms",
"url": "https://scholars.uthscsa.edu/es/publications/aortic-input-impedance-in-normal-man-relationship-to-pressure-wav/",
"verification": "author-institution-abstract-checked-not-full-text",
"year": 1980
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.14814/phy2.13160",
"pmid": "28351966"
},
"sourceId": "kohli-2017-normalized-human-pv-loops",
"title": "The quest for load-independent left ventricular chamber properties: exploring the normalized pressure-volume loop",
"url": "https://physoc.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.14814/phy2.13160",
"verification": "primary-full-text-methods-and-figures-4-5-checked",
"year": 2017
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1016/j.echo.2014.10.003",
"pmid": "25559473"
},
"sourceId": "lang-2015-chamber-quantification",
"title": "Recommendations for Cardiac Chamber Quantification by Echocardiography in Adults: An Update from the American Society of Echocardiography and the European Association of Cardiovascular Imaging",
"url": "https://www.asecho.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/2015_ChamberQuantificationREV.pdf",
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"year": 2015
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1093/ehjci/jet284",
"pmid": "24451180"
},
"sourceId": "kou-2014-norre-chamber-reference",
"title": "Echocardiographic reference ranges for normal cardiac chamber size: results from the NORRE study",
"url": "https://orbi.uliege.be/bitstream/2268/169431/1/Eur%20Heart%20J%20Cardiovasc%20Imaging-2014-Kou-680-90.pdf",
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"year": 2014
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1186/s12968-015-0111-7",
"pmid": "25928314"
},
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2015-cmr-normal-values",
"title": "Normal values for cardiovascular magnetic resonance in adults and children",
"url": "https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1186/s12968-015-0111-7.pdf",
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"year": 2015
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1186/1532-429X-14-51",
"pmid": "22839436"
},
"sourceId": "carlsson-2012-cmr-cardiac-output",
"title": "Cardiac output and cardiac index measured with cardiovascular magnetic resonance in healthy subjects, elite athletes and patients with congestive heart failure",
"url": "https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/1532-429X-14-51",
"verification": "primary-full-text-methods-and-results-checked",
"year": 2012
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1016/j.jocmr.2025.101853",
"pmcid": "PMC12159681"
},
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2025-scmr-reference-values",
"title": "Society for Cardiovascular Magnetic Resonance reference values (normal values) in cardiovascular magnetic resonance: 2025 update",
"url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12159681/",
"verification": "primary-full-text-methods-and-results-checked",
"verificationScope": "Sections 2-4 and Tables 2, 3, 8, 9; anatomical versus smooth segmentation and pooled adult sex-specific intervals. No current gate endpoints are verified by this source comparison.",
"year": 2025
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1016/j.jcmg.2024.01.009",
"pmid": "38613554"
},
"sourceId": "raisi-estabragh-2024-hhc-anatomical-tables",
"title": "Cardiovascular Magnetic Resonance Reference Ranges From the Healthy Hearts Consortium: author-published anatomical segmentation tables",
"url": "https://healthy-hearts.org.uk/tables/",
"verification": "author-published-tables-7-and-37-checked-not-full-article",
"verificationScope": "Full one-page source PDFs visually checked, including headers, age columns, units and N ranges. White men and women aged 40-49 are parallel illustrative comparisons, not the declared model subject or a new gate.",
"year": 2024
},
{
"identifiers": {
"pmid": "13514210"
},
"sourceId": "barratt-boyes-wood-1958-healthy-hemodynamics",
"title": "Cardiac output and related measurements and pressure values in the right heart and associated vessels, together with an analysis of the hemo-dynamic response to the inhalation of high oxygen mixtures in healthy subjects",
"url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/13514210/",
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"year": 1958
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1016/j.echo.2025.01.006",
"pmid": "40044341"
},
"sourceId": "mukherjee-2025-right-heart-guideline",
"title": "Guidelines for the Echocardiographic Assessment of the Right Heart in Adults and Special Considerations in Pulmonary Hypertension: Recommendations from the American Society of Echocardiography",
"url": "https://www.asecho.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/PIIS0894731725000379.pdf",
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"year": 2025
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1183/09031936.00145608"
},
"sourceId": "kovacs-2009-healthy-pap-review",
"title": "Pulmonary arterial pressure during rest and exercise in healthy subjects: a systematic review",
"url": "https://publications.ersnet.org/highwire_display/entity_view/node/476971/full",
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"year": 2009
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1183/13993003.00967-2024",
"pmid": "38964777"
},
"sourceId": "zeder-2024-healthy-pawp-meta-analysis",
"title": "Pulmonary arterial wedge pressure in healthy subjects: a meta-analysis",
"url": "https://publications.ersnet.org/content/erj/64/2/2400967",
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"year": 2024
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1183/13993003.00879-2022",
"pmid": "36028254"
},
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"title": "2022 ESC/ERS Guidelines for the diagnosis and treatment of pulmonary hypertension",
"url": "https://publications.ersnet.org/lookup/pmid/36028254",
"verification": "primary-table-11-and-rhc-methods-checked",
"verificationScope": "Table 11 and section 5.1.12.1, European Heart Journal pp. 3646-3647. Passage verification does not establish the model operator mapping or support wider retained pressure bounds.",
"year": 2022
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1007/s00392-023-02269-2"
},
"sourceId": "alhakak-2023-copenhagen-cardiac-time-intervals",
"title": "Age- and sex-based normal reference ranges of the cardiac time intervals: the Copenhagen City Heart Study",
"url": "https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00392-023-02269-2",
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"year": 2023
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1016/j.echo.2025.03.011"
},
"sourceId": "nagueh-2025-lv-diastolic-function",
"title": "Recommendations for the Evaluation of Left Ventricular Diastolic Function by Echocardiography and for Heart Failure With Preserved Ejection Fraction Diagnosis: An Update From the American Society of Echocardiography",
"url": "https://www.asecho.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/Left-Ventricular-Diastolic-Function.pdf",
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"year": 2025
},
{
"identifiers": {
"pmid": "602351"
},
"sourceId": "bussmann-1977-normal-lv-contractile-relaxation-reserve",
"title": "Contractile and relaxation reserve of the left ventricle. I. Normal left ventricle",
"url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/602351/",
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"year": 1977
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1161/01.cir.62.4.756",
"pmid": "7190882"
},
"sourceId": "hirota-1980-lv-relaxation",
"title": "A clinical study of left ventricular relaxation",
"url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7190882/",
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"year": 1980
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1378/chest.78.1.10",
"pmid": "7471826"
},
"sourceId": "stein-1980-rv-pressure-fall",
"title": "Effect of chronic pressure overload on the maximal rate of pressure fall of the right ventricle",
"url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7471826/",
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"year": 1980
}
],
"supplementalChecks": [
{
"boundRationale": "ASE 2025 section 2/Table 1 calls >48 ms prolonged. Contextual warning only, no arbitrary normal lower bound and no transfer of that threshold to Glantz. Hirota reports 33 +/- 8 ms in 18 selected controls, using P0 / peak negative dP/dt, not this fitted observer; that cohort is not a normal interval.",
"checkId": "left-ventricle.relaxation-tau",
"evaluationRole": "reference-warning",
"measurementMeaning": "Intracavitary LV Weiss zero-asymptote time-weighted log-pressure fit, from minimum dP/dt interval midpoint after AVC to next EDP + 5 mmHg before MVO; Glantz derivative-pressure free-asymptote sensitivity fit reported separately.",
"observationMethodId": "main-wire-lv-relaxation-tau-v1",
"qualityRationale": "Minimum window support and regression/residual limits are explicit provisional numerical fit-usability settings, not empirically established physiological limits. Both fits and the extrapolated Glantz pressure asymptote remain visible; neither may be selected for being closer to a target.",
"referenceSourceIds": [
"nagueh-2025-lv-diastolic-function",
"hirota-1980-lv-relaxation"
],
"referenceUpperMs": 48,
"requiredObservation": "Prospective v3 baseline assessment must contain an interpretable tau observation; unavailable or poor fit is unresolved analysis, not normality and not a disease diagnosis."
}
]
},
"policy": {
"anatomyRule": "For this sex-unspecified generic baseline only, automatic eligibility requires all six valid anatomical CMR comparisons inside BOTH declared sex strata. Otherwise require demographic/method review, not automatic disease rejection. This conservative design intersection does not assign sex or claim joint population normality; preset/patient fitting must use its own profile.",
"loadGuardRationale": "Keep a baseline away from low/high systemic load and high native end-filling pressure. Ao bounds are retained design choices, not derived from Herbert. LV native flow cessation may precede the pressure upstroke; <=16 is an approximate end-filling design ceiling, not validated catheter LVEDP equivalence or a lower normal limit.",
"numericalAndConstructionProvenance": "Inherited numerical/gradient/ringing checks resolve their existing per-check evidence; new rest criteria do not reinterpret the old physiological corridors or clear the old provenance audit.",
"operating": [
{
"basis": "source-informed-operating-target",
"locator": "Table 11, CI",
"lower": 2.5,
"metricId": "systemic-net-flow.cardiac-index",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"upper": 4
},
{
"basis": "source-informed-operating-target",
"locator": "Table 11, mean RAP",
"lower": 2,
"metricId": "central-venous-pressure.mean",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"upper": 6
},
{
"basis": "source-informed-operating-target",
"locator": "Table 11, mean PAP",
"lower": 8,
"metricId": "pulmonary-artery-pressure.mean",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"upper": 20
},
{
"basis": "retained-engineering-load-guard-NOT-source-derived-normal-range",
"locator": "Methods, invasive versus cuff-calibrated pressure distinction",
"lower": 90,
"metricId": "aortic-pressure.maximum",
"sourceId": "herbert-2014-central-pressure-reference",
"upper": 140
},
{
"basis": "retained-engineering-load-guard-NOT-source-derived-normal-range",
"locator": "Methods, DBP calibration; no central-DBP reference interval",
"lower": 60,
"metricId": "aortic-pressure.minimum",
"sourceId": "herbert-2014-central-pressure-reference",
"upper": 90
},
{
"basis": "source-informed-engineering-load-guard-NOT-method-matched-normal-range",
"locator": "Section2, Table1 p539 (>16), Figure1 p540",
"lower": null,
"metricId": "left-ventricle.native-end-filling-pressure",
"sourceId": "nagueh-2025-lv-diastolic-function",
"upper": 16
}
],
"policyId": "main-wire-prospective-baseline-admission-v1",
"regression": "__tests__/mainWireProspectiveBaselineAdmissionV1.test.ts",
"scope": "Resting unassisted nonshunting sinus research construction, BSA1.9, HR60 or70, zero intrathoracic reference. Scientific eligibility for exact-model promotion, not public mint or clinical normality.",
"warningRule": "Keep strict source comparisons for phasic PAP, ET, anatomy and SVI plus historical timing/E-A/dPdt/roundness context. A warning never excuses missing, nonfinite or invalid observations. Preserve unexplained ringing/closure-rebound construction holds; pressure-peak phase and PV roundness are not universal normality gates."
}
},
"methodId": "main-wire-baseline-observation-v2",
"reference": {
"clinicalValidationClaimed": false,
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"label": "baseline",
"referenceId": "baseline",
"target": {
"admissionPolicyId": "main-wire-prospective-baseline-admission-v1",
"comparisonProfileId": "main-wire-resting-reference-profile-v1",
"evaluationRolePolicyId": "main-wire-standard70-baseline-evaluation-roles-v3",
"evidenceRegistryId": "main-wire-normal-reference-evidence-v1",
"kind": "construction-corridors",
"referenceOutputsAreTargets": false
}
}
}
},
{
"modelId": "circleheart.main-wire-integrated-transaction-v3.static-anatomy.standard-74",
"numericalSourceSha256": "f92b231c6f11c4746bb9f47e96d89cbe6f17692f57f704cca5ff82eb1ee2b326",
"resultSha256": "04f0c00b4eee5014418049a4786e385039ade65dda86b731d15b8ee86bd087fc",
"nominalDtSec": 0.001,
"initialization": {
"kind": "cold"
},
"cycles": 56,
"rest": {
"assessment": {
"anatomyReviewRequired": false,
"comparison": {
"admissionDecision": "not-performed",
"applicabilityReview": "Caller must separately establish settlement, no support/shunt and correct pressure reference. This readback does not infer those conditions from a plausible scalar or small flow mismatch.",
"endTimeSec": 47.86799999999995,
"entries": [
{
"actual": 0.25499999999999545,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": 0.248,
"upper": 0.336
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "Copenhagen pooled healthy adults; HR 63 +/- 10"
}
],
"locator": "Methods, Cardiac time intervals; Table 2, pooled LVET 95% prediction interval",
"mapping": "Native accumulated positive AoV-flow duration, not mitral-leaflet color-TDI timing. Opening-to-closure interpretation requires the separate morphology/timing observer to establish one forward episode; this comparison does not enforce that condition. No HR correction or method equivalence inferred.",
"metricId": "aortic-valve.ejection-time",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "method-context",
"sourceId": "alhakak-2023-copenhagen-cardiac-time-intervals",
"unit": "s"
},
{
"actual": 0.25800000000000267,
"comparisons": [],
"locator": "Abstract: population and recording stations; no numeric adult ET interval verified",
"mapping": "Native accumulated positive PV-flow duration; the separate morphology/timing observer must establish one forward episode. Doppler PA versus RVOT station, respiration and HR differ. No adult ET bounds inferred from acceleration time, tissue S-wave duration or LVET.",
"metricId": "pulmonary-valve.ejection-time",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "method-context",
"sourceId": "van-oort-1988-pulmonary-doppler",
"unit": "s"
},
{
"actual": 111.35437809515427,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": 80,
"upper": 110
},
"statistic": "published-10th-90th-percentiles",
"status": "outside-source-range",
"stratum": "women 20-29"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 92,
"upper": 115
},
"statistic": "published-10th-90th-percentiles",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "men 20-29"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 84,
"upper": 119
},
"statistic": "published-10th-90th-percentiles",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "women 30-39"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 88,
"upper": 120
},
"statistic": "published-10th-90th-percentiles",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "men 30-39"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 87,
"upper": 123
},
"statistic": "published-10th-90th-percentiles",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "women 40-49"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 90,
"upper": 123
},
"statistic": "published-10th-90th-percentiles",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "men 40-49"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 93,
"upper": 127
},
"statistic": "published-10th-90th-percentiles",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "women 50-59"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 96,
"upper": 126
},
"statistic": "published-10th-90th-percentiles",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "men 50-59"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 97,
"upper": 129
},
"statistic": "published-10th-90th-percentiles",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "women 60-69"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 97,
"upper": 128
},
"statistic": "published-10th-90th-percentiles",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "men 60-69"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 100,
"upper": 131
},
"statistic": "published-10th-90th-percentiles",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "women 70+"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 99,
"upper": 130
},
"statistic": "published-10th-90th-percentiles",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "men 70+"
}
],
"locator": "Methods, Standardizing methodologies; Table 2, Normal population, all adult age rows",
"mapping": "Model Ao root pressure is invasive-like. Source cSBP is cuff-calibrated noninvasive estimation; authors explicitly distinguish it from higher invasive intra-aortic SBP. Published P10/P90 are context, not 95% normal cutoffs or a model calibration target.",
"metricId": "aortic-pressure.maximum",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "method-context",
"sourceId": "herbert-2014-central-pressure-reference",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 77.54846419227914,
"comparisons": [],
"locator": "Methods, Standardizing methodologies; Table 1, brachial DBP summary",
"mapping": "Source assumes DBP consistency for calibration, but does not publish a central-DBP normal interval. Do not turn the brachial mean +/- SD into a verified Ao-node cutoff.",
"metricId": "aortic-pressure.minimum",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "method-context",
"sourceId": "herbert-2014-central-pressure-reference",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 3.0758312312680354,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": 2,
"upper": 6
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "resting adult RHC reference"
}
],
"locator": "Table 11, mean RAP; section 5.1.12.1",
"mapping": "Absolute lumped pressure, no respiratory cycle; compare with supine end-expiratory catheter values at the specified zero. No catheter transfer function or peripheral waveform is simulated.",
"metricId": "central-venous-pressure.mean",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "operating-comparison",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 26.166946634024157,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": 15,
"upper": 30
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "resting adult RHC reference"
}
],
"locator": "Table 11, systolic PAP; section 5.1.12.1",
"mapping": "Absolute lumped pressure, no respiratory cycle; compare with supine end-expiratory catheter values at the specified zero. No catheter transfer function or peripheral waveform is simulated.",
"metricId": "pulmonary-artery-pressure.maximum",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "operating-comparison",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 12.03387992696858,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": 4,
"upper": 12
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "outside-source-range",
"stratum": "resting adult RHC reference"
}
],
"locator": "Table 11, diastolic PAP; section 5.1.12.1",
"mapping": "Absolute lumped pressure, no respiratory cycle; compare with supine end-expiratory catheter values at the specified zero. No catheter transfer function or peripheral waveform is simulated.",
"metricId": "pulmonary-artery-pressure.minimum",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "operating-comparison",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 17.871712818401345,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": 8,
"upper": 20
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "resting adult RHC reference"
}
],
"locator": "Table 11, mean PAP; section 5.1.12.1",
"mapping": "Absolute lumped pressure, no respiratory cycle; compare with supine end-expiratory catheter values at the specified zero. No catheter transfer function or peripheral waveform is simulated.",
"metricId": "pulmonary-artery-pressure.mean",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "operating-comparison",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 8.377448599630208,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": null,
"upper": 15
},
"statistic": "clinical-upper-limit",
"status": "not-above-source-upper-limit",
"stratum": "adult RHC PAWP clinical reference"
}
],
"locator": "Table 11, PAWP; section 5.1.12.1",
"mapping": "Observed quantity remains LA mean, not a wedge measurement or LVEDP. PAWP <=15 is the guideline clinical reference upper limit, not a healthy-cohort distribution or a verified model LA-to-PAWP transfer. No lower bound is invented.",
"metricId": "pcwp-surrogate.mean",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "method-context",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 75.64295371315426,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": 46,
"upper": 104
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "men, pooled adult ages"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 46,
"upper": 91
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "women, pooled adult ages"
}
],
"locator": "Table 2, anatomical segmentation, sex-specific indexed volume/EF rows",
"mapping": "Native valve-closure cavity blood volumes, BSA indexed; compared with anatomical bSSFP CMR excluding papillary/trabecular myocardium from the blood pool. No validated image segmentation or age/sex assignment; separate marginal ranges are not a joint distribution. EF is derived from EDV and ESV.",
"metricId": "left-ventricle.edv-index",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "demographic-comparison",
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2025-scmr-reference-values",
"unit": "mL/m2"
},
{
"actual": 33.45028226585985,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": 11,
"upper": 41
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "men, pooled adult ages"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 11,
"upper": 34
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "women, pooled adult ages"
}
],
"locator": "Table 2, anatomical segmentation, sex-specific indexed volume/EF rows",
"mapping": "Native valve-closure cavity blood volumes, BSA indexed; compared with anatomical bSSFP CMR excluding papillary/trabecular myocardium from the blood pool. No validated image segmentation or age/sex assignment; separate marginal ranges are not a joint distribution. EF is derived from EDV and ESV.",
"metricId": "left-ventricle.esv-index",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "demographic-comparison",
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2025-scmr-reference-values",
"unit": "mL/m2"
},
{
"actual": 0.5577872012678575,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": 0.53,
"upper": 0.79
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "men, pooled adult ages"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 0.55,
"upper": 0.8
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "women, pooled adult ages"
}
],
"locator": "Table 2, anatomical segmentation, sex-specific indexed volume/EF rows",
"mapping": "Native valve-closure cavity blood volumes, BSA indexed; compared with anatomical bSSFP CMR excluding papillary/trabecular myocardium from the blood pool. No validated image segmentation or age/sex assignment; separate marginal ranges are not a joint distribution. EF is derived from EDV and ESV.",
"metricId": "left-ventricle.ejection-fraction",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "demographic-comparison",
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2025-scmr-reference-values",
"unit": "fraction"
},
{
"actual": 74.05801460699432,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": 49,
"upper": 117
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "men, pooled adult ages"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 47,
"upper": 99
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "women, pooled adult ages"
}
],
"locator": "Table 8, anatomical segmentation, sex-specific indexed volume/EF rows",
"mapping": "Native valve-closure cavity blood volumes, BSA indexed; compared with anatomical bSSFP CMR excluding papillary/trabecular myocardium from the blood pool. No validated image segmentation or age/sex assignment; separate marginal ranges are not a joint distribution. EF is derived from EDV and ESV.",
"metricId": "right-ventricle.edv-index",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "demographic-comparison",
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2025-scmr-reference-values",
"unit": "mL/m2"
},
{
"actual": 31.86570133636767,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": 12,
"upper": 56
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "men, pooled adult ages"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 11,
"upper": 43
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "women, pooled adult ages"
}
],
"locator": "Table 8, anatomical segmentation, sex-specific indexed volume/EF rows",
"mapping": "Native valve-closure cavity blood volumes, BSA indexed; compared with anatomical bSSFP CMR excluding papillary/trabecular myocardium from the blood pool. No validated image segmentation or age/sex assignment; separate marginal ranges are not a joint distribution. EF is derived from EDV and ESV.",
"metricId": "right-ventricle.esv-index",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "demographic-comparison",
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2025-scmr-reference-values",
"unit": "mL/m2"
},
{
"actual": 0.5697197459927834,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": 0.44,
"upper": 0.77
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "men, pooled adult ages"
},
{
"range": {
"lower": 0.49,
"upper": 0.77
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "women, pooled adult ages"
}
],
"locator": "Table 8, anatomical segmentation, sex-specific indexed volume/EF rows",
"mapping": "Native valve-closure cavity blood volumes, BSA indexed; compared with anatomical bSSFP CMR excluding papillary/trabecular myocardium from the blood pool. No validated image segmentation or age/sex assignment; separate marginal ranges are not a joint distribution. EF is derived from EDV and ESV.",
"metricId": "right-ventricle.ejection-fraction",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "demographic-comparison",
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2025-scmr-reference-values",
"unit": "fraction"
},
{
"actual": 2.953486998647304,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": 2.5,
"upper": 4
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "resting adult RHC reference"
}
],
"historicalCheckId": "systemic-forward-flow.cardiac-index",
"locator": "Table 11, CI; section 5.1.12.1, direct Fick/thermodilution",
"mapping": "Use signed native AoV NET output/BSA under a distinct metric ID. Interpretation as whole-circulation CO requires a settled unassisted nonshunting state; no positive-only flow substitution or distal-CMR-plane equivalence.",
"metricId": "systemic-net-flow.cardiac-index",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "operating-comparison",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"unit": "L/min/m2"
},
{
"actual": 42.19267140924705,
"comparisons": [
{
"range": {
"lower": 33,
"upper": 47
},
"statistic": "published-reference-interval",
"status": "inside-source-range",
"stratum": "resting adult RHC reference"
}
],
"historicalCheckId": "systemic-forward-flow.stroke-volume-index",
"locator": "Table 11, SVI; section 5.1.12.1",
"mapping": "Signed native AoV NET volume/BSA. CI = HR * SVI / 1000, so this is a coupled comparison, not a second independent fitting objective. The CI-conditional interval is reported separately; it is not this published SVI interval.",
"metricId": "systemic-net-flow.stroke-volume-index",
"observationStatus": "observed",
"role": "coupled-flow-context",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"unit": "mL/m2"
}
],
"flowCoupling": {
"basis": "signed-native-AoV-net-flow",
"ciConditionalSviIntervalMlPerM2": {
"lower": 35.71428571428558,
"upper": 57.14285714285693
},
"ciMinusHrTimesSviOver1000": -4.440892098500626e-16,
"conditionalIntervalIsPublishedSviReference": false,
"forwardMinusNetCi": 0,
"pulmonaryMinusAorticNetFlowLPerMin": -0.00004763389824535835
},
"heartRateBpm": 70.00000000000026,
"nativeLvEndDiastolicPressure": {
"absolutePressureMmHg": 10.940681487530963,
"differenceFromMeanLaMmHg": 2.563232887900755,
"externalPressureMmHg": 0,
"timeSec": 47.11571428571428,
"transmuralPressureMmHg": 10.940681487530963
},
"observationApplicabilityEstablished": false,
"physiologicalNormalityClaimed": false,
"profileId": "main-wire-resting-reference-profile-v1",
"scope": "Settled resting unassisted, nonshunting sinus baseline; source comparisons are not patient-fit targets or a replacement for numerical/construction checks.",
"selectionRule": "Report every declared comparison, never select a stratum because it passes. This comparison profile alone provides no sex-union, sex-intersection or summed-score admission rule; any consuming design decision must be explicit and separately versioned.",
"startTimeSec": 47.0108571428571,
"subject": {
"age": "unspecified",
"allowedHeartRatesBpm": [
60,
70
],
"bodySurfaceAreaM2": 1.9,
"ethnicity": "unspecified",
"sex": "unspecified"
}
},
"historicalWarnings": [
{
"actual": 2600.069423820747,
"checkId": "left-ventricle.maximum-dpdt",
"maximum": 2500,
"minimum": 1200,
"status": "failed",
"unit": "mmHg/s"
},
{
"actual": -1556.3378582564847,
"checkId": "left-ventricle.minimum-dpdt",
"maximum": -700,
"minimum": -1400,
"status": "failed",
"unit": "mmHg/s"
},
{
"actual": 0.0931428571428583,
"checkId": "timing.ict",
"maximum": 0.07,
"minimum": 0.02,
"status": "failed",
"unit": "s"
},
{
"actual": 0.7338935574229916,
"checkId": "timing.tei-index",
"maximum": 0.65,
"minimum": 0.29,
"status": "failed",
"unit": "ratio"
}
],
"invalidOrFailedRetained": [],
"operating": [
{
"actual": 2.953486998647304,
"basis": "source-informed-operating-target",
"locator": "Table 11, CI",
"lower": 2.5,
"metricId": "systemic-net-flow.cardiac-index",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"status": "passed",
"upper": 4
},
{
"actual": 3.0758312312680354,
"basis": "source-informed-operating-target",
"locator": "Table 11, mean RAP",
"lower": 2,
"metricId": "central-venous-pressure.mean",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"status": "passed",
"upper": 6
},
{
"actual": 17.871712818401345,
"basis": "source-informed-operating-target",
"locator": "Table 11, mean PAP",
"lower": 8,
"metricId": "pulmonary-artery-pressure.mean",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"status": "passed",
"upper": 20
},
{
"actual": 111.35437809515427,
"basis": "retained-engineering-load-guard-NOT-source-derived-normal-range",
"locator": "Methods, invasive versus cuff-calibrated pressure distinction",
"lower": 90,
"metricId": "aortic-pressure.maximum",
"sourceId": "herbert-2014-central-pressure-reference",
"status": "passed",
"upper": 140
},
{
"actual": 77.54846419227914,
"basis": "retained-engineering-load-guard-NOT-source-derived-normal-range",
"locator": "Methods, DBP calibration; no central-DBP reference interval",
"lower": 60,
"metricId": "aortic-pressure.minimum",
"sourceId": "herbert-2014-central-pressure-reference",
"status": "passed",
"upper": 90
},
{
"actual": 10.940681487530963,
"basis": "source-informed-engineering-load-guard-NOT-method-matched-normal-range",
"locator": "Section2, Table1 p539 (>16), Figure1 p540",
"lower": null,
"metricId": "left-ventricle.native-end-filling-pressure",
"sourceId": "nagueh-2025-lv-diastolic-function",
"status": "passed",
"upper": 16
}
],
"status": "passed",
"unavailable": []
},
"observation": {
"checks": [
{
"actual": 1,
"checkId": "settlement.period1",
"maximum": 1,
"minimum": 1,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "bool"
},
{
"actual": 1,
"checkId": "waveform.LVP.single-peak-no-ringing",
"maximum": 1,
"minimum": 1,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "bool"
},
{
"actual": 0.2047946870215112,
"checkId": "waveform.LVP.rounded-not-plateau",
"maximum": 0.35,
"minimum": 0.08,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "fraction"
},
{
"actual": 1,
"checkId": "waveform.RVP.single-peak-no-ringing",
"maximum": 1,
"minimum": 1,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "bool"
},
{
"actual": 0.18713168215863774,
"checkId": "waveform.RVP.rounded-not-plateau",
"maximum": 0.35,
"minimum": 0.08,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "fraction"
},
{
"actual": 4.2688920544472495,
"checkId": "aortic-valve.mean-gradient",
"maximum": 5,
"minimum": 0,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 7.856587691589837,
"checkId": "aortic-valve.peak-gradient",
"maximum": 10,
"minimum": 0,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 0.25499999999999545,
"checkId": "aortic-valve.ejection-time",
"maximum": 0.34,
"minimum": 0.24,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "s"
},
{
"actual": 2600.069423820747,
"checkId": "left-ventricle.maximum-dpdt",
"maximum": 2500,
"minimum": 1200,
"status": "failed",
"unit": "mmHg/s"
},
{
"actual": -1556.3378582564847,
"checkId": "left-ventricle.minimum-dpdt",
"maximum": -700,
"minimum": -1400,
"status": "failed",
"unit": "mmHg/s"
},
{
"actual": 0.9290646643310849,
"checkId": "mitral-flow.peak-e-to-a",
"maximum": 2,
"minimum": 0.8,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "ratio"
},
{
"actual": 0.0931428571428583,
"checkId": "timing.ict",
"maximum": 0.07,
"minimum": 0.02,
"status": "failed",
"unit": "s"
},
{
"actual": 0.0940000000000012,
"checkId": "timing.irt",
"maximum": 0.134,
"minimum": 0.059,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "s"
},
{
"actual": 0.7338935574229916,
"checkId": "timing.tei-index",
"maximum": 0.65,
"minimum": 0.29,
"status": "failed",
"unit": "ratio"
},
{
"actual": 111.35437809515427,
"checkId": "aortic-pressure.maximum",
"maximum": 140,
"minimum": 90,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 77.54846419227914,
"checkId": "aortic-pressure.minimum",
"maximum": 90,
"minimum": 60,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 26.166946634024157,
"checkId": "pulmonary-artery-pressure.maximum",
"maximum": 35,
"minimum": 15,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 12.03387992696858,
"checkId": "pulmonary-artery-pressure.minimum",
"maximum": 15,
"minimum": 4,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 3.0758312312680354,
"checkId": "central-venous-pressure.mean",
"maximum": 8,
"minimum": 1,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 8.377448599630208,
"checkId": "pcwp-surrogate.mean",
"maximum": 13,
"minimum": 4,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 75.64295371315426,
"checkId": "left-ventricle.edv-index",
"maximum": 99,
"minimum": 34,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mL/m2"
},
{
"actual": 33.45028226585985,
"checkId": "left-ventricle.esv-index",
"maximum": 40,
"minimum": 10,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mL/m2"
},
{
"actual": 0.5577872012678575,
"checkId": "left-ventricle.ejection-fraction",
"maximum": 0.74,
"minimum": 0.52,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "ratio"
},
{
"actual": 74.05801460699432,
"checkId": "right-ventricle.edv-index",
"maximum": 87,
"minimum": 32,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mL/m2"
},
{
"actual": 31.86570133636767,
"checkId": "right-ventricle.esv-index",
"maximum": 44,
"minimum": 8,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mL/m2"
},
{
"actual": 0.5697197459927834,
"checkId": "right-ventricle.ejection-fraction",
"maximum": 0.82,
"minimum": 0.42,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "ratio"
},
{
"actual": 2.9534869986473034,
"checkId": "systemic-forward-flow.cardiac-index",
"maximum": 4,
"minimum": 2.5,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "L/min/m2"
},
{
"actual": 42.19267140924705,
"checkId": "systemic-forward-flow.stroke-volume-index",
"maximum": 65,
"minimum": 35,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mL/m2"
},
{
"actual": 4.453576925688471,
"checkId": "pulmonary-valve.mean-gradient",
"maximum": 5,
"minimum": 0,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 7.415462429217236,
"checkId": "pulmonary-valve.peak-gradient",
"maximum": 10,
"minimum": 0,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mmHg"
},
{
"actual": 0.25800000000000267,
"checkId": "pulmonary-valve.ejection-time",
"maximum": 0.35,
"minimum": 0.22,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "s"
},
{
"actual": 602.8260931029814,
"checkId": "right-ventricle.maximum-dpdt",
"maximum": 1000,
"minimum": 300,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mmHg/s"
},
{
"actual": -375.68447322572655,
"checkId": "right-ventricle.minimum-dpdt",
"maximum": -150,
"minimum": -700,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mmHg/s"
},
{
"actual": 1.089865656083185,
"checkId": "tricuspid-flow.peak-e-to-a",
"maximum": 2,
"minimum": 0.8,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "ratio"
},
{
"actual": 0.027999999999998693,
"checkId": "right-timing.ict",
"maximum": 0.09,
"minimum": 0.02,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "s"
},
{
"actual": 0.06400000000000006,
"checkId": "right-timing.irt",
"maximum": 0.12,
"minimum": 0.03,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "s"
},
{
"actual": 0.3565891472868132,
"checkId": "right-timing.tei-index",
"maximum": 0.65,
"minimum": 0.25,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "ratio"
},
{
"actual": 1,
"checkId": "waveform.PAP.single-peak-no-ringing",
"maximum": 1,
"minimum": 1,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "count"
},
{
"actual": 1,
"checkId": "waveform.PV-flow.single-forward-episode",
"maximum": 1,
"minimum": 1,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "count"
},
{
"actual": 1,
"checkId": "waveform.PV-flow.single-peak-no-ringing",
"maximum": 1,
"minimum": 1,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "count"
},
{
"actual": 0,
"checkId": "waveform.PAP.post-PV-closure-rebound",
"maximum": 0.5,
"minimum": 0,
"status": "passed",
"unit": "mmHg"
}
],
"measured": {
"LVP": {
"centralRangeFraction": 0.2047946870215112,
"forwardEpisodeCount": 1,
"peakPhase01": 0.746031746031746,
"significantPeakCount": 1,
"totalVariationRatio": 1.1735192456354728
},
"RVP": {
"centralRangeFraction": 0.18713168215863774,
"forwardEpisodeCount": 1,
"peakPhase01": 0.6745098039215687,
"significantPeakCount": 1,
"totalVariationRatio": 1.2871731286441173
},
"aorticValve": {
"ejectionTimeSec": 0.25499999999999545,
"meanGradientMmHg": 4.2688920544472495,
"peakGradientMmHg": 7.856587691589837
},
"cardiacSizeAndFunction": {
"bodySurfaceAreaM2": 1.9,
"leftVentricle": {
"ejectionFraction01": 0.5577872012678575,
"endDiastolicVolumeIndexMlPerM2": 75.64295371315426,
"endDiastolicVolumeMl": 143.72161205499307,
"endSystolicVolumeIndexMlPerM2": 33.45028226585985,
"endSystolicVolumeMl": 63.555536305133714
},
"rightVentricle": {
"ejectionFraction01": 0.5697197459927834,
"endDiastolicVolumeIndexMlPerM2": 74.05801460699432,
"endDiastolicVolumeMl": 140.7102277532892,
"endSystolicVolumeIndexMlPerM2": 31.86570133636767,
"endSystolicVolumeMl": 60.54483253909857
},
"systemicForwardFlow": {
"cardiacIndexLPerMinPerM2": 2.9534869986473034,
"cardiacOutputLPerMin": 5.611625297429876,
"strokeVolumeIndexMlPerM2": 42.19267140924705,
"strokeVolumeMl": 80.16607567756938
}
},
"hemodynamicPressure": {
"aortic": {
"maximumMmHg": 111.35437809515427,
"minimumMmHg": 77.54846419227914
},
"centralVenousMeanMmHg": 3.0758312312680354,
"pcwpSurrogateMeanMmHg": 8.377448599630208,
"pulmonaryArtery": {
"maximumMmHg": 26.166946634024157,
"minimumMmHg": 12.03387992696858
}
},
"leftVentricle": {
"maximumDpDtMmHgPerSec": 2600.069423820747,
"minimumDpDtMmHgPerSec": -1556.3378582564847
},
"mitralFlow": {
"peakAMlPerSec": 425.6736983557625,
"peakEMlPerSec": 395.478391677468,
"peakEToA": 0.9290646643310849
},
"pulmonaryRootMorphology": {
"maximumPostClosurePapReboundMmHg": 0,
"papSignificantPeakCount": 1,
"pvFlowSignificantPeakCount": 1,
"pvForwardEpisodeCount": 1
},
"pulmonaryValve": {
"ejectionTimeSec": 0.25800000000000267,
"meanGradientMmHg": 4.453576925688471,
"peakGradientMmHg": 7.415462429217236
},
"rightTiming": {
"ictSec": 0.027999999999998693,
"irtSec": 0.06400000000000006,
"teiIndex": 0.3565891472868132
},
"rightVentricle": {
"maximumDpDtMmHgPerSec": 602.8260931029814,
"minimumDpDtMmHgPerSec": -375.68447322572655
},
"timing": {
"ictSec": 0.0931428571428583,
"irtSec": 0.0940000000000012,
"teiIndex": 0.7338935574229916
},
"tricuspidFlow": {
"peakAMlPerSec": 328.9148690433511,
"peakEMlPerSec": 358.4730195454467,
"peakEToA": 1.089865656083185
}
}
},
"referenceId": "baseline",
"status": "passed"
},
"referenceContext": {
"assessmentPolicy": {
"evidence": {
"checkGroups": [
{
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"changeReason": "Fail closed before interpreting any derived baseline measurement.",
"checkIds": [
"settlement.period1"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "numerical-quality",
"evidenceGap": "No clinical population interval applies to an exact periodic-classifier contract.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "settlement",
"measurementMeaning": "Whether the exact periodic classifier established the required period-one terminal state.",
"observationLimitations": "Period-one settlement is numerical admissibility, not physiological normality or independent model validation.",
"sourceComparisons": [],
"thresholdBasis": "exact-contract"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"changeReason": "Retain the artifact guards motivated by Standard65-to-68 ringing, separately from unvalidated contour reference corridors. This is a current-model construction requirement, not a claim that every healthy human trace has one peak.",
"checkIds": [
"waveform.LVP.single-peak-no-ringing",
"waveform.RVP.single-peak-no-ringing"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "construction-guard",
"evidenceGap": "No primary healthy-cohort distribution supports the exact peak-count or variation cutoffs. They remain transparent construction guards; no clinical normality follows from passing.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "ventricular-pressure-morphology",
"measurementMeaning": "Algorithmic peak count, total variation and episode count of pressure during the associated semilunar-valve forward-flow episode.",
"observationLimitations": "Prominence and variation depend on accepted sampling and the thresholded forward-flow episode. Real arterial reflection can produce a systolic shoulder or secondary rise; the current lumped model has no explicit propagation/reflection mechanism, so that observation does not explain its numerical or coupled-mode ringing.",
"sourceComparisons": [],
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"changeReason": "Demote the frozen central-range and peak-index corridors to descriptive warnings: no matched normal distribution supports the limits, and a single compound failure previously conflated late pressure peak with flatness. Numerical thresholds are not widened to admit a candidate.",
"checkIds": [
"waveform.LVP.rounded-not-plateau",
"waveform.RVP.rounded-not-plateau"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "reference-warning",
"evidenceGap": "No matched healthy LV or RV reference interval was identified for centralRangeFraction 0.08-0.35 or peakPhase01 0.2-0.8. These values remain visible warnings, not independent scientific validation or permission to accept unexplained ringing.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "ventricular-pressure-contour-reference",
"measurementMeaning": "Central accepted-sample-index pressure range divided by full ejection pressure range, jointly with the first maximum's normalized sample index. The check reports peak index when that alone fails; it is not PV-loop curvature or a time-weighted shape measurement.",
"observationLimitations": "Sample-index phase is not elapsed-time phase on nonuniform accepted steps. Pressure versus time and pressure versus volume have different curvature because ejection flow varies. Resolution, pressure loading and the selected episode affect these summaries; RV and LV cannot be assigned the same physiological contour solely by analogy.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "Demonstrates aortic contour diversity and reflection-related interpretation, but supplies no numeric cutoff for LV/RV roundness and does not justify reflection-like oscillation in this model.",
"locator": "Author-institution abstract; ascending aortic pressure waveform groups",
"observationMeaning": "Simultaneous ascending aortic pressure and flow; early versus late systolic pressure, not the model's ventricular central-range or peak-index fractions.",
"sourceId": "murgo-1980-human-aortic-waveforms",
"sourceRange": "Late greater than early in 7, nearly equal in 7, early greater than late in 4.",
"targetPopulation": "18 elective catheterization patients in whom no heart disease was found; not a population reference sample."
},
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The displayed contours vary, including a relatively flat upper limb (visual inference, not digitized statistics). No central-range, ejection peak-phase or PV-curvature normal interval was reported.",
"locator": "Methods; Tables 1 and 4; Figures 4-5, PDF pp. 6-7",
"observationMeaning": "Simultaneous Millar conductance-catheter LV pressure/volume sampled at 250 Hz; observed inter- and intra-subject PV contours.",
"sourceId": "kohli-2017-normalized-human-pv-loops",
"sourceRange": null,
"targetPopulation": "13 catheterization subjects selected for normal LV function, sinus rhythm and valves; 9 had hypertension. This is not a strictly healthy normative cohort."
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"changeReason": "Constrain the non-stenotic baseline while retaining the model's explicit pressure-station limitation.",
"checkIds": [
"aortic-valve.mean-gradient",
"aortic-valve.peak-gradient"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "construction-guard",
"evidenceGap": "No matching healthy-population source establishes the exact mean or peak cutoffs for these model pressure stations. Stenosis diagnostic thresholds would not validate them.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "aortic-valve-gradient",
"measurementMeaning": "Time-weighted mean and maximum raw LV-minus-Ao node pressure difference during native aortic forward flow.",
"observationLimitations": "This hydraulic node gradient is neither a Doppler Bernoulli gradient nor a simultaneous catheter LV-to-recovered-aortic pressure difference; pressure recovery and spatial acceleration are not observed.",
"sourceComparisons": [],
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"changeReason": "Prevent a gradient reduction obtained by implausibly shortening or prolonging ejection.",
"checkIds": [
"aortic-valve.ejection-time"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "physiological-target",
"evidenceGap": "The frozen construction interval is provisional. Similarity to the retrospective Copenhagen interval does not establish its historical derivation or cross-method validity.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "aortic-ejection-time",
"measurementMeaning": "Native AoV zero-flow opening to exact completed-beat closure; the observer requires agreement with the completed beat's accumulated positive-flow duration.",
"observationLimitations": "A single complete ejection episode is required. This hydraulic duration is shared with left ICT, IRT and Tei calculations, but is not color-TDI, Doppler-envelope or ECG timing; HR and population selection matter.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen interval is slightly broader at both endpoints; no observer-specific calibration has established equivalence.",
"locator": "Table 2; Methods, Cardiac time intervals",
"observationMeaning": "Color-TDI M-mode mitral-leaflet event timing; pooled 95% prediction intervals, not interchangeable with other Doppler or hydraulic event methods.",
"sourceId": "alhakak-2023-copenhagen-cardiac-time-intervals",
"sourceRange": "LVET 248-336 ms.",
"targetPopulation": "1,969 Danish adults without cardiovascular disease or risk factors; median age 46 (IQR 33-58) years, 61.5% women, HR 63 +/- 10/min."
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"changeReason": "Retain plausible contraction and relaxation rates while adjusting aortic ejection morphology.",
"checkIds": [
"left-ventricle.maximum-dpdt",
"left-ventricle.minimum-dpdt"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "reference-warning",
"evidenceGap": "The positive corridor overlaps small normal-LV patient series, but the frozen negative corridor excludes their resting means. Neither series supplies a population-normal acceptance interval; keep both corridors as warnings rather than validated pass/fail physiology.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "left-ventricular-pressure-rate",
"measurementMeaning": "Maximum and minimum accepted-step finite-difference derivative of absolute intracavitary LV pressure over the completed beat.",
"observationLimitations": "Accepted-step bandwidth, pressure loading, HR, preload, medication and catheter filtering affect extrema. Published negative dP/dt is often a positive magnitude, whereas this model stores a signed minimum; this is not a transmural derivative.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The positive mean lies within the frozen corridor; the signed negative mean does not. Exercise values cannot justify a resting cutoff.",
"locator": "Abstract; resting values before ergometer exercise",
"observationMeaning": "Invasive maximal LV pressure rise and pressure-fall magnitude; the accessible abstract does not fully establish acquisition bandwidth.",
"sourceId": "bussmann-1977-normal-lv-contractile-relaxation-reserve",
"sourceRange": "Resting maximum +1721 +/- 378 mmHg/s; negative magnitude 1862 +/- 343 mmHg/s (mean +/- SD).",
"targetPopulation": "13 patients described as having a normal LV; not a population-based, sex/age-stratified healthy sample."
},
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The frozen relaxation corridor excludes the control mean and much of the observed range. Means/SDs and observed extrema are context, not newly selected cutoffs.",
"locator": "Methods p. 757; normal-control table p. 759; abstract",
"observationMeaning": "Millar LV micromanometer and continuous differentiator; average of five sinus beats, after premedication.",
"sourceId": "hirota-1980-lv-relaxation",
"sourceRange": "Maximum +1674 +/- 421 mmHg/s; negative magnitude 1864 +/- 390 mmHg/s (observed negative-magnitude range 1275-2772).",
"targetPopulation": "18 normal controls including patients investigated for chest pain, murmurs or other indications; not a healthy population reference sample."
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"changeReason": "Retain the recorded corridor as context only: native volumetric E/A is not Doppler velocity E/A. Positive resolved waves remain required; no numeric widening or candidate-specific target change.",
"checkIds": [
"mitral-flow.peak-e-to-a"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "reference-warning",
"evidenceGap": "The fixed corridor is provisional, not an age-specific Doppler normal interval. Better event anchoring does not remove the flow-versus-velocity observation mismatch.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "mitral-e-to-a",
"measurementMeaning": "Ratio of peak native mitral forward volume flow in early and atrial filling windows anchored to the observed atrial-capture event.",
"observationLimitations": "Volume-flow peaks are not leaflet-tip Doppler velocities; varying effective valve area can change their ratio. A complete post-capture inlet closure and identifiable E/A windows are required, and age, rhythm, HR and loading affect interpretation.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen bounds truncate some healthy age-specific ranges and admit values outside others; numerical overlap cannot validate a native volume-flow ratio.",
"locator": "Tables 3 and 5 (p. 551)",
"observationMeaning": "PW Doppler mitral leaflet-tip E and A velocities, identified relative to ECG T and P waves; estimated fifth-to-95th percentiles.",
"sourceId": "nagueh-2025-lv-diastolic-function",
"sourceRange": "E/A: ages 20-39, 0.88-2.73; ages 40-60, 0.69-2.07; ages 60-80, 0.50-1.40.",
"targetPopulation": "Healthy reference data grouped by age; guideline echocardiographic assessment in adults, with age- and sex-aware supplementary data."
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"changeReason": "Demote method-mismatched ICT/IRT/Tei corridors to context; retain complete ordered hydraulic events, positivity and exact Tei arithmetic. ET remains an explicitly chosen baseline operating target, not proof of a population-normal timing pattern.",
"checkIds": [
"timing.ict",
"timing.irt",
"timing.tei-index"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "reference-warning",
"evidenceGap": "The intervals remain provisional hydraulic timing targets. Matching some published endpoints does not establish a measurement-equivalence study or historical source derivation.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "left-ventricular-timing",
"measurementMeaning": "ICT from exact MV closure to AoV zero-flow opening, IRT from exact AoV closure to MV zero-flow opening, and (ICT + IRT) divided by the matched aortic ejection duration.",
"observationLimitations": "Closure landmarks and trace-interpolated openings must describe one complete beat. Tei is algebraically linked to ICT, IRT and the separately checked ejection time, so these are not independent constraints.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "IRT and Tei endpoints match this pooled table, while the chosen ICT upper bound is wider. The source expressly limits generalization across measurement methods.",
"locator": "Table 2; Methods, Cardiac time intervals",
"observationMeaning": "Color-TDI M-mode mitral-leaflet event timing; pooled 95% prediction intervals, not interchangeable with other Doppler or hydraulic event methods.",
"sourceId": "alhakak-2023-copenhagen-cardiac-time-intervals",
"sourceRange": "IVCT 20-59 ms; IVRT 59-134 ms; MPI 0.29-0.65.",
"targetPopulation": "1,969 Danish adults without cardiovascular disease or risk factors; median age 46 (IQR 33-58) years, 61.5% women, HR 63 +/- 10/min."
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"changeReason": "Maintain broad resting systemic-pressure compatibility as a construction safety envelope.",
"checkIds": [
"aortic-pressure.maximum",
"aortic-pressure.minimum",
"central-venous-pressure.mean"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "physiological-target",
"evidenceGap": "No verified primary healthy central-aortic source establishes both chosen Ao ranges. The RA range is broader than the invasive reference below. All three are provisional resting construction targets.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "systemic-pressure",
"measurementMeaning": "Completed-beat extrema of absolute Ao root-compliance-node pressure and time-weighted mean absolute RA pressure; the active AoP display uses this same Ao node.",
"observationLimitations": "The lumped central Ao node has no arterial propagation, peripheral amplification or pressure recovery and is not a brachial cuff observation. RA pressure is intracavitary, not transmural; its beat mean does not reproduce end-expiratory catheter averaging or IVC-based RAP estimation.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen RA corridor is wider. A single illustrative arterial pressure cannot substantiate either Ao endpoint.",
"locator": "Table 11; section 5.1.12.1",
"observationMeaning": "Supine catheter pressure, mid-thoracic zero and end-expiratory reading; output by direct Fick or thermodilution.",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"sourceRange": "Mean RAP 2-6 mmHg; systemic systolic/diastolic pressure is illustrated as 120/80 mmHg, not a reference interval.",
"targetPopulation": "Adult resting right-heart catheterization reference values summarized by the guideline, not a new sex-, age-, or BSA-stratified healthy cohort."
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"changeReason": "Use broad resting pressure context as a sentinel while withholding a pulmonary-waveform validation claim.",
"checkIds": [
"pulmonary-artery-pressure.maximum",
"pulmonary-artery-pressure.minimum"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [
"mukherjee-ase-right-heart-2025"
],
"evaluationRole": "physiological-target",
"evidenceGap": "The chosen systolic and diastolic upper bounds are broader than both cited invasive references. This remains a provisional pressure envelope, not confirmation of normal PAP or pulmonary waveform shape.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "pulmonary-artery-pressure",
"measurementMeaning": "Extrema of absolute model PA root-node pressure over the exact completed beat.",
"observationLimitations": "This is an invasive-like lumped pressure signal, not TR-derived RVSP/PASP or a spatially resolved catheter waveform; respiratory reference and averaging differ. RVSP is not PASP when an RV-to-PA gradient is present.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen lower bounds match; the upper bounds are deliberately wider and are not the guideline's normal interval.",
"locator": "Table 11; section 5.1.12.1",
"observationMeaning": "Supine catheter pressure, mid-thoracic zero and end-expiratory reading; output by direct Fick or thermodilution.",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"sourceRange": "PAP systolic 15-30 mmHg; diastolic 4-12 mmHg.",
"targetPopulation": "Adult resting right-heart catheterization reference values summarized by the guideline, not a new sex-, age-, or BSA-stratified healthy cohort."
},
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "These distributions provide context but do not establish the chosen wider systolic and diastolic corridors.",
"locator": "Table 1; healthy resting supine catheterization data",
"observationMeaning": "Invasive resting supine PAP pooled across cohorts; mean +/- SD rather than a joint systolic/diastolic normal region.",
"sourceId": "kovacs-2009-healthy-pap-review",
"sourceRange": "Systolic 20.8 +/- 4.4 mmHg (upper limit 29.6); diastolic 8.8 +/- 3.0 mmHg.",
"targetPopulation": "47 studies, 1,187 healthy participants overall; resting supine systolic PAP available in 625, with heterogeneous age and sex representation."
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "literature-context-plus-engineering-envelope"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"changeReason": "Bound left-sided filling pressure while preserving the explicit station and measurement mismatch.",
"checkIds": [
"pcwp-surrogate.mean"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [
"kovacs-pawp-healthy-meta-2024"
],
"evaluationRole": "physiological-target",
"evidenceGap": "The chosen upper limit has healthy PAWP context, but the lower bound lacks an exact source and no observation study establishes this model's LA-mean-to-PAWP equivalence.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "pcwp-surrogate",
"measurementMeaning": "Time-weighted completed-beat mean absolute LA pressure, exposed only as a labelled PCWP surrogate.",
"observationLimitations": "Mean intracavitary LA pressure is not LVEDP, transmural LA pressure or an actual wedged-catheter observation. Wedge zero, respiratory sampling and transmission through the pulmonary circulation are not reproduced.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen upper limit matches the pooled upper limit, not every subgroup. The study does not establish the chosen lower limit or validate mean model LA pressure as a wedge observation.",
"locator": "Main results; individual-data and zero-reference subgroup analyses",
"observationMeaning": "Resting supine catheter PAWP, with heterogeneous zero references and respiratory conventions; significant sex differences.",
"sourceId": "zeder-2024-healthy-pawp-meta-analysis",
"sourceRange": "Pooled PAWP 9.4 +/- 1.82 mmHg; upper limit 13 mmHg (mid-thoracic-zero subgroup 12.2 mmHg).",
"targetPopulation": "960 mainly nonobese healthy participants from 49 studies; individual-data subset n=159, median age 26 (IQR 23-53), 67% men."
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "literature-context-plus-engineering-envelope"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"changeReason": "Create a deliberately broad cross-modality construction corridor rather than a joint population-normal claim.",
"checkIds": [
"left-ventricle.edv-index",
"left-ventricle.esv-index",
"left-ventricle.ejection-fraction"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [
"lang-ase-eacvi-2015",
"kou-norre-2014",
"cmr-consolidated-normal-reference-2016"
],
"evaluationRole": "physiological-target",
"evidenceGap": "The frozen corridor combines context across methods; its volume endpoints do not reproduce the cited echo or CMR intervals, and its independent marginal gates are not a joint healthy distribution.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "left-ventricular-indexed-size-function",
"measurementMeaning": "Valve-event-defined 0D LV volumes indexed to the reference BSA and their event-defined ejection fraction.",
"observationLimitations": "ED/ES are volumes at native inlet/outlet closure, not necessarily global extrema. Event definitions can align with imaging, but 0D cavity boundaries lack echo/CMR segmentation conventions. Fixed reference BSA does not select a sex/age cohort; EF is derived from the two volumes.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "Chosen EF is the sex-union; the volume corridor is not the sex-union and admits larger volumes.",
"locator": "Table 2 (p. 7); ED/ES definition (p. 6)",
"observationMeaning": "2D biplane LV volumes indexed to BSA; ED/ES may use valve events or cavity extrema; normal ranges based on mean +/- 2 SD.",
"sourceId": "lang-2015-chamber-quantification",
"sourceRange": "Men: EDVi 34-74, ESVi 11-31 mL/m2, EF 52-72%; women: 29-61, 8-24, 54-74%.",
"targetPopulation": "Adult sex-specific echocardiographic reference data."
},
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen volume and EF bounds are broader than these sex-specific intervals; the source does not support their exact endpoints.",
"locator": "Table 2, pp. 684-685",
"observationMeaning": "Biplane Simpson 2D echo, excluding papillary muscles and trabeculae from the cavity; BSA indexing does not remove age/sex effects.",
"sourceId": "kou-2014-norre-chamber-reference",
"sourceRange": "Men: EDVi 34.8-75.7, ESVi 11.7-28.8 mL/m2, EF 55.8-71.3%; women: 34.2-67.6, 10.5-25.9, 57.3-72.6%.",
"targetPopulation": "734 healthy adults (320 men, 414 women), age 45.8 +/- 13.3 years, predominantly white Europeans from 22 institutions."
},
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen corridor is not a CMR normal interval and can exclude source-normal EDVi or EF while admitting much lower volumes.",
"locator": "Table 2 (p. 2)",
"observationMeaning": "1.5 T SSFP CMR with LV papillary muscles included in mass; mean +/- 2 SD.",
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2015-cmr-normal-values",
"sourceRange": "Men: EDVi 57-105, ESVi 14-38 mL/m2, EF 57-77%; women: 56-96, 14-34, 57-77%.",
"targetPopulation": "Pooled adult European cohorts, ages 20-80 years; sex-specific results."
},
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "An updated, method-declared comparison, not support for the retained cross-modality endpoints or a demographic assignment to the synthetic model.",
"locator": "Sections 2-3; Table 2 (papillary muscles/trabeculations in mass)",
"observationMeaning": "Short-axis bSSFP anatomical cavity volumes; random-effects aggregation with reference-limit estimation. Myocardial tissue is excluded from the blood pool; imaging events and spatial segmentation are not reproduced by a 0D cavity.",
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2025-scmr-reference-values",
"sourceRange": "Men: EDVi 46-104, ESVi 11-41 mL/m2, EF 53-79%; women: 46-91, 11-34, 55-80%.",
"targetPopulation": "Pooled healthy adult CMR cohorts, sex-specific and mixed ages; not an age-40-49 or single joint population interval.",
"thresholdVerification": "context-only"
},
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "Retain both comparisons rather than selecting the sex that admits the candidate; no new gate or joint-95-percent normality claim.",
"locator": "Author website Table 37 (men) and Table 7 (women), 40-49-year column, LV rows",
"observationMeaning": "CMR anatomical segmentation, BSA-indexed volumes and EF; both ventricles can be compared in the same stratum without joining different modalities.",
"sourceId": "raisi-estabragh-2024-hhc-anatomical-tables",
"sourceRange": "Men: EDVi 51-102, ESVi 13-40 mL/m2, EF 53-77%; women: 49-88, 13-33, 56-78%.",
"targetPopulation": "Illustrative same-study White adults aged 40-49; variable-dependent N 378-447 men and 458-518 women. Neither stratum is assigned to the model.",
"thresholdVerification": "context-only"
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "literature-context-plus-engineering-envelope"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"changeReason": "Retain broad RV size/function safety bounds without extending the current systemic and left-heart claim.",
"checkIds": [
"right-ventricle.edv-index",
"right-ventricle.esv-index",
"right-ventricle.ejection-fraction"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [
"lang-ase-eacvi-2015-3de-rv"
],
"evaluationRole": "physiological-target",
"evidenceGap": "The volume bounds match a union of male/female 3D-echo ranges, not a population-specific or cross-modality range. The EF endpoints combine age/sex subgroup extremes rather than defining a single healthy cohort.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "right-ventricular-indexed-size-function",
"measurementMeaning": "Valve-event-defined 0D RV volumes indexed to the reference BSA and their event-defined ejection fraction.",
"observationLimitations": "Native TV/PV closure volumes and derived EF do not specify a 3D-echo or CMR segmentation method. BSA indexing alone does not remove sex/age effects; EF and the two event volumes are algebraically linked.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "Volume bounds reproduce the sex-union. EF bounds span subgroup extremes, not a universal normal range.",
"locator": "Table 8 (p. 20); Supplemental Table 8 (p. 39.e13)",
"observationMeaning": "3D-echo RV volume segmentation and BSA indexing; subgroup EF limits are fifth/95th percentiles.",
"sourceId": "lang-2015-chamber-quantification",
"sourceRange": "Men: EDVi 35-87, ESVi 10-44 mL/m2; women: 32-74, 8-36. Subgroup EF extremes include 42% and 82%; general RV EF below 45% is abnormal.",
"targetPopulation": "Adult sex-specific 3D-echo data; supplemental RV EF limits further stratified by age."
},
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "Chosen volume bounds exclude substantial CMR-normal values; the 3D-echo corridor cannot be called a broad cross-modality RV normal interval.",
"locator": "Table 6 (p. 7)",
"observationMeaning": "1.5 T SSFP CMR with RV trabeculations and papillary muscles in the cavity; mean +/- 2 SD.",
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2015-cmr-normal-values",
"sourceRange": "Men: EDVi 61-121, ESVi 19-59 mL/m2, EF 52-72%; women: 48-112, 12-52, 51-71%.",
"targetPopulation": "Healthy adult cohorts aged 20-68 years, sex-specific results; indexed RV ESV uses the Hudsmith cohort."
},
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "This uses the anatomical RV counterpart of the LV comparison. Do not substitute age-specific smooth-contour RV rows or retroactively replace old check bounds.",
"locator": "Sections 2 and 4; Table 8 (papillary muscles/trabeculations in mass), not smooth-segmentation Table 9",
"observationMeaning": "Short-axis bSSFP anatomical RV cavity volume with myocardial tissue excluded from blood volume; event, geometric and segmentation correspondence to 0D remains approximate.",
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2025-scmr-reference-values",
"sourceRange": "Men: EDVi 49-117, ESVi 12-56 mL/m2, EF 44-77%; women: 47-99, 11-43, 49-77%.",
"targetPopulation": "Pooled healthy adult CMR cohorts, sex-specific and mixed ages. Constituent cohorts differ from LV Table 2; marginal limits do not define a joint healthy subject.",
"thresholdVerification": "context-only"
},
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "Provides a coherent same-study alternative for future prospective design. BSA1.9 alone does not select either column, and the current upper EDVi bound is not verified by this study.",
"locator": "Author website Table 37 (men) and Table 7 (women), 40-49-year column, RV rows",
"observationMeaning": "CMR anatomical segmentation and BSA indexation, same subject strata and measurement convention as the LV comparison.",
"sourceId": "raisi-estabragh-2024-hhc-anatomical-tables",
"sourceRange": "Men: EDVi 61-118, ESVi 21-55 mL/m2, EF 44-71%; women: 53-97, 17-42, 49-73%.",
"targetPopulation": "Illustrative same-study White adults aged 40-49; variable-dependent N 378-447 men and 458-518 women. Neither stratum is assigned to the model.",
"thresholdVerification": "context-only"
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "literature-context-plus-engineering-envelope"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "objective",
"changeReason": "Maintain broad resting forward-flow compatibility across the admitted HR values.",
"checkIds": [
"systemic-forward-flow.cardiac-index",
"systemic-forward-flow.stroke-volume-index"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [
"cardiac-index-clinical-reference",
"resting-indexed-flow-reference"
],
"evaluationRole": "physiological-target",
"evidenceGap": "CI has an exact guideline interval, but SVI is a cross-source construction choice. The retained Barratt-Boyes binding was metadata-verified only and does not provide a verified quantitative derivation here.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "indexed-systemic-forward-flow",
"measurementMeaning": "Positive-only native AoV flow integrated for stroke volume and converted to cardiac output over the completed beat, both indexed to reference BSA.",
"observationLimitations": "Forward volume is not signed net aortic flow or EDV-minus-ESV when regurgitation or other routes exist. CI and SVI are linked by HR, so at a fixed HR they are not independent targets; reference BSA and body habitus remain relevant.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "CI endpoints match exactly; SVI endpoints do not. Fick/thermodilution output is not necessarily the model's positive-only valve-flow output.",
"locator": "Table 11; section 5.1.12.1",
"observationMeaning": "Supine catheter pressure, mid-thoracic zero and end-expiratory reading; output by direct Fick or thermodilution.",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"sourceRange": "CI 2.5-4.0 L/min/m2; SVI 33-47 mL/m2.",
"targetPopulation": "Adult resting right-heart catheterization reference values summarized by the guideline, not a new sex-, age-, or BSA-stratified healthy cohort."
},
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen SVI interval is close to, but not identical to, a calculated mean +/- 2 SD interval of 37-65. Such a calculation is not a published universal normal cutoff.",
"coveredCheckIds": [
"systemic-forward-flow.cardiac-index",
"systemic-forward-flow.stroke-volume-index"
],
"locator": "Methods; healthy-group results and age analysis",
"observationMeaning": "Supine free-breathing ascending-aortic phase-contrast CMR at pulmonary-bifurcation level, distal to coronary origins; signed whole-cycle flow integrated for SV, Mosteller BSA. The paper attributes expected Qp/Qs around 1.04 to coronary flow of 3-5 percent, so absence of regurgitation alone does not equate this plane to native AoV output.",
"sourceId": "carlsson-2012-cmr-cardiac-output",
"sourceRange": "CI 3.2 +/- 0.5 L/min/m2; SVI 51 +/- 7 mL/m2 (mean +/- SD).",
"targetPopulation": "144 healthy nonathletic adults, 68 women, ages 21-81 (mean 39 +/- 16) years; BMI <=30, no cardiovascular disease or medication.",
"thresholdRationale": "Methods and healthy-group results checked in full text on 2026-09-06. These are cohort summaries, not direct verification of the retained construction endpoints; passage verification alone must not qualify those endpoints.",
"thresholdVerification": "context-only"
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "literature-context-plus-engineering-envelope"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "right-heart-sentinel",
"changeReason": "Record the existing Standard70 right-heart gradient sentinels without promoting them to left-objective groups or changing their numerical limits.",
"checkIds": [
"pulmonary-valve.mean-gradient",
"pulmonary-valve.peak-gradient"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "construction-guard",
"evidenceGap": "No source establishes the exact mean and peak healthy cutoffs for these pressure stations. These remain non-stenotic construction guards, not clinical normal-gradient intervals.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "pulmonary-valve-gradient",
"measurementMeaning": "Time-weighted mean and maximum raw RV-minus-PA node pressure difference while native PV flow is positive over the completed beat.",
"observationLimitations": "The model's hydraulic gradient is not a Doppler Bernoulli or recovered catheter gradient; an explicit outlet node does not provide spatial velocity, pressure recovery or an invasive sensor model.",
"sourceComparisons": [],
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "right-heart-sentinel",
"changeReason": "Record the existing Standard70 pulmonary ejection-time corridor with its missing method-matched normative evidence.",
"checkIds": [
"pulmonary-valve.ejection-time"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "physiological-target",
"evidenceGap": "No exact primary normal interval was identified for this observer and target population. Retain the frozen interval only as a provisional physiological target; left-sided LVET data do not establish a right-sided range.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "pulmonary-ejection-time",
"measurementMeaning": "Native PV zero-flow opening to exact completed-beat closure; the observer requires agreement with the completed beat's accumulated positive-flow duration.",
"observationLimitations": "A complete single ejection episode is required. This duration also enters right ICT, IRT and Tei calculations; hydraulic timing is not a Doppler-envelope or tissue-Doppler measurement and depends on HR/loading.",
"sourceComparisons": [],
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "right-heart-sentinel",
"changeReason": "Reclassify the existing Standard70 RV derivative corridors as reference warnings without altering the recorded numerical bounds.",
"checkIds": [
"right-ventricle.maximum-dpdt",
"right-ventricle.minimum-dpdt"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "reference-warning",
"evidenceGap": "No verified source establishes either frozen normal corridor. Sparse normal-PAP invasive data and a method-specific abnormal Doppler threshold justify contextual warnings, not hard healthy-population acceptance limits.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "right-ventricular-pressure-rate",
"measurementMeaning": "Maximum and minimum accepted-step finite-difference derivative of absolute intracavitary RV pressure over the completed beat.",
"observationLimitations": "These load- and bandwidth-dependent extrema are neither transmural pressure derivatives nor the mean RV-to-RA pressure-gradient rise inferred over a selected TR velocity interval. Signed negative extrema must not be confused with published pressure-fall magnitudes.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "This is not the maximum native intracavitary derivative and does not establish either chosen endpoint or a normal upper limit.",
"locator": "RV dP/dt section, pp. 158-159",
"observationMeaning": "TR Doppler 1-to-2 m/s upslope converted to a 12 mmHg pressure-gradient rise divided by time.",
"sourceId": "mukherjee-2025-right-heart-guideline",
"sourceRange": "RV dP/dt below 400 mmHg/s is abnormal for this Doppler method.",
"targetPopulation": "Adult right-heart echocardiography; normal-reference data are limited."
},
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "Both loading groups can fit the broad signed negative corridor. The reported summary values are not a healthy reference interval and cannot define its bounds.",
"locator": "Abstract; normal-PAP and pulmonary-hypertension groups",
"observationMeaning": "Maximal invasive RV pressure-fall magnitude; strong pressure-load dependence, with acquisition detail incompletely resolved by the abstract.",
"sourceId": "stein-1980-rv-pressure-fall",
"sourceRange": "Normal-PAP group 170 +/- 20 mmHg/s; pulmonary-hypertension groups 670 +/- 60 mmHg/s, with or without RV failure.",
"targetPopulation": "34 patients: eight with normal PAP, 17 with pulmonary hypertension, nine with pulmonary hypertension and RV failure; not a general healthy reference cohort."
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "right-heart-sentinel",
"changeReason": "Demote the native tricuspid flow-ratio corridor to context because Doppler velocity and respiratory averaging are different observations; resolved positive filling waves remain required.",
"checkIds": [
"tricuspid-flow.peak-e-to-a"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "reference-warning",
"evidenceGap": "The numerical corridor resembles a guideline Doppler interval but remains provisional for the native-flow observer; the source upper endpoint is exclusive whereas the frozen gate is inclusive.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "tricuspid-e-to-a",
"measurementMeaning": "Ratio of peak native tricuspid forward volume flow in early and atrial filling windows anchored to the observed atrial-capture event.",
"observationLimitations": "Requires identifiable windows and an observed post-capture inlet closure. Volume-flow peaks do not equal Doppler velocities if effective valve area changes; respiration, HR, rhythm, age and loading remain relevant.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen numeric endpoints match, but flow-versus-velocity and respiratory averaging differ; this is not method-matched validation.",
"locator": "Table 1; RV diastolic function, pp. 168-169",
"observationMeaning": "PW tricuspid inflow E/A velocities; end-expiratory averaging over at least five beats.",
"sourceId": "mukherjee-2025-right-heart-guideline",
"sourceRange": "Tricuspid E/A >=0.8 and <2.0.",
"targetPopulation": "Adult echocardiographic reference context."
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "right-heart-sentinel",
"changeReason": "Demote the unsupported hydraulic right ICT/IRT/Tei numeric corridors to context. Ordered complete valve events and algebraic consistency remain mandatory; a short RV isovolumic phase is not automatically pathological.",
"checkIds": [
"right-timing.ict",
"right-timing.irt",
"right-timing.tei-index"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "reference-warning",
"evidenceGap": "No primary source was identified for the chosen joint ICT/IRT/Tei corridors. The source below supplies method-specific context, not equivalent normal intervals; all three remain provisional physiological targets.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "right-ventricular-timing",
"measurementMeaning": "ICT from exact TV closure to PV zero-flow opening, IRT from exact PV closure to TV zero-flow opening, and (ICT + IRT) divided by the matched pulmonary ejection duration.",
"observationLimitations": "One complete valve-event sequence is required. Tei is algebraically linked to ICT, IRT and the separately checked pulmonary ET; PW-Doppler, TDI and hydraulic timings are different observations.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "The chosen upper IRT and Tei bounds are wider, and no chosen lower bound or ICT interval follows from these thresholds.",
"locator": "RV MPI, pp. 158-159; IVRT, pp. 168-169",
"observationMeaning": "PW-Doppler or tissue-Doppler MPI and tissue-Doppler IVRT, not native valve-flow events.",
"sourceId": "mukherjee-2025-right-heart-guideline",
"sourceRange": "MPI <0.40 by PW Doppler or <0.55 by TDI; IVRT <=73 ms by TDI.",
"targetPopulation": "Adult right-heart echocardiography."
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess"
},
{
"analysisPartition": "right-heart-sentinel",
"changeReason": "Record Standard70 pulmonary ringing and re-ejection guards as construction-only waveform criteria.",
"checkIds": [
"waveform.PAP.single-peak-no-ringing",
"waveform.PV-flow.single-forward-episode",
"waveform.PV-flow.single-peak-no-ringing",
"waveform.PAP.post-PV-closure-rebound"
],
"contextEvidenceIds": [],
"evaluationRole": "construction-guard",
"evidenceGap": "No primary normal distribution supports the exact one-peak, one-episode or rebound cutoffs. A qualitative Doppler flow shape must not be cited as proof of these pressure-waveform thresholds.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"groupId": "pulmonary-root-morphology",
"measurementMeaning": "Algorithmic full-cycle PA pressure peak count, thresholded PV forward-episode count, primary-episode PV flow peak count and maximal post-episode PA rebound.",
"observationLimitations": "The episode threshold and peak-prominence algorithm define these observations; the post-episode rebound is not an invasive dicrotic-notch metric. One peak does not characterize the entire pressure or flow contour.",
"sourceComparisons": [
{
"comparisonToChosenBounds": "Qualitative flow context only; it establishes no peak-prominence, PAP peak-count or post-PV-closure rebound cutoff.",
"locator": "RVOT Doppler flow, p. 158",
"observationMeaning": "Qualitative RVOT Doppler velocity waveform: parabolic with a midsystolic peak.",
"sourceId": "mukherjee-2025-right-heart-guideline",
"sourceRange": null,
"targetPopulation": "Adult resting right-heart echocardiography."
}
],
"thresholdBasis": "engineering-guess"
}
],
"claimScope": {
"currentBaselineEvidenceRole": "construction",
"finalConfirmationStatus": "unavailable",
"reason": "Standard68/69 gates, Standard69 preload-reserve floors, and candidate outputs were inspected during model construction; no lineage-disjoint final evidence set has been frozen."
},
"evaluationPolicyId": "main-wire-standard70-baseline-evaluation-roles-v3",
"evidenceBindings": [
{
"canonicalSourceIds": [
"lang-2015-chamber-quantification"
],
"evidenceId": "lang-ase-eacvi-2015",
"limitations": "Modality-, sex-, age-, and body-size-dependent reference context; it does not directly define this model's joint admissible interval.",
"measurementMeaning": "Adult echocardiographic LV chamber volumes and systolic function.",
"useRole": "construction-context"
},
{
"canonicalSourceIds": [
"kou-2014-norre-chamber-reference"
],
"evidenceId": "kou-norre-2014",
"limitations": "The cohort and measurement method do not identify a unique 0D-model parameter vector or a joint multivariate normal region.",
"measurementMeaning": "Two-dimensional echocardiographic adult chamber-size reference ranges.",
"useRole": "construction-context"
},
{
"canonicalSourceIds": [
"kawel-boehm-2015-cmr-normal-values"
],
"evidenceId": "cmr-consolidated-normal-reference-2016",
"limitations": "The retained legacy evidence ID has a 2016 label but resolves to the 2015 publication; CMR and echocardiographic volumes are not interchangeable without a measurement model.",
"measurementMeaning": "CMR chamber-volume and function reference context across published cohorts.",
"useRole": "construction-context"
},
{
"canonicalSourceIds": [
"lang-2015-chamber-quantification"
],
"evidenceId": "lang-ase-eacvi-2015-3de-rv",
"limitations": "A 0D chamber volume is compared only as broad construction context; acquisition and segmentation conventions remain different.",
"measurementMeaning": "Adult three-dimensional echocardiographic RV volumes and ejection fraction.",
"useRole": "construction-context"
},
{
"canonicalSourceIds": [
"carlsson-2012-cmr-cardiac-output",
"barratt-boyes-wood-1958-healthy-hemodynamics"
],
"evidenceId": "cardiac-index-clinical-reference",
"limitations": "The model interval is an engineering synthesis across methods and cohorts, not a verbatim interval from either source.",
"measurementMeaning": "Resting forward cardiac output indexed to body surface area.",
"useRole": "construction-context"
},
{
"canonicalSourceIds": [
"carlsson-2012-cmr-cardiac-output",
"barratt-boyes-wood-1958-healthy-hemodynamics"
],
"evidenceId": "resting-indexed-flow-reference",
"limitations": "Stroke-volume index depends on heart rate, body-size convention, cohort, and acquisition method; the gate is a broad engineering envelope.",
"measurementMeaning": "Resting systemic forward stroke volume indexed to body surface area.",
"useRole": "construction-context"
},
{
"canonicalSourceIds": [
"mukherjee-2025-right-heart-guideline",
"kovacs-2009-healthy-pap-review"
],
"evidenceId": "mukherjee-ase-right-heart-2025",
"limitations": "This does not directly support the exact 10-35 mmHg model interval or validate the current pulmonary waveform shape.",
"measurementMeaning": "Right-heart echocardiographic assessment and healthy pulmonary arterial pressure context.",
"useRole": "construction-context"
},
{
"canonicalSourceIds": [
"zeder-2024-healthy-pawp-meta-analysis"
],
"evidenceId": "kovacs-pawp-healthy-meta-2024",
"limitations": "The retained legacy evidence ID uses the last author's name; the model reports mean LA pressure, not a simulated wedged-catheter measurement.",
"measurementMeaning": "Supine resting pulmonary arterial wedge pressure in healthy subjects.",
"useRole": "construction-context"
}
],
"observationMethodId": "main-wire-baseline-observation-v2",
"operatingTargetInterpretation": "Retained ET, pressures, indexed size, EF, CI and SVI are predeclared resting-baseline design targets. Failure means the intended operating point was not met, not physiological impossibility. Their source-specific observation limitations remain binding; no cross-modality universal normality is claimed.",
"policyRevisions": [
{
"changeReason": "Capture the current Standard68 mint policy and healthy-reference context after retrospective provenance repair.",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"policySha256": "74f5b1ca712b56f304fee1ccf20da3e9dee8c7102213a2cb60dc2e7701cf3356",
"revisionId": "main-wire-standard68-baseline-policy-r1"
}
],
"preloadReservePolicyRevisions": [
{
"changeReason": "Freeze the Standard69-specific relative CO, pressure-flow slope, and relative EDV floors after exploratory candidate inspection. These are construction-only non-regression thresholds, not independently validated physiological cutoffs.",
"decisionTiming": "post-hoc-after-exploratory-candidate-inspection",
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"policySha256": "dec7d6cdf587522c67892f0f94c910a2a8871a1aada6620c1a8778869109f4d5",
"revisionId": "main-wire-standard69-preload-reserve-policy-r1"
}
],
"referenceSubjectInterpretation": "BSA 1.9 m2 and sex-neutral synthetic anatomy do not identify age, sex or ethnicity. Conserved cavity blood volume is conceptually closer to anatomical segmentation excluding myocardial tissue from the blood pool than to smooth-contour volume that includes that tissue. This is an operator comparison, not a validated imaging-equivalence claim or permission to select the cohort that passes a candidate.",
"registryId": "main-wire-normal-reference-evidence-v1",
"schemaVersion": 1,
"sourceComparisonTiming": "retrospective-provenance-audit-not-original-cutoff-derivation",
"sources": [
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1093/eurheartj/ehu293"
},
"sourceId": "herbert-2014-central-pressure-reference",
"title": "Establishing reference values for central blood pressure and its amplification in a general healthy population and according to cardiovascular risk factors",
"url": "https://academic.oup.com/eurheartj/article/35/44/3122/2293191",
"verification": "primary-full-text-methods-and-results-checked",
"verificationScope": "Methods, Standardizing methodologies, and Tables 1-2 checked on 2026-09-07. Cuff-calibrated noninvasive cSBP differs from invasive intra-aortic pressure; Table 2 gives P10/P90, not 95% normal limits. Does not verify retained Ao-node bounds.",
"year": 2014
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1093/oxfordjournals.eurheartj.a062515",
"pmid": "3383877"
},
"sourceId": "van-oort-1988-pulmonary-doppler",
"title": "Reference values for pulsed Doppler signals from the blood flow velocity on both sides of the pulmonary valve",
"url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/3383877/",
"verification": "primary-abstract-population-and-method-checked-not-full-text",
"verificationScope": "215 healthy subjects aged 1-65; pulmonary artery and RVOT Doppler measurements. Adult ejection-time limits not verified; acceleration time or LV timing is not substituted.",
"year": 1988
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1161/01.CIR.62.1.105",
"pmid": "7379273"
},
"sourceId": "murgo-1980-human-aortic-waveforms",
"title": "Aortic input impedance in normal man: relationship to pressure wave forms",
"url": "https://scholars.uthscsa.edu/es/publications/aortic-input-impedance-in-normal-man-relationship-to-pressure-wav/",
"verification": "author-institution-abstract-checked-not-full-text",
"year": 1980
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.14814/phy2.13160",
"pmid": "28351966"
},
"sourceId": "kohli-2017-normalized-human-pv-loops",
"title": "The quest for load-independent left ventricular chamber properties: exploring the normalized pressure-volume loop",
"url": "https://physoc.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.14814/phy2.13160",
"verification": "primary-full-text-methods-and-figures-4-5-checked",
"year": 2017
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1016/j.echo.2014.10.003",
"pmid": "25559473"
},
"sourceId": "lang-2015-chamber-quantification",
"title": "Recommendations for Cardiac Chamber Quantification by Echocardiography in Adults: An Update from the American Society of Echocardiography and the European Association of Cardiovascular Imaging",
"url": "https://www.asecho.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/02/2015_ChamberQuantificationREV.pdf",
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"year": 2015
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1093/ehjci/jet284",
"pmid": "24451180"
},
"sourceId": "kou-2014-norre-chamber-reference",
"title": "Echocardiographic reference ranges for normal cardiac chamber size: results from the NORRE study",
"url": "https://orbi.uliege.be/bitstream/2268/169431/1/Eur%20Heart%20J%20Cardiovasc%20Imaging-2014-Kou-680-90.pdf",
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"year": 2014
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1186/s12968-015-0111-7",
"pmid": "25928314"
},
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2015-cmr-normal-values",
"title": "Normal values for cardiovascular magnetic resonance in adults and children",
"url": "https://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1186/s12968-015-0111-7.pdf",
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"year": 2015
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1186/1532-429X-14-51",
"pmid": "22839436"
},
"sourceId": "carlsson-2012-cmr-cardiac-output",
"title": "Cardiac output and cardiac index measured with cardiovascular magnetic resonance in healthy subjects, elite athletes and patients with congestive heart failure",
"url": "https://link.springer.com/article/10.1186/1532-429X-14-51",
"verification": "primary-full-text-methods-and-results-checked",
"year": 2012
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1016/j.jocmr.2025.101853",
"pmcid": "PMC12159681"
},
"sourceId": "kawel-boehm-2025-scmr-reference-values",
"title": "Society for Cardiovascular Magnetic Resonance reference values (normal values) in cardiovascular magnetic resonance: 2025 update",
"url": "https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12159681/",
"verification": "primary-full-text-methods-and-results-checked",
"verificationScope": "Sections 2-4 and Tables 2, 3, 8, 9; anatomical versus smooth segmentation and pooled adult sex-specific intervals. No current gate endpoints are verified by this source comparison.",
"year": 2025
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1016/j.jcmg.2024.01.009",
"pmid": "38613554"
},
"sourceId": "raisi-estabragh-2024-hhc-anatomical-tables",
"title": "Cardiovascular Magnetic Resonance Reference Ranges From the Healthy Hearts Consortium: author-published anatomical segmentation tables",
"url": "https://healthy-hearts.org.uk/tables/",
"verification": "author-published-tables-7-and-37-checked-not-full-article",
"verificationScope": "Full one-page source PDFs visually checked, including headers, age columns, units and N ranges. White men and women aged 40-49 are parallel illustrative comparisons, not the declared model subject or a new gate.",
"year": 2024
},
{
"identifiers": {
"pmid": "13514210"
},
"sourceId": "barratt-boyes-wood-1958-healthy-hemodynamics",
"title": "Cardiac output and related measurements and pressure values in the right heart and associated vessels, together with an analysis of the hemo-dynamic response to the inhalation of high oxygen mixtures in healthy subjects",
"url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/13514210/",
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"year": 1958
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1016/j.echo.2025.01.006",
"pmid": "40044341"
},
"sourceId": "mukherjee-2025-right-heart-guideline",
"title": "Guidelines for the Echocardiographic Assessment of the Right Heart in Adults and Special Considerations in Pulmonary Hypertension: Recommendations from the American Society of Echocardiography",
"url": "https://www.asecho.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/PIIS0894731725000379.pdf",
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"year": 2025
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1183/09031936.00145608"
},
"sourceId": "kovacs-2009-healthy-pap-review",
"title": "Pulmonary arterial pressure during rest and exercise in healthy subjects: a systematic review",
"url": "https://publications.ersnet.org/highwire_display/entity_view/node/476971/full",
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"year": 2009
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1183/13993003.00967-2024",
"pmid": "38964777"
},
"sourceId": "zeder-2024-healthy-pawp-meta-analysis",
"title": "Pulmonary arterial wedge pressure in healthy subjects: a meta-analysis",
"url": "https://publications.ersnet.org/content/erj/64/2/2400967",
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"year": 2024
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1183/13993003.00879-2022",
"pmid": "36028254"
},
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"title": "2022 ESC/ERS Guidelines for the diagnosis and treatment of pulmonary hypertension",
"url": "https://publications.ersnet.org/lookup/pmid/36028254",
"verification": "primary-table-11-and-rhc-methods-checked",
"verificationScope": "Table 11 and section 5.1.12.1, European Heart Journal pp. 3646-3647. Passage verification does not establish the model operator mapping or support wider retained pressure bounds.",
"year": 2022
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1007/s00392-023-02269-2"
},
"sourceId": "alhakak-2023-copenhagen-cardiac-time-intervals",
"title": "Age- and sex-based normal reference ranges of the cardiac time intervals: the Copenhagen City Heart Study",
"url": "https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00392-023-02269-2",
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"year": 2023
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1016/j.echo.2025.03.011"
},
"sourceId": "nagueh-2025-lv-diastolic-function",
"title": "Recommendations for the Evaluation of Left Ventricular Diastolic Function by Echocardiography and for Heart Failure With Preserved Ejection Fraction Diagnosis: An Update From the American Society of Echocardiography",
"url": "https://www.asecho.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/07/Left-Ventricular-Diastolic-Function.pdf",
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"year": 2025
},
{
"identifiers": {
"pmid": "602351"
},
"sourceId": "bussmann-1977-normal-lv-contractile-relaxation-reserve",
"title": "Contractile and relaxation reserve of the left ventricle. I. Normal left ventricle",
"url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/602351/",
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"year": 1977
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1161/01.cir.62.4.756",
"pmid": "7190882"
},
"sourceId": "hirota-1980-lv-relaxation",
"title": "A clinical study of left ventricular relaxation",
"url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7190882/",
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"year": 1980
},
{
"identifiers": {
"doi": "10.1378/chest.78.1.10",
"pmid": "7471826"
},
"sourceId": "stein-1980-rv-pressure-fall",
"title": "Effect of chronic pressure overload on the maximal rate of pressure fall of the right ventricle",
"url": "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7471826/",
"verification": "primary-source-metadata-checked",
"year": 1980
}
],
"supplementalChecks": [
{
"boundRationale": "ASE 2025 section 2/Table 1 calls >48 ms prolonged. Contextual warning only, no arbitrary normal lower bound and no transfer of that threshold to Glantz. Hirota reports 33 +/- 8 ms in 18 selected controls, using P0 / peak negative dP/dt, not this fitted observer; that cohort is not a normal interval.",
"checkId": "left-ventricle.relaxation-tau",
"evaluationRole": "reference-warning",
"measurementMeaning": "Intracavitary LV Weiss zero-asymptote time-weighted log-pressure fit, from minimum dP/dt interval midpoint after AVC to next EDP + 5 mmHg before MVO; Glantz derivative-pressure free-asymptote sensitivity fit reported separately.",
"observationMethodId": "main-wire-lv-relaxation-tau-v1",
"qualityRationale": "Minimum window support and regression/residual limits are explicit provisional numerical fit-usability settings, not empirically established physiological limits. Both fits and the extrapolated Glantz pressure asymptote remain visible; neither may be selected for being closer to a target.",
"referenceSourceIds": [
"nagueh-2025-lv-diastolic-function",
"hirota-1980-lv-relaxation"
],
"referenceUpperMs": 48,
"requiredObservation": "Prospective v3 baseline assessment must contain an interpretable tau observation; unavailable or poor fit is unresolved analysis, not normality and not a disease diagnosis."
}
]
},
"policy": {
"anatomyRule": "For this sex-unspecified generic baseline only, automatic eligibility requires all six valid anatomical CMR comparisons inside BOTH declared sex strata. Otherwise require demographic/method review, not automatic disease rejection. This conservative design intersection does not assign sex or claim joint population normality; preset/patient fitting must use its own profile.",
"loadGuardRationale": "Keep a baseline away from low/high systemic load and high native end-filling pressure. Ao bounds are retained design choices, not derived from Herbert. LV native flow cessation may precede the pressure upstroke; <=16 is an approximate end-filling design ceiling, not validated catheter LVEDP equivalence or a lower normal limit.",
"numericalAndConstructionProvenance": "Inherited numerical/gradient/ringing checks resolve their existing per-check evidence; new rest criteria do not reinterpret the old physiological corridors or clear the old provenance audit.",
"operating": [
{
"basis": "source-informed-operating-target",
"locator": "Table 11, CI",
"lower": 2.5,
"metricId": "systemic-net-flow.cardiac-index",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"upper": 4
},
{
"basis": "source-informed-operating-target",
"locator": "Table 11, mean RAP",
"lower": 2,
"metricId": "central-venous-pressure.mean",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"upper": 6
},
{
"basis": "source-informed-operating-target",
"locator": "Table 11, mean PAP",
"lower": 8,
"metricId": "pulmonary-artery-pressure.mean",
"sourceId": "humbert-2022-esc-ers-pulmonary-hypertension",
"upper": 20
},
{
"basis": "retained-engineering-load-guard-NOT-source-derived-normal-range",
"locator": "Methods, invasive versus cuff-calibrated pressure distinction",
"lower": 90,
"metricId": "aortic-pressure.maximum",
"sourceId": "herbert-2014-central-pressure-reference",
"upper": 140
},
{
"basis": "retained-engineering-load-guard-NOT-source-derived-normal-range",
"locator": "Methods, DBP calibration; no central-DBP reference interval",
"lower": 60,
"metricId": "aortic-pressure.minimum",
"sourceId": "herbert-2014-central-pressure-reference",
"upper": 90
},
{
"basis": "source-informed-engineering-load-guard-NOT-method-matched-normal-range",
"locator": "Section2, Table1 p539 (>16), Figure1 p540",
"lower": null,
"metricId": "left-ventricle.native-end-filling-pressure",
"sourceId": "nagueh-2025-lv-diastolic-function",
"upper": 16
}
],
"policyId": "main-wire-prospective-baseline-admission-v1",
"regression": "__tests__/mainWireProspectiveBaselineAdmissionV1.test.ts",
"scope": "Resting unassisted nonshunting sinus research construction, BSA1.9, HR60 or70, zero intrathoracic reference. Scientific eligibility for exact-model promotion, not public mint or clinical normality.",
"warningRule": "Keep strict source comparisons for phasic PAP, ET, anatomy and SVI plus historical timing/E-A/dPdt/roundness context. A warning never excuses missing, nonfinite or invalid observations. Preserve unexplained ringing/closure-rebound construction holds; pressure-peak phase and PV roundness are not universal normality gates."
}
},
"methodId": "main-wire-baseline-observation-v2",
"reference": {
"clinicalValidationClaimed": false,
"evidenceRole": "construction",
"label": "baseline",
"referenceId": "baseline",
"target": {
"admissionPolicyId": "main-wire-prospective-baseline-admission-v1",
"comparisonProfileId": "main-wire-resting-reference-profile-v1",
"evaluationRolePolicyId": "main-wire-standard70-baseline-evaluation-roles-v3",
"evidenceRegistryId": "main-wire-normal-reference-evidence-v1",
"kind": "construction-corridors",
"referenceOutputsAreTargets": false
}
}
}
}
]This document records the case assessment and its measurement-time Surface. Validation of ESPVR, EDPVR, PVA and presentation under a later Surface is separate. Historical passive-mechanics tests are not relabelled as fresh successes.